xtqd lr l"f al 'text ixacl daebz "lecb ly elecib" zexrde zeaebz

Podobne dokumenty
zihxwqic dwihnzna ziteq dpiga

ly eileblb :xnh`q 'minkgl cre zia' uaew xecd iwa`n rwx lr i`pw zrîazk

ilnxkd lape cec ` zekfaxwiraxekfwxtd.ilnxkdlapececdyrnawqer`"nyxtqadkwxt `iandidydyrnncecz`e,ceclyeqrkndlraz`dlivdy,libia`lydznkg

SUPPLEMENT. IS THE devn OF xtey TO HEAR xtey OR TO BLOW xtey A DISCUSSION BY RABBI BAKSHI-DORON, CHIEF SEPHARDIC RABBI OF ISRAEL

d wxt hk oniq b wlg xfril` uiv z"ey.eixg` eipale el eiepina wifgdl dxxy wifgnle qpxtl dwfg yi m`

m"anxd it lr dkepgd ini zernyn

gqt oaxw zaxwd onf lr crend leg zyecw lre

e` 'gn :dhlewt my :ihxt

l`xyi ux` zxez :zekxa 'dkld ipipt' xtq

zegiy ihewl zegiy ihewl jzelrda od`qxe`ipy מליובאוויטש od`qxe`ipy vf,uc, kvahd vahju, cthbyrby: kghkuh ban, rw hvusv c"r mch vhra g"v xyrtk

ceqid oxwl wew d"i`xd ly eqgi

:oetlh xtqnl zeptl `p qxhpewd ipipr lkl (416) :liin-i`a e` dgnya dplawzz zexrd

zegiy ihewl uwn lcprnmgpnx"enc` jzelrda bk k wlg zegiy ihewl ly zegiyd itl caerne mbxezn (iytg mebxz) vuxpv q caur, vdtukv od`qxe`ipy מליובאוויטש

gqta ond ziilzl xewnd

lhinr l`ei axd oia n"en l"pd oipra iwvaliq l`xyi mdxa` axd oial

תשובות לקושיות על התכלאל "עץ חיים" החדש [ח"א]

mixa` g"nx qxhpew a wlg,zeny yneg lr

(` `) dlibn zeklda m"anxa zex`de mixexia

SUPPLEMENT. milwy zyxt zayl

zkxrna elawzp mdizegxe`,fpky` inkg ly mzxezl dpy xtq.d"ryzd.epzyexi zqpkd zia ibdpn gel llek.zexiwqe mixwgn,zepexkfe zexeqn,mdibdpne

zxeqne zepin` il`xa l`ix` axd dncwd

'l`xyi za zxdh' xtq lr

zaya xf` zcled xeqi` lr l"vf jaxrie` f"yxbd ly ezpyna

SUPPLEMENT. xekf zyxt zayl

zegiy ihewl b glya lcprnmgpnx"enc` jzelrda

o"xl qgeind dxezd xtq oiipra cer dketd c"eia i"cvde

Wednesday 18 May 2016 Morning Time allowed: 45 minutes approximately + 5 minutes reading time before the test

zkxrna elawzp ,obznxemilyexi.wilbl`eny.a-`mikxk.q"yzzpycreqetcdziy`xn ( ).f"qyz-e"qyz

ipxcen'yexeeyg`'- izlii`

milyexia qpit n"ix lr mxgd oncixt cec iax eqib mr eixywe

?"il` 'dl in" edizzn xn` ok` m`d

ipy wxt,c"qa `n sc iepind zrya meiw icr jixv dfay,dkledl zegilye dlawl zegily oia wlgny (`"ayxd k"ke.eh,b

l`xyi xe` iy Ô Î ÏÚ Î

jenk jrxl zad`e zevna

:miyp yely ieyp didy in oipra miaiynl daeyze ipy wlg

מסכת מגילה תוכן הסוגיות בקצרה בעריכת יוסף בן ארזה יוצא לאור בהשתתפות מכון עיון הדף שע"י כולל עיון הדף ת.ד הר נוף, ירושלים

ipy h"ei rvn`a hilgdy l"eg oa oiipra cer ux`d ayezl jetdl

- '...`zelia` eilr lg `lc meyn mzd,yxete devn zlira lrea ipzwc `nili`,`lew i`n'

. oclefdcediaxd;uiaewxaxi`naxd;exitqxfril`oerny'textaxd

'mler `xea eppre' zlitz ly dzxin` onf minyb zxivr zripnl

`"hily daiyid y`x epxenn ireay xeriy zehn zeiyxt

oiihyphkil oexd` axd oe`bd oia n"en dcewt aexiq oiipra iwvaliq l`xyi mdxa` axd

oexzt [10%] :1 dl`y.(0, 0) dcewpd zaiaqa zeneqg ody zeiwlg zexfbp zlra f(x, y) idz.(0, 0) dcewpa dtivx f ik gked

zinewn zigiyn zelirt e`

.fi sc ohw cren zkqn

zay ly sqenay zepey ze`gqep xe`iaa

dixehqide oexkif,zeaxz

- zay zek`lna xnegd oeilik. l"vf jaxie` f"yxbd zhiy

hlw 1 `"r h"i ezny in - iyily 't zekxa

miyp yely ieyp didy in oipra daebz

hyta mixe`ae zexrd cvik,zeywdl yi Ð '...edn cg` qek jezl owgne zeheq izyl zelibn izy azk `ax ira'

gegld zkxa oiipra xewneloi`e`xaqa`ed,gegldiaeraielzxacdywlgnd? `ivend .dkxa `la yixtdl xingdl oekpe aehe,dlg odn

`"hily daiyid y`x epxenn ireay xeriy zehn zeiyxt

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy devz zyxt. mixet zekld

* `prd onlf dnly 'x wcwcnd lr cer

!'lehi myd z` lehil dvexd lk `l'

iliiw zgqep a"dx`,mit,(daniel J. Kleitman),onhiilw l`ipc 'text oeipkha ihnznd oecrena dpzipy d`vxd zerlvde,micewcew

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy izewega - xda zyxt

z d n i a r.

ixaca :i oldl x`ean oke.mixteq ixaca s` cenll xyt` `xaqn aiegnd xnege-lwy df itl d`xpe.y"r,`piax

icm dl ixn`e,ifi` il `ni`

zxge`n zecre zncwen zecr ziad xda zicedi zegkepl

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy `yp zyxt zereay lil xcq

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy izewega - xda zyxt

oncixt dcedi `ny mixkfpd mitca aezkk zekldd gqep `id "`nw `xecdn".extqa xagn lihny my mi`ad miaezkyde miiepiyd jq `id

1inxbc `pic. inxbc `pica minkge xi`n 'x zwelgn xe`ia.` wxt

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy. ycew zay ipipra yecwd xdefd ixn`n

oglyheg iwqp`ipxeh degl iy ,mih dwix`,mwexîofg zilb,lhxa l`xyi qixtiy iwie,hxal`îhxettx dcr,biieevpfex dice`lw milyexia zixard dhiqxaipe`d mikxer

zegiy ihewl zeny lcprnmgpnx"enc` jzelrda `k bk wlg zegiy ihewl ly zegiyd itl caerne mbxezn (iytg mebxz) kghkuh ban, rw angui vfvi c"r nav vfvi g"v

`"hily daiyid y`x epxenn ireay xeriy. zecin b"ie zegilq zekld

`nlra `nbec Ð '...dicicn lik`c zliy xa l`eny ax oebk ax xn`c,axck :iia` xn` `l`'

'xiee`l lhen `edy cenr'

leki dz`y mewn lk jkle,i`cek dxez ez`yr dheq wtqy i"tr` - '...`ed `witq wtq i`n`e'

`"hily daiyid y`x epxenn ireay xeriy. awr zyxt. dxezd inkga zewacd zevn

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy. ayie zyxt. xxea zekld jynd

mixetlxiy-'miypyelylrycgdtixiy'

z`xwp dlibn - oey`x wxt

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy. igie zyxt zay zekld

dxekad on cleed z` zxhetd ieb zetzey

dnex ipa bdpnk xefgnd ly dycg dxecdn

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy. exzi zyxt zay zekld ycewzaylilyeciwdxcq

l`xyi ux`a "gxf`zdl" leki l"eg oa m`d?ipy aeh mei rvn`a

"heicd `xwp edyere xacd on xehtd lk" dkeq zevna

xnb hwiiext- zizek`ln dpial `ean

dpn`d' ziixe`z xy`îxa mdxa` xevil`

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy xetk. xetik mei ibdpne zekld

d`elb zxeze zecyd zxeza dxfg zel`y

.a `xza `aa. xvga dvign zeyrl evxy oitzeyd :dpyn Hachana 1. DWC What s the yecig of the dpyn saying you shall place the wall in the middle?

yxcnd zian `veid zlitz gqep oipra cer

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy ayie zyxt. dyxta xdefd ixn`n. `EddA waczi `lc oiba,awric Ÿ Dilr Exar oiwia dom

wepiz ly zaya dlin lre,zeynyd oia onf lr zayd z`vl jenq clepd

Gdyńskim Ośrodkiem Sportu i Rekreacji jednostka budżetowa

i`gei xa oerny iax,xi`i oa qgpt iax "mixyi zliqn"e

oglyheg iwqp`ipxeh degl iy ,mih dwix`,mwexîofg zilb,lhxa l`xyi qixtiy iwie,hxal`îhxettx dcr,biieevpfex dice`lw milyexia zixard dhiqxaipe`d mikxer

`"hily daiyid y`x epixenn ireay xeriy wla zyxt

I n f o r m a c j e n a t e m a t p o d m i o t u k t ó r e m u z a m a w i a j» c y p o w i e r z y łk p o w i e r z y l i p r o w a d z e p o s t p

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy ybie zyxt

c"qa zetqezl mixe`ia zekxa zkqn z`n `pdk l"vf `bxy l`wfgi x"xden oa

`"hily epaxe epxenn ireay xeriy jlie-miavp zeiyxt. dpyd y`x zlitz

`"hily daiyid y`x epixenn ireay xeriy wla zyxt

Transkrypt:

zexrde zeaebz xtqd lr l"f al 'text ixacl daebz * "lecb ly elecib" `edy d`xp.ezxiht xg`l miizpy al 'text ixac z` mqxt "oirnd" jxer ayg`edydnzxin`lezyibllek,d`vxddze`aal'textxn`ydnmrddcfn `"lai"oirnd"jxermbel"fal'textmbmle`.zecaerzxzqdi`le"zn`dlk"l miyi` ixe`ize mictqd "oirnd"a izi`x `l :ef dhiyl m`zda mibdep mpi` d`vxdd seba mbe,jixrn jxerdy zeienca xaecnyk zeilily zepekz millekd zexnl,iwvpinw ozp axd ly xtqd iabl zg` zxewia zcewp ele dxkfed `l `"hily jeapxhy axdy izrny ip` mb,lynl jk.ea xwal dn yi hlgday eil` izptlh el` oirn mixac invra wecal ikxcky `l`,xtqd z` "xiykd" mb j` miaeh mixac likn xtqdy aiyd axd ;ezrc idn (my melira) eizl`ye ici lr zxaben l`xyi ilecbl izkxrdy `vn` m` okle,ce`n mirx mixac.lecglilrf`ik-jtidlm`e,ea`exwljiyndllke`yixdd`ixwd zcin ly dkxrd lawl ick zeyrl jixvy dn lk :xtqd ly zepin`d iabl ippi` zexewnd on wlg;xtqd seqay zexewnd zniyxa oiirl `id ely zepin`d mixaca izxkfp.mipin`l mayeg ipi`y zexewnk izidif mwlg z` j`,xikn oa` dilcb 'xl 'dlawd zlyly' xtq ly zepin`d lr `"cigd azky mitixgd wlgy wtq oi` dyrnl.dwica ilan rnye d`xy dn lk extql qipkdy,`igi.zepin` zeidl zeleki opi` mbe,zepin` opi` xtqa ze`aend zeielikxd on lecb feg` 85Îy 'miig utg'd ly eza zkxrd z` xagnd `ian xtqd zligza wtwtn envr iwvpnw ozp 'x ;mipekp mpi` dia` lr mixteqnd mixetiqdn lkn.zipxnydkxrd`weec`idefyoin`dldhepinvrip`j`,efdwihqihhqa lr jenql xyt` i`y xexa feg` 55Îa wx e` feg` 85Îa xaecn m` oia mewn i` miixehqid mixetiq lr mby il xn`(oeixehqid) xnef'text.df beqn mixetiq meya miwizrd dixehqidd ixtqn l"fg ehhiv `l okl ezrcle,jenql xyt`.l"ce,mewn,l"wevf xlhew oxd` iax,l`xyi oe`b,x"en lr xtqa `aend xetiqd iabl f"`xbdcizrlepzegipiraoge`vn`lymixaceaeidyezqex`lazknazky `id `xew lk ly ezrc lr dlery dpey`xd daygndy wtq oi`,l"vf xvln.jli`e100'nr[`,p]r"yzixyz'oirnd' * 77

ozp 'x xn` s` il) yxetna z`f azk `l ozp 'xy s`,ihpnex azkna xaecndy mqxetn did oexag zaiyiay il rcep j`.(azkna aezk did dn byen el oi`y lrexetiqldxeywdzidoxd`'xazkyazkndlrn"f`xbdlyezxewiayepnfa ly dnîzcin dfa yiy yyg n"f`xbdy,daiyia exxer xiardy"zexeag"dy oiprd i`vgaezkli`ckm`d.dprydndwcealqn`aqdeldprdflre;xzizex`tzd iwvpnw ozp 'xl izxn`?zn`a dyrpy dn lr mly rci oi` azeklyk zezin` rxdoeylys`"xwy"mbxzqelwpe`e"`eyrny"rxdoeylldxezdd`xwokly.dpenzd lk zii`x `ll oecipd itlk dhen dkxrd xviin `edy iptn,zn` `ed,enya awpe on`p xewnn xetiqdy xn` ozp 'x.xetiqd z` el xtiq in eizl`y lr?on`pxewndyokm`eloipneizl`y.ziyi`dfmc`xiknepi`ydcedj` mirneye miyp` ly xzei ax xtqn mipii`xny lkky oaen...aiydl lki `l df ly zecr lr mb.dpin` `l divnxetpi` lawl iekiqd lcb mipey mixetiq mdn `le dpzipmifixfl zecr(a,aimigqt)`xnbd zxne`dyrn eze`lr micripy ernye`e`xymihxtlrmixtqnmipwfykokylk,(unglrmieevnd)mrdlkl.xzeie mipy laei iptl mdixerpa zraep l"vf xlhew oxd` 'xa dribta xtql micbpznd ly zecwnzddy okzi `aqa,dwcealqn `aqa dribtd izrcl la`,eickp e` eicinlz eid migendy jkn,dxeng xzei daxd,dkxal miwicv xkf,hplqn l`xyi iax l`xyi yecwae mlwn.jklrdgn`lyi`yipira`lte miqqean xtqa mi`aend mixacd on daxd:zeivlewtqd od zegt `l zexeng dar mphewy miyp` ly zeivaihena ltltl zepeiqp lre zererx zeivlewtq lr zeyrlyiwicvkwfgen`edm`e,zekfsklmc`oeclmieevnep`.xagndipzenn ezeedzd'xtqd.(e,`zea`m"anxdln"dit'ir)wegx`edzekfdcenilykmbz`f zetiqend dl`k opi` ely zepwqnd llk jxcae,dl`k zeivlewtqa `ln'lecb ly zeaihpxhl` izrvde xagnd ipta izravd dl`k zenewn dnk lr.mipecipl ceak z`laiwok``edmixwndonwlgazegtle,mirexi`dzeaiqplzexiaqzegt`l.ixac zxzekd lynl jk.iepibl die`x mixwnd on wlga mixacd zbvd zxev mb ahid wgyl ezleki zekfa'fiaepeta zepaxd z` laiw'fiaepetn axd ik zxyand znglna ipnxbd cwtnd mr ewgyn zn`ay xn`p m` s`,die`x dpi`,hngy df mb gwlp axl zexigaa m` s`e,enr mr aihidl el xyti` dpey`xd mlerd mipax mincewd zexeca'fiaepeta eidy dcep m` s`e,dxeza ezlecb cvl oeayga exira axl dpnzp lbethkee axdy hiladl ie`x m`d:ztqep `nbec.epnn milecb zxaer zepaxy otec z`vei drtez ef m`d?mcewd axd ly eza z` `ypy iptn?yxeid ly eixeyik zkxrda mbet gxkda df m`d?dyexia,ziqexdzextqdlkz`rcil"vfoxd`iaxyaezkll"fal'textfixtdydn il li`yd eze`) 'lecb ly ezeedzd' xtqa xewn el iz`vn `le,mfben il d`xp 78

lr dxen epi` oiicr oiwyet z`n ze`wqit hhvl zrcl.(...envr al 'text epnfa.ziqexd zextqd lka ze`iwa da `veik mi`ven ep`.dleqt gxkda dpi` milecb ly "ze`hg" zbvd,ab` `hegdlyeipiyzxgydxe`izallkjxcadeeln`idxy`k,l"fgiazkaej"pza i`pza oaenk z`f lke,xetiqd z` mixtqn cvik ielz lkd ;'cke zeiprz aexn xegy'zxevabivnl"fal'textydniablazekip`z`f.ahidqqeanok``edy,dzidyitkdixehqiddz`x`zlmikixvmiwicvixetiqm`dl`ydz`'oale`!zirvn`jxcmbdpyij`.miaehdmixacdz`wxlikdlmikixvmdye` hrnke,ahidziqexrcioxd`'xydfji`mrtizl`yyxkfpip`efzepncfda ezeidacnlziqexyheytixd:ddinzaiaehiadigiyipa?llkzilbp`rci`ly ezepwfaoxd`iaxz`xikdyinlkla`!owfezeidaribda"dx`lycera,xirv yicwd `l heyt `ed.zipgexe zilky dpigan 'owf' did `l mrt s` `edy rci.xwidepnfldie`xdzeaiygjkad`x`lik,zyxcpdaldzneyzz`zilbp`l,`xwl"vfoxd`axyzihqipenewzextqlxekfi`xtqaizi`xyilxekf`l,ab`.di`xdpi`izi`x`lile`la` miiaeigddgiydiwlglrm"anxdlyekxcahwepxtqdyd`xp`llkdjqa milernd gayl oke...`ed,aed`d `ede,iriaxd wlgde" :(fh,` zea`l n"dit)."mkxca eklie mc` ipa ipira mbdpn ahiiy ick,mdizelrna mlldle inkgzbvdicilrxtqdz`xdhliznbndeiccvîcgdoeiqipdmbiepiblie`x mi`pw ly miaizkz it lr milrety ink xtqd z` enixgdy mdilecbe l`xyi mdilr dztk dgbydd eli`k,oiprd z` bivdl dqpn ozp 'xy itk e`,mikeyg.die`x `le dpekp `l dxeva bdpzdl zfxkdn zegepîi` yibxn iaxrn jepigl seyg didy in lk :siqedl ipevxa mixeqi`d mday mixwn lr dxen ixehqidd oeiqipd.mixtq lr zenxge mixeqi` exweplv`mbla`,mlerdzene`lv`xwiradxwjk.miwceveid`lzenxgde zfxkd mewna eli` xzei xye`n iziid invr ip`.mixrvn mixwn mipyd jyna lrlhedyxeqi`d.xtqayminbtdz`seyglenvrlrgweledyindidxeqi` xearwzrinekqmlylmkiglmiweznmiaepbminxy`el`lmxebxtqdz`ixw enk;oenddipiraxtqdz`xwiin`edjke,dxrdajxerdoiivok`yitk,xtqd ixag mipaxd mby ipnec.miax lv` zenirp `l zeiv`iveq` xviin `ed ok z` xizdl ehp mwlg eixac it lre,ozp 'x ly extq zwical enwedy zecreed ixagn cg` mr izxaic.dhiqxaipe`a ecnl s` mwlge,iaxrn jepig elaiw,xtqd mbe,(al'text ixaca exkfedy minrhdn ipnec) xeqi`d zlhdl cbpzdy dcreed mexbl icka xtqa oi` ezrcl la`,xtqd z` qitcdl jixv did `ly ayg `ed...enezcrxtqdz``xw`ldfyi`mbozp'xlyelfnlyildncp;axwfpl.'oeer xtki megx `ede' qiie oeyxb awri 79

"lecb ly elecib" xagn z`n daebzl daebz (ci,al mixac) 'xngdzyzaprmce' mikqnjxerdm`:"oirnd"lyjxerdlr`iyewae`ynz`ligzni"pazekd lk z` `weec xnel mikixv mc` mix`znyky l"f al a`f 'text ly eixacl exkfeiy yxec epi` caeknd eperaxa mictqd `ed qitcnyk dnl,zn`d xwia `l envr l"f al 'text dnl,cere?mictqpd ly zeililyd mdizepekz mixac hlgda ea yi xy`, 1 MAKING OF A GODOL ixtq z` ez`vxda rnyy mixac azekd `ian jkl di`xke- dyw zxewial elit`e,zxewial miie`xd xqe` epi`y zexnly, 2 zicxgd dcrd c"a`x,`"hily jeapxhy dyn axd z`n el` eizeiyew lr.le`yl azekd dywid jk.eilr dyw zxewia el yi ixtq z` mbxzidl dlekiy,"`xng" zinx`d dlind lr iypi` ixn`c dna ip` dpr` milkzqn?xenga e` oiia xaecn m` mircei ji`: 3 "oii" mbxzidl dlekie"xeng" `ed m` :`vnp "`xng"d dti`,epiidc,"`xng"d ly (xywda=) "hqkhpew"a ji` miraewyk,ok enk.oii `ed ixd szxna `ed m`e,xeng `ed dpd deexe`a z`mipenopiniiwmc`lyectqdam`:elyhqkhpewaoeclmikixvxacx`zl zenc `xewl yibdl mivex m`,jci`ne,eizepexqg z` `le xhtpd ly eizelrn mre eizelrn mr `edy enk eze` x`zl aiign hqkhpewd,mc` ly zixehqid mbhxtlmikixvxtqdlyeteblxtqdfi`lrdkxrdmiazekm`,jke.eizerxbn zrc itly,xtq lr xeqi` z`ved lr mivxn m` j`,eillv z` mbe eizexe` z` eizepexqgz`hxtljxevmeyoi`-zleei`eilrxeqi`deaehxtq`eddvxnd.xtqd ly zah"oirnd"aixtqlrdkxrdxn`nal"fx`iexaikcxn'textdyrweicajk ezywa jyn `ed :dwfega ixtq z` xwia eay,(jli`e 81 'nr a,cn) c"qyz elyqxddgekaynndnecmdncg`xy`,mivigdyelyixtqadxiezcnelnd mdn zexewnd ly mzepin`a wetwt epiidc,ixtq cbp azekd dhpy zipgle axgl ly zeivaihena ltltl zepeiqipae zererxd zeivlewtq"a s`e,xnegd z` iza`y :(82'nr)x`iexa'textmyazkjke."(dxezilecb)miyp` miax mixac.ircnd cerizd aiha rbep xagnd ea cnr `ly xg` xbz` ik dnec mle`...dt lray mixac lr miqqean xtqa mi`aend ce`n itn cr itn cr,d`xed dxen e` daiyi y`x itn e`viy mixac zxiqna etiqed`ny,dkldkxacdoaed`l`ny:dpynzexidfaxwegdaiig,cr.oldlcerdflrla`-"lecb ly ezeedzd" mya e`xew i"p azekdy oiany"axdy,al'textlyez`vxdzbvdjeza103'nrlrmiileyzxrda,oiivjxerdy."eze` xiykde elek xtqd z` `xw zilbp`?"izyinlxnge`akxinlxng,dheyd`lilb"a,bpoiaexir'ire 1 2 3 80

rtyxtqayi,oklrxzi...eziihpeezpaditlyi`,mdnerxbe`eixaclr...miihpze` zexewna ceqi `ll miyegipe zexryd wfplmexblickaxtqayiywiqni"pazekdyceray,`edoiiprndxacdok` ondpeydzidl"fx`iexa'textlyezpwqn- enez cr ed`xwiy inl xwira ax :(85'nr)dvwdl`dvwd eizeylegmixieegn,enezcreaep`xwyxg`lxtqdzxibqmr,lkdixg` xi`yn `edy xqnd `eti` dn.eizexe`e eibyid miwidane eillve ztewza `hila dxezd mler ly ezgixte ezlecb `ed xqnd?epzrceza ilecb mixega eayi odilqtq lryke,oahina eid zeaiyidyk,ezgixt `iy...d`xiedxez `lmbi`ceea`ed,l"fx`iexa'textlyezkxrdz`d`x`lazekdydgpda.(jli`e 63 'nr [b,cn] c"qyz oqip "oirnd") `idd ezkxrdl izaebz z` d`x ip`oklymyiztqede,miyelwzexewnlrmbizknzqddnlx`anip`izaebza wx mdy izybcd izygipy mixacd lre,exne` my z` xace xac lk lr `ian dn,jenql dn lr envrl hilgdl lkei `xewdy ick weica - `nlra iizexryd i"p azekdn ywa` wx,mixacd lr xefgl jxev oi`e.zegcl dne wtqa xi`ydl.my oiiriy `ivedazekdymixac,`"hilyjeapxhyaxdixaczernynnmb,miptlklr ip`,lkmcew.exykdnc"a`xdeaxfg`lymi`ex-enyznlrdickjezepnn mixacliknxtqd"xn``edye,axdlyeixacawiic`li"pazekdyxeaqldhep,"ce`nmirxmixacmbj`miaehmixac"`le)"mirxmixacmbj`ce`nmiaeh ixtqz``xwc"a`xdyixg`ik,jkldxexadgkedilyi.(azekdlyehehivk ziaaeplltzde,c"a`xdlyezpekyasepxdaipzglv`zeayliloncfp enez cr ze`n mr cgi,epgp` epiidyk,dlitzd ixg`."`"xbd zqpk zia",eyxcn epnn jxazdle ekxal yxcnd zia jeza axd ipt lr xearl epkxca,milltznd zexyr ipfe`ae mx lewa ixarl `xw,axwzn ize` d`x `ede,"mely zay"a jklkaezkllekiyxg`oi`ik,aezkljiynz,ozp'x":myettehvdymiyp`d ;ixtqayxetip`ydrixidagexnlrtzn`edyilxn`zxg`mrte!"jenkaeh!"ziyr dlecb dk`ln!?xneg daxd jk lk seq`l zglvd ji`" :xn`e dnz `ed c"a`xd ynzyn da,mii`lk 'ldn a"d e"ta c"a`xd zbydl ize` dptid `ede :ce`n oiiprn xac izi`xe my izpiir.m"anxd zcear z` ex`za el` milina `xnbd ixac eztiq`a dyrdlecbdk`lnik`lel,iy`xiig"myazekc"a`xd z`f ;'eke "einkge eipwfe mr ztiq` eilr sq`n iziid - `ztqeze inlyexide "xeqi`"a ecbp z`vle mr ztiq` m"anxd lr seq`ln rpnp c"a`xdy zxne` ribdlickxnegdaxdsq`edywcarm"anxdyiptn-mirhendeiwqtlrxeng 81

iitkribiz`eiiperz`"epia`awrixn`ydndflruilndllke`.dl`eiwqtl izrbiy iptn itcex oal iptn ilr obn d"awd,xnelk,"yn` gkeie miwel` d`x iala ip` izxn` el`d c"a`xd ixac z` izi`xyk mpn`.dyw dcear izcare ik,ixtq z` aezkl il gwly mipyd dxyr ynga witqn izrbi `l d`xpky mi`veieinkgnel`xyiipwfndnkeid`lygipdlxyt`dywxzeiizcarilnl`.izlert z` xeq`l icbp jeapxhyaxdc"a`xditnhhivyminezqdmixacdz`xiaqd`li"pazekd xtqa d`ixwd ici lr xabez l`xyi ilecbl jzkxrdy `vnz m`":epiidc,`"hily ixd:dil`ndvvdl`yde."lecgljilrf`jtidlm`e,ea`exwljiyndllkez xabz ea d`ixwd jezn m`d rcei epi` m`d,xtqd z` `xw jeapxhy axd jynda dxw xy` z` dlb` o`ke?hrnz e"g e` l`xyi ilecbl dkxrdd xtqn"y ixg`,epiidc,ez`vxd rvn`a x`zn al 'texty mixacd zelylzyd.(103'nrmy)"xtqdz`mixgdlepnnyexcl`"hilyaiyil`axlekldmiyp` y"venae,b"qyz elqk g"x iyily meia `"hily aiyil` axd oxnl dybed dpelzd wxa ipal reqpl ipa lr cwt dlde, 4 oxn ly eziaa lecbd ipa xwia eixg`y 5 myn opelznl azekdi"rzxkfenyxtqdi`xewlydcreedz`miwdldxhna xeqi`dzlhdlcbpzdldcreedziihpz`dlezazekd,ab`jxc.eixacseqai"p d`xpk azekd;"dhiqxaipe`a ecnl s` mwlge iaxrn jepig elaiw" dixagy dna ici lr `weec exgap xtqd z` xizdl ehpy zixewnd dcreed ixagy rcei eppi` rixtd `l mippelznly rnyne,md mzxigal iznkqd wx ip`e,mnvr mippelznd ziaa ipa ly exewia zxgnl,mipt lk lr. 6 mzexirva elaiw dcreed ixagy jepigd wdaencinlzmrey"nxmxagmr,w"xxew"ix,iipaipyerqpaiyil`axdoxn ilxhiipmc`kyickmdil`sxhvdlepnneywiamdy,f"`x,l"vfxlhewaxdly miizpiay,opelzndz`el`ymymzeida.aehxzeidcvdlrdyrplkdyd`xi `ianxtqdm`d,eizerxbnlklrzelrlickdciwyaxtqdz`ixwrvn`adid wngzdl dqipe epexba gkgke mbnb opelznd?mleflfl e` milecbd ly mzvxrdl `ian `ed" :dpr xac ly eteqae,aiydl eilr ugl f"`xy cr,daeyz zzln mippelznd y`x mby ixd."dpekp izla dxeva elek aezk `ed la` - mzvxrdl al 'text xn`y enk l"ega izidy ixtq lr dipexhd uaval dlgdyk `idd zra.ii`peycbpdnglndixywaf`cnry`edipae,(104'nryix)ez`vxda mippelznd oian icigid did `ed,izxt` sqei axd,oxn ly exfer ly eixac itl xy`.eilr jnq oxny dhiqxaipe` cinlz lk lqet `ed m`e,dhiqxaipe`a cnl envra i"p azekd ixd,mvrae leqtlnmbenvrz`leqtljixvdid,xtqdz`xiykdl d`ay dcreea zayln xaryl `eld-eaexwzaehlcirn`edykwxzecrlleqt,xg`zecrleqte`,aexwike;eze`!ezrxlcirn`edykmbleqt`ed 4 5 6 82

dn ok m` ;jtidl `le,l`xyi ilecb ly mzvxrdl `ian xtqdy drca did axd zpeeky ipayeg?jka wtq lihd dxe`kl xy`k `"hily c"a`xd oieekzd `idzg`d:l`xyiilecblqgiizdlji`mikxcizyopyiepxeciyp`oiaydziid mi`exak mdil` qgiizdl `id zxg`de,dy` iceli mc` ipak mdil` qgiizdl l`xyi ilecb lr lkzqn dz` m`,inipep`d otlhnl c"a`xd xn`,okae.miicb` d`xze,jipiraelcbiwxmdxtqdz`ixwnf`,yep`ipalrkdpyd`niptlny mixevi l`k mdil` qgiizn dz` m` la` ;zn`a milecb miyp` eid mdy eidy ze`xl afk`zz ik,xtqa `exwln lcg,`l eze'miyecw zeny'k,miipeinc.yep`ipaeidok`mdye,miigmda `nyyygotlhndedinrci`lyjeapxhyaxdy,xzeiild`xpdfe,cerokziie rnzynd ote`a dpr okle,mdn xdfidl mikixvy mirextd mi`pwdn cg` `ed mipey micrva ilr enii`y dl`k mi`pw eidy"oirnd" i`xewl dlb`.mipt ipyl ip` ea zqpkd ziaaiaqe izia aiaq zepbtd zkixr,ilr zenxgzlhd :mipeyne ilv` crezn lkd - izgtyn ipa z`e ize` zeyitknd zexaeg zvtd,lltzn xeq`e,leaqlipic"xfk`ip`yoeikymnvrlenkiqmd.oalb"rxegymiaezka xizqdl ycewa mkxc - ipenl` ipelt,cg` i`pw dide."ixg` secxln zetxdl zgwlmikixvyxn`elydaiyidy`xywiqt`lc`lwyiyil`azky-mzedf milekieidmixacd."`zpkyn"ilzzleiiqpknz`cixedlmyexrizyxeglize`.zipivx dziid mdly `gzixc `pcira mi`pwd zpeeky `lel,miryryn zeidl,miptlklr!eicinlziptacwendlrixtqz`dlrds`mziitepkiy`xncg` i`ckoi`yrciipnnaehxzeidaxdicxgdaegxdz`xikny`"hilyc"a`xd `lndtaazekldpr`lokle,exewcimaxs`eetgcimaxmbikmi`pwaybpzdl.oixcdnlxykepidxtqdy:ealaayeg`edizrcitlydn (ci,adki`)'ltze `ey jl efg jii`iap' xlhewoxd`'xazkymezqazknzece`lrixtqaxetiqdyhwepi"pazekd,oxd`'xlyeaxlazkndz`d`xddlde)xvlnf"`xbdlyeza,ezqex`lxirvd ezaygna dlrn,(wicv dk eppi` df cizrlîepzgy gikedl,dwcealqn `aqd ip` izrc lry minexna icdq.ihpnex azkna xaecny `xewd ly zipey`xd enqxt mippelzndy ixg`.llke llk efk daygn dzlr `l xtqd z` izazkyk - 7 ezqex`l zeltiz azkn azk oxd` 'xy ixtqa izazk eli`k qbd xwyd z`,xetiqdz`mi`xewdepiaidkkyizrclrdlr`lzn`adnlinvrlip`izgzip Dqex`ydfadgendidonlfxqi`'xm`ipwteqn,lkmcew:zeaiqdnkizilrde lyzaylysqenaaezki`edyjkaenxbe,cg`i`pezirldfldxwydz`exiards`e."mixtq mitxey mipaxd" zxzekd zgz iqiqr xn`n(b"qyz hay'f)"aixrn" oezir 7 83

epeylk) "etebk dze` aed`le etebn xzei dcakl" aiig didi hrn cery,eza ly jzrc`wlqji`,cere.dfkazkndlazek,(zeyi`'ldlye"htseqam"anxdly xqi` 'x xar `l i`ceeae?dqex`n ihpnexîiyi` azkn dia`l d`xz dxegay `l llk,jknxzeie!eil``ledil`dptedyazkngeztld"nbxcmxglronlf hqkhpewa`a`lxetiqdlkixdik,`eddazknaaezkdidydnaizpiiprzd `l`,xlhew oxd` axd ly ezbdpd ly - xwird `ed "hqkhpew"d mrt cer - lye,eicinlz ly mdizepekza dwcealqn `aqd ly ezpad wner ly hqkhpewa xqi`'xmrdfdxetiqd.mipydzeaxagztzixirvmc`ji``aplelyzlekid d`xdyk,myizazkyenkik,`aqdlyegeklzeaxipnzg`dnbec`edonlf `lyxn`e`aqdaibd,oxd`'xlyazkndz`dwcealqn`aqlonlfxqi`'x jk lk lecb wicv didi cer la`,dfd meik wicv `edy ely ozgd lr el xn` i"p azekdy dne.epkez dfe hqkhpewd df.elek mlerd lk lr rityz ezewcivy xqnpxetiqdik,oekpepi`,jkaizicedip`yellkjnqenepi`dfdxetiqdyoreh z` d`ex did maqy ji` dnbeck dwcealqn `aqd zgtyn jeza xecl xecn oa `ed (enya aewp` `ly ipywae) il` xetiqd z` xiardy mc`de,clepd.`aqdlyei`v`vncg`lieyp`ed-dgtynd rebtl izpeekzdy ize` eniy`de,"wqr" dfd xetiqdn eyry ixg`,oaenk "zpweznd dxecdn"a qgiizdl xak izgxked,qge dlilg l"f oxd`'x ly eceaka ygplwxizlekiyitlrs`,azkndlyepkezl(d"qyza xe`l d`viy) ixtq ly dxecdnaiztqed,mirhndemirehdlymaln`ivedlick,okle.eaaezkdiddn xqny ezqex`l oxd` 'x xtiq eazknay ygpn ip`" :oldlck `idd dycgd z`x`znip`myixtqaxg`mewnl`xewdz`dptnip`e,"dniyxn'dxeag' dig zipaxd,dwcealqn `aqd ly ezckp z` hhvne,dwcealqa zexeagd zxiqn ezedyl dpexg`d dpya xqen did xlhew oxd` 'xy 'zexeag'dy,onley mixn mr law oibtdl icke.xzeia zegaeyn eid,qxe`n didy dtewza epiidc,daiyia xz` lr `xewd z` iziptd mb,ipira xwi ce`n oxd` 'x ly eceaky dcre 'x ly zewcivd lceb mda mbceny ixtqa zenewn dnkl "zpweznd dxecdn"a zeyrl izlcbde.dwcealqn `aqd ly epefg znybdk,eiig ini jyna xlhew oxd` dxn`ydnz`l"foxd`'xlymiaeygdmicinlzdncg`myamyizxqnyk :eziieeldn eayyk dlra icinlzl,oecipay xarylîdqex`d,oxd`'x ly zipaxd."enlerljldlecbwicvyzxne`ip`e,xhtpylecboe`blrexaicmlek" oiiprn xac ezqex`l oxd` 'x ly azknd zyxtl siqedl il yi ef zepncfda,xe`l d`vi xak "zpweznd dxecdnd"y ixg` xnelk,e"qyz hay 'ia :ce`n wgvi epax zaiyi iy`xn cg`,onley jexa edil` axdn a"dx`n oetlh izlaw wxei eipay wx`t exea zpekya mixb eid,`hil i`veimdy,eixede `edy,opgl` dxtiq`"nyzzpyayilxtiqotlhnd.ezgtynexlhewoxd`'xlymzepkya dniyx Dqex` oxd` 'x dl gly mrty dl dxtiq dzengy oxd` 'x ly ezlk el 84

.l"vfonlfxqi`'x,dia`z`fibxddfe,`xwzyi`ckyziqexzextqlyzvlnen edfyxazqn:oxd`'xlyazkndzyxtlrycgxe`jtypdfitl.eldxtiqjk xak `lnl`! 8 dwcealqn `aqd ly eal zneyzl dia` z`n xaredy azknd izazky iptn,gxken iziid xacd il rcepy drya"zpweznd dxecdnd" dqtced `l`-`nlrayegip`lxtqaaezkl,(oaenk,ipirze`xitl)zn`dz`wxixtqa ezqex`l i`cky ziqex zextq ly dniyx lr xaec l"pd azknay xnele jezgl ly mzrc qitdl ick xe`l iz`ved "zpweznd dxecdnd" z` j`.`exwl oxd`'xy dycgd dxecdna dlbn iziid eli`e,zixewnd dxecdnd lr mippelznd icinlzlympexgilrjzipdidixd-`exwlziqexamixtqdfi`ezqex`luilnd,xng=)xnegiztq`odamipydjynayzexnl,jke!ferxziaez`yxziaceewiil iziid zgkype dwizr drici il` dribn dzidyk(d"ra zexecl xneynd aehd oii z`fdyirxndriciy`weecizgnyz`fdmrta-axlly`venkdilryeyllibx seqz`xwli"pazekdydny,zrclz`fe.xtqldqpkp`ljke,onfaipzribd`l zextqdlkz`xikdoxd`'xyeazekadcindlrfixtdal'textyxne`eixac ixtqa305'nra:oekpeppi`-ixtqajkloikeniq`vn`ly oreh `ede,ziqexd el xn` weica dkky l"f oixey l`xyi axd iqib z` yexita ip` hhvn ixewnd zextqd lka iwa did oxd` 'x" :oxd` 'x ly mixerpd xag,l"vf ix`n `a` oxd`'xlyezlkdxqnyxetiqdnmb;epzgll"f`a`xn`"ziq`lwdziqexd dniyxxagldidlekiyjkickcrdtwidaziqexdzextqdz`xikd`edygken ly dpey`xd dxecdna wxy lirl izybcd.ezqex`l zvlnen ziqex zextq ly hirndl iziqip da,"zpweznd dxecdn"a ik,l"f `a` ly ezecr driten ixtq mb.z`fd zecrd z` izhnyd,ceewiil icinlz ly mzeelyl erixtdy mixaca.xirv cli didyk ziqex zextq `xw maxy izazkyk,zxg` mixacd z` izgqip :oeyld dfa izazk zixewnd dxecdna,okle icenila`iddzrawqrzdxlhewoxd`'xmb,(l"f`a`)eplyxeaibdenk z` ekyny mircna xy`n zextqa xzei oiiprzd `ed.ighy ote`a leg did oxd` 'xy oixey l`xyi axd epzgl xtiq `a`.`a` ly ezepiiprzd xewia jldna xy`k dxye` ef dcaer.ziq`lwd ziqexd zextqd lka iwa dlnx xira daiyi y`xa cnry yi` oefgd ly eicinlzn xirv g"z lv` ici lr xn`p df" miieqn oipr lr oxd` 'x hlt (oiihyhex iav ac axd) daiyia.`edd daiyid y`x geeicy itk-"oiwyet xcpqkl`(iqexd xteqd) zpy ly uiwa 'eke onipiixb l`eny 'x,xlhew oxd` 'x exwia dlnxay.(dyrnd ihxta my jiynn ip`e)...c"iyz :jk izazk"zpweznd dxecdn"a eli`e...onlfxqi`'xz`efibxdyoxd`'xlymiazknipyeidyycgleploi`ik 8 85

oxd` 'x ly dgtynd my) qpit oxd` xirvd mb hlw,eply xeaibd enk zligza wqpina ezeida leg zerici zvw (ozgzdy cr qpit did xlhew dlbzd ef mixerp ziieegn zipxez zlrez witd ji` xetiq.ely dxyrd zepy cnr c"iyz zpy ly uiwa.oiihyhex iav ac axd mr izkxry oei`xa il 'eke dlnxa daiyi y`xa,yi` oefgd ly eicinlzn xirv g"z,oii`exnd.(dyrnd ihxta jiynn ip`e) mixac daxd izipiy iytpl il egipi mi`pwdy dewzay s`,ipea`cl ok` mb :izpwza dne`n izlred `l,iz`ady dnbecd enk,"zpweznd dxecdn"a dxecdnd" lr xeqi`d ik,dfa xacl dn daxd yie.dxq`p z`fd dxecdnd miaiig xy` mei - xc`a c"i - ce`n aeyg meia f"qyz zpya `ved "zpweznd ecwy df meia `weec...ikcxn jexal ond xex` oia mircei `ly cr ea myazdl.dfdinixetddyrnajix`dlmewndo`koi`la`,ixtqlrxeqi``ivedliiaie` `xw ezexirva oxd` 'xy ixtqa `vn `ly azek `edyk wcev mpn` i"p azekd did jky al 'text ly eixac z` xy`n azekdy s` - zihqipenew zextq mb dfn dyer iziid `l jkl rcen iziid m` mb j`,df lr izrci `l ip`.ze`ivna epnnxirvdidy,exagel"f`a`y`edixtqaoiivlizivxydnlkik,"minrhn" mixac mze`a,xqenae dxeza zelcbl mzelr mxh,epiiprzd,miyceg dxyra.mda epiiprzd `edd xeca mixg` milnxep mixirvy,opc elqka dawqena dtexi` ipax qpka mitzzynd cg`n il rcep ab` jxcae oxd` 'x ziieeld dniiwzd xy`k b"kyz zpy yixa oexag zaiyia cnl xy` dwcealq zaiyi cinlz didy,l"f `pxq l`wfgi 'x eaxy,l`xyi ux`a xlhew,mevrdielird,oxd`'xydwcealqaerci":f`xird,oxd`'xmycnlyk`hila lkz`f`rci`eld.mlg`lcg`s`-wicvdidiyla`;lecboe`bzeidleicr ef drici!"iwvexh ly eine`p z` renyl jled dide,dt lra ziqexd zextqd `aqd ly eipir wxy ji` dnibcn mbe,lirl izazky dn lk z` dkeza zalyn.etwidlkal"foxd`'xlecbdecinlzlyecizrz`efgdwcealqn (eia`myamyw"cxdyexititl,gv,hiwmilidz)'ipnkgz iiaie`n',xeng xzei ote`ae,`l`l"vfxlhewoxd`'xawx`lizrbtyoiivni"pazekd miwicv xkf,hplqn l`xyi iax l`xyi yecwae mlwn `aqae dwcealqn `aqa izrnydkcrik,ce`noiiprndfxac.(jklrdgn`lyi`y`ltzn`ede)dkxal :(a"`dxcqitlr)oldlcmilecbaizrbtywx "yi` oefg"d,uilxw ediryi mdxa`'x ceewiile wvlw wvelq zeaiyi y`x,xlhew oxd`'x flh zaiyi y`x,oecxeb xfril`'x 86

"dix`zb`y"d,uinnaildix`'x uipnwe dwcealq zeaiyi y`x,uiaeaiil xa jexa'x wqixa ly daxe oi'feleea daiyi y`x,wi'viaeleq miig'x dpaewlydax,xehwtqopgl`wgvi'x xin zaiyi gibyn,uiaeail mgexi'x dwcealq zaiyi y`x,oiihyt` ikcxn dyn'x (a"ivpd) oi'felee zaiyi y`x,oilxa dcedi iav ilztp'x :efd zcaeknd dniyxl dyely cer etqep i"p azekd zekfae xqend zrepz llegn,xhplq l`xyi'x dwcealqn `aqd,lwpit iav ozp'x mlwn`aqd,eiflqifdgny'x o`n `l` - dl`d milecbd lka izrbty cg` xewnn izrnyy eaygz l`e ok m` eprbd lkd jqa.dka xn` dfe dka xn` df,`d xn` `l `d xn`c xa jexa 'x,oecxeb xfril` 'x,xlhew oxd` 'x,mdn dyingl rbepa. 9 xqilzl zeprhdoddnmyedtilxn`p,uiaeailmgexi'xewi'viaeleqmiig'x,uiaeaiil milecbdzyelylrllek,maexlr,mxa.zg`lzg`oze`izigce,ilrzeipephwd ixnblip`ddcfnokle.mceakaizrbtdnabyeniloi`,i"pazekdicilretqepy xzei xye`n iziid invr ip`" :oexg`d etirqa i"p azekd ly uxgpd ehtyn mr."xtqayminbtdz`seyglenvrlrgweledyindid,xeqi`zfxkdmewnaeli` dn il milbn iicbpzn eid eli` iziid xye`n ce`n!jk miyer eidy i`eeld,ied mpi`yxacexaclklrmdld`xniziidf`ik,ixg`ewlcikiz`hgdneiryt ip`el`xyiux`aelreevavazenelrdzepelzdyk,ok`e.migymddnlrmircei zeevna jiyndl l"f oxd` 'x ly eckp wxei eipl ribd if`e,lirl xkfpk,l"ega my obx`py el izrvd,ux`a o`k ligzd `edy ("jaxwn rxd zxrae") dticxd,iizeaeyzz`yext`ip`eeizeprhz`mdiptayexti`ededxezipalydtiq` eaxiq zixewnd dxecdnd lr wx `le.axiq `ed la`.wcvd in mr erixki mde iwcvh lka ewngzd "zpweznd dxecdnd" lr mb `l`,iz` znrzdl iicbpzn `vz xy`ky dziid `"hily aiyil` axd oxn z`n izyixc ixd.ilen zayln zeprha eil` e`eai i`ceea miywird iicbpzne,zpweznd dycgd dxecdnd xe`l z` eki `le iipta `weec mdizenevr z` eyibiy,`edd xtqa mb azkpy dn lr wqt oxne.l"ega izidyyk zncewd dxecdna ey ryitk,iabixeg`n,xzqamrx z` oxn biiq seqal j`.(zwcev dprh ef=) "dprh rbihkix õ fi` qôc",xn`e miyp` xnelk,oey`xd xeqi`a miaxern eid `ly miyp` m`y hilgde,ewqt epze`deeyndz`ycr",cg`ocxhiebldgxwoaryediiaxzaeyzaxkfpip``coebkae.eze`c"tdax`xwieoiir,"jipaz`deeydejl- 9 87

elki jk oibae.iipta `weec eciriy jxev oi`,cirdl e`eai,dyxtd lkl miycg mircei mpi`y caln xy`,miyp` ipy eiptl m`iada,oxn z` zenxl iicbpzn mx`eevcrmirewyemiaxerneidmbixtqz``exwlickzwtqndcinazilbp` dppi`"zpweznd dxecdnd"y oxnl xn` df qng gtie,oey`xd xeqi`d z`veda gwl,drztda weyl ribdy,zixewnd dxecdnd,dpde.zixewnd dxecdndn dpey zexnl,"zpweznd dxecdnd" dznerle,dxeqi` z` obx`l miiyceg wx iicbpznl cr dlgd dzxikny zrn dpy ivg dxar,xe`l z`vl zcner `idy erci mdy zelwa`evnlegilvd`lik?jklkaxonfmdlgwldnle.xeqi`dz`epbx`y mde ;ewqete l`xyi lecb z` - oaenk "miny myl" - zenxl mipkend miyp` ci lr zayl ea` `l,oey`xd xeqi`a miaxern eidy oxn rci mdilry,mnvra ik,ecbpkoerhleweylycgdxtqdz`vacin`"hilyaiyil`axdlyepgley mdicr zzle (!"zwcev dprh ef"y raw oxn ixd) ilen zayl migxken eid f` xt`mzvrz`emif`mdizeprhz`yerciik,elki`lote`meyayxac,ewcvie.mirbie mikex` mixacde.zepncfd il ozpiz wx el (bn,al mixac) 'eixvl aiyi m"wpe' ipydivgadpbni"pazekdyixtqamiihxtdmixacdzyelylraiy`eiykr 'faipetazepaxdz`laiw'faipetnaxdikzxyandzxzekd"(`)mde,eazknly lbethkee axdy hiladl ie`x m`d" (a) oke,"hngy ahid wgyl ezleki zekfa otecz`veidrtezefm`d?mcewdaxdlyezaz``ypyiptnexiraaxldpnzp (b)?"yxeid ly eixeyik zkxrda mbet gxkda df m`d?dyexia zxaer zepaxy eli`k ixtq lr xeqi`d oiipr z` bivdl "iznbn" ote`a iziqipy ezny`d.die`x `l dxeva bdpzdl l`xyi ilecb lr dztk dgbydd.oexg` oexg` lre oey`x oey`x lr aib`e oiai i"p azekd ly epeyln :ezxyn z` biyd 'faipet ly oexg`d axd ji` (`) xird iaeh ici lr ogap l"vf onpdk dnly sqei axdy izazk ixtqay `xewd xyekae ezepcnla `le,hngyd wgyna ezeignena z`fd daeygd zi`hild ("qeqxewqk`",oeicd) aigxzd ly `vend zcewp.ynn dlilr z`fe.ezebidpn uetp jk lk hngyd wgyn did dwcealq zaiyiay dzid(1049-1054'nr) ixtqa miaigxzlymkxcke."zi`wcealqdlgn"hngydwgynz`dpikl"f`a`ycr,l"f upixel dnly axd ixac e`aed,oiiprl oiiprn milylzyny("miqeqxewqk`") `aqd ly epa zey`x zgz f` dziidy xin zaiyia cenll dixbpedn `ayky daiyid y`x ly epa yipiia 'x did,l"f lwpit dcedi xfril` axd,dwcealqn `aede.zeqekn eipiryk mixgzn dray cbp iphleniq hngy mipnfdîoiaa wgyn cnloexg`dyk,l"f`a`mreiwgynlrilxtiql"fiwvcelew`pkyaxdydn cenll dxyr yely oa ccea mezik dwixn`n ribd `ede,dwcealq lleka xak 88

tnw" uiw dpgna eicinlz mr hngy wgiy l"f `a`y xteqn k"g`e.dpaewa e"kyz zpya dxy iig y"vena eckp mre - wxei eip zpicnay mixda "`zaizn zlreza zeixe`iz bivn ip`e,(ynge miray oa xak did l"f ix`n `a`yk) onpdk dnly sqei axdy dnl mixacd milylzyn f` wxe.el` eiyrna zikepigd dyrnd z` epiidc,`"hily oeqiel awri 'x oecpela reawd egx`nl dlib l"f mipnxbdyk,d"rxz zpya gilvd hngyd wgyna ely rcid jezny ji`,eihxtl miqex miliig ze`n ryz zenn livdl,dpey`xd r"dgln onfa `hila ehly odik `edy mewna,fcie dxiird i"r ipnxb miieay dpgna mixeq` eidy miicedi xtiqe,eiieayz`dprndid,hngydwgynlaxdlyetzey,ipnxbdcwtnd.axk?axd dyr dne.ezeni mleky cr miieayd itl` z` airxdl opkzn `ed ik axl miipy micedid miieayd z` ekezn aipbne dpgnd ixney z` cgyn did `ed xirl myne,d`xadl dwegx xirl millne`d miarxend z` gley dide,miipy dayiyxkipdid`lycrdaexbymiaxdmicedidoiaernhpda,'faipetdlecbd ezlertlrlynnlrcepdidm`yoaenk.ehlnpydnglniieaylydlecbztqez wgviaxdz`hhvnip`e.ynneiigz`okiq`ed-cinbxedlaxd`vendidef xeyrd ly ipyd ivga izcnl da daiyid ldpn didyk eizxkdy,l"f xciipy,(zepaxlizkinqlrmezg`ed)"zrcedxez`zaizn"-y"zdzepylyoey`xd dldykonpdkaxdmewnz``lnndidywdaenmkgcinlz,'faipetayezecili xgap onpdk axdy xn` xciipy axd ;zetekzd eizeriqp z`tn exirn xcrp did,'uiaepiax wgvi axd lecbd oe`bd ly enewn `lnl'faipet dlecbd xird ly daxk fcieen dnglnd inia exary miaxd fcie iyp` zekfa wx,x'faipet lvi`'xkrecid xxgiyonpdkaxdymiieaydeiddl`fcieiyp`yizrcz`rianip`. 10 'faipetl evn`zd okle,mze` le`bl eiig z` okiqy mc`l dcez exikdy,miiayn mze` zeitxbepend xtqay jkn ef izpaezl oikeniq `ian ip`.xird axk eze` xegal mr exagn miiwy zepei`x jezn eazkp ea mixn`n daxdy,"mixeaib zyw" fcieezxiirnn"w165lywgxn-'faipetaxwandidonpdkaxd"yxn`p,eixeaib dxfrd.weqireoekiymdl`evnlemihiltzegtyndaaiyedlick,onflonfnmicedid lkn dcd`e dxwed el e`iad dizeaiaqae'faipeta mdl wtiqy dlvdde xgapyiptlcerdlidwdibidpni"ruxrpdid`edokl.llkdon`veiila,xiray zi`exd dyxt llebn ip` ea,xaecnd aigxzd ly okezd zivnz o`k cr."daxk ik i"p azekd ia `vn leer dn :l`ey ip`e.l"vf onpdk axd zecleza dnelre?iptiwzd urjxca"xtqa`aedydnhhvnip`eaixtqaxg`mewnl`xewdz`dptnip`mye z`mipnneideli`yxne`didf"`xy,l"fxvlnonlfxqi`'xlyditxbeiad,"miigd lawnlvi`'xdid-daiyidze`axeriyicibnzeidlwi'viaeleqmiig'xz`elvi`'x.miwixan xzei md eiyecigy iptn,deab xzeid xeriyd z` 10 89

i"p azekd ly epeyln :lew dxiird ly zepaxl lbethkee axd ly ezepnzd (a) dxiirdaxlyezaz``yplbethkeeaxdyizxkfdydnaiznbny`xewdoiai wcva xird okle,eitlk dkxrda mebtl dziid - zepaxd z` laiw jk jezne ike!mdxa`c dix`n.yxeid ly eixeyika znbet dpi` zepax zyexi zrtezy mc`dlriz`xwwx`lip`?l"flbethkeeh"eidyn'xae"grebtlizpeekdziid mipylaeiiptlizikfmb`l`,agxdxeaivlmirecimpi`yzexewnadfdlecbd ixg` zepaxa yniy my,dcpw,l`ixhpen xira ezi` ggeyle eze` yebtl eilr izazky dn z` xyid `xewl xiar`e.dpey`xd r"dgln ly zeketdzd zpya 'faipet zepaxl ribd onpdk axd ji` izhxityk :(1054-1057 'nr) ixtqa xirdy izxkfd,miqexl xfg lynnde `hiln ebeqp xak mipnxbdyk,h"rxz ezrted dziid efe,drayd ini meza lvi` 'x z` citqdle `eal eze` dpinfd ly iaxrnd dvwa,wxt eze`ay mb izxtiq.dzepaxl cnrenk zinyxd dpey`xd 11 lew ezclen zxiira,`hil,zeaxmipyjynadlidwdy`x,ail'x,eia`akymlerd zngln seqa `hila xxyy edeaeîedezd llba xy`k,ieec yxr lr 'faipetn mbe,`hil ly igxfnd dvway,fcien mb zwzepn dxiird dziid dpey`xd milbdzkdlvi`'xlyezxihtok`.epalv`dxewdnrci`lail'xe,drvn`ay ail 'x xn` f`.wfad zexidna diagxa evetp zeaevrd zeycgde,dpicnd lka ly zepaxd `qk lr ayi cer dnly sqei eppay jl xne` ip`" :ezy`l qqebd l"pd dpey`xd ezyxc z` `yp oady meia,lvi` 'xl drayd seqa."'faipet a`donhpzepaxdazkz`ecillaiwoadykzxgnle,lewaa`dxhtp,'faipeta lbethkeeh"eidynaxdyixtqaazekip`e.ipydlrrceicg`dyila-ezxiira miwicvdlewiayezlymxetiqz`xtqnip`f`e,`iddzralewlydaxdid zpyay,uity ozp dyn 'x xara did dxiird ly dax :(e"kyz "xard" jezn) aiieg `ede,`txn zkeug f` dzidy zwacin zrxv zlgna dwelk ogae` a"qxz cg`d,diqexa eid dl`k zecqen ipy.zrxv ilegl icecia cqena fty`zdl y`x.dbix uxtna,ihxt ipyde,bxeaqxht dxial jenq cplpit uxtna,izlynn dndxezdilecbz`le`yl,f`epacnlmy,flhllewnrqponpdkail'xldwd 12 oiihyxea oxd` mdxa` 'x,bixeeh ly dax z` my ybte,zeyrl wqt dlde, iyp`l dlri dfy s`,ihxtd cqena epiidc,exirl aexw ikd zeidl jixv maxy maxl zepn`p jezne,cakd lerd z` mdilr elaiw dxiird icedi.ax oed xird zgtyna mzxiir ly zepaxdx`yizy icke,mdiigae`xi `l aeyxaky dlegd axd?edipo`ne.zepaxdz`elexqnelecbmkgcinlzlezaz`epzigs`,max dnly sqei rcep mdizexiir my lr micinlzd z` oda mi`xew eidy `hil zeaiyia."xlew dwei"k onpdk zaiyi y`xk yniy eiigl zepexg`d miizpyae,e"txza milyexia xhtpy,"oxd` xp" lra."axdfkxn" 11 12 90

c"i') dwcealqn micinlzd xyr drax`n cg` didy,l"f lbethkee h"ei dyn ip`e.izazky dn df.wvelqa daiyid z` onlf xqi` 'x cqii mzi`y ('dwfgd?iptiwzdiki"pazekdia`vnleerdn:aeyl`ey ilecb lr dztk dgbydd eli`k xeqi`d oiipr z` bivdl "iznbnd" oeiqipd (b),iznbn ote`a ixtq lr obn ip`y i`ceea,ok`.die`x `l dxeva bdpzdl l`xyi,ok`?eilrob` `like,iig zxivi,ily "qete`mepbn"d`ed ixtqixd?dn`l` lr dztk dgbydd eli`k" xeqi`d oiipra ily dpaezd z` x`zn i"p azekdyk ilydngboinkdze`bivn`ed-"die`x`ledpekp`ldxevabdpzdl(mixqe`d).jkxacdoi`e;`leze,ixtq lr ze`ngn ze`n eteq cre mlerd seqn izlaiw.iixac z` xiaq`e zeevn xenyle,xzei cenll,l`xyi ilecb z` xzei xwiil epnn ertyed ei`xewy cgeincg`la`,ilmixkeneid`lmixywzndlymaexaex.xzeictwenote`a `ed.zilbp`axknîiaxmixtqxaigy,dxezoa,wizedaeyzlra-ilxkendid :(inebxza)azk`edea,ritedixtqyixg`zereaydyelyl"`ecilgly ick jez la`,dpeyn rnyii ile` dfy rcei ip`!oprxn jk lk xtqd,daeyza xefgl izhlgdyk il dziidy dybxdd z` aey izybxd d`ixw ig ip` eli`k ax onf izyg.jk izybxd f`n onf ce`n daxd xar xake d"a ip`y zexnl zipgex dkyga jldzn ip`y,zizin` dpen`n wegx edyfi`a gex ixeaib zeidl miaiigy yibxn ip`e,dxez cnele zeevn xney izi`xxtqdz`iz`xwykdpde.el`kmicceawxxiknip`la`-mewn milecb,mdil` xaegn yibxdl iziid lekiy miyp` eid zn`a mrty rczy izivxe,xtqa zrwydy dceard lk lr jl zecedl izivx.miizin` dz`y zayg `l i`ceeay miyp` - ipenk miyp` daxd mpyi `nzqny mdldziidydieegdnzeigelawimipyjynay-mzpen`z`wfgljled.zizin` zelcb ea eybte xtqa e`xwyk lkepnn'wifgd'yxtqde,zexaerzezayrayxy`kenvrldfmc`xn`idn enixedxezdilecble`alrilaiyp`:xn`i`l`ed?dxezilecbicilrxq`pjk bxapieawril`igi'xicilrx`ezndxacdoirko`kdxwyaeygi`l`ed.mze` miaxemivxeylecbmc`lye`qiklaiaqnikoeiqipditlrep`mircei `l ik ghanl odl didz ozephw xy`,miphw miynx oin,zelty zeixa ly ezilha onvr lr olit`da,od zeleki ok lre,dp`vnz `le dp`xz dpkqlkoi`axyimc`lkixg`secxle,ynxddyrnkzeyrl,"lecb"d ilanmqxetnoe`bicilrmirbtpmixyimiyp`xy`minrtlyie.oytpl : 13 l"f.(blw'nrb"qyzm-i'cdn)fcellydax,l"flfiinmiigdil`'xlrectqda"miwxtl"a 13 91

"axwr zviwr" `id z`fy md mixeaqk,mryte mz`hg z` oiad "lreylydkiyp"`l`z`foi`xacdxwiraycera,oe`bdlrmixnxnzne...ewiga mngznd ygp zyigl e`,oe`b ly miycewd iycew zian `veid z` ote` meya epiai `l,md zecdil mi`nve md mininz xy`,daeyz ilra itlr"eze`xikn`ede)x`zn`edyenkxacyoin`dlickik.bxapieaxdixac oa izc icedi oa izc icedi zeidl mikixv,ze`ivna epibega zexwl leki(!"oeiqipd daeyz lrad.ixc dxyr zegtd lkl zizcd dxaga axernd,izc icedi ly epa epnn adlzd envra `ed ez`ixw jezny xtq lr xeqi` z`vedn afk`zdy,ocic oiicry d`xpk jk lk zeax mipy dxez izcnly ixg`" :xn`i,dpen`le zeigl dk df xtqy aeygl lbeqn iziid ji` zxg`,zecdid jxc z` zn`a rcei ippi` xeq``edycr'sxh'dk`edymixne`milecbdzecdidignenydrya-liren ip`,idn izpad `l oiicr zecdi izcnly mipyd lk ixg` m`e?'d ldwa `eal ezpwqndidzz`f...?"ildni`zndppi`dxezdjxcile`e;oia`mrti`m`ddez xeqi`d z` bivdl iziqipy azkyk zwiecn dpi` i"p azekd ly dibelepinxhd edynlrwxik,die`x`ldxevabdpzdll`xyiilecblrdztkdgbyddeli`k oaen izla edynyke, 14 "dgbyd" z`fy mixne` daehl.l"x dxewy llkd on `vei dnxgda axern ohyd did dn iptne."ohy dyrn" eze` mixicbn drxl dxew driztnddrtezdz`yilgdloeekzd`ed?dfaohydgieexddn?efzpaenizla lrilad iyp` enxb wfp dfi` rcei zn`a ine."daeyzd ilra" zrepz,epxec ly!divpbilhpi`d ibega zegtl,daeyzd zrepzl ilr elilrdy :ez`vxdaal'textlyeixacseqlrmbxirdldvexip`e mixedhd z` `nhny,dnec` dxt enk `ed dfd xtqdy azky in yi `lxakdfdxtqd-`nhyin:jtddxne`ip`la`,mi`nhdz`xdhne.dxdhcerelsiqedllekidfdxtqdxedhyine,eze``nhi dxtl ixtq z` dnicy inn ixtq lr obdy lr l"f al 'textl dcen oaenk ip` ip`y xn`i dlrnl iixac z` `xewd `ny,ok`.`ed in rcei ippi`y - dnec` miqenre minlye mi`xi mi`xewl la`,`ed aeh xtqd daeyz ilraly izwcv ixtqzxcbdy`eddazekdmrmikqi`ede,wifndfdxtqddcilneohandxeza ike:eayiiazdlmikixvyxacdnec`dxtad`exip`oi`j`."dnec`dxt"`ed f"vy deevn - zeevnd b"ixzn zg` `idy dnec` dxt ly oic draw `l dxezd?"epzne`a lecb xac" dze` xicbny,(h"vy deevn mbe) jepigd xtq ly epiipna migayny ixd dnec` dxt enk `edy xac dfi` lr mixne` m`y zxne` z`f l`'dipir"'eke"ux`diayeilkl` gibydezayoeknn"blmilidzamiweqtditlr.'ebe"mytp zenn livdl"'eke"ei`xi 14 92

!zeevnd z` mifan - oeifia myl ef dxethna miynzyn m` ;jtidl `le,eze`?lecbxacedevnzeidldleki`idji`e,z`nhnmbdnec`dxt`eld:l`yzm`e dfznerle,'ynyaxrd'wxzyxecddlwd`nehz`nhn`idyoeik,`eduexizd.lecb xace devn `idy i`ceea,mini dray za dxeng d`nehn zxdhn `id xdhne,dciln miizcd z`,mixedhd z` `nhn ixtqy xn`z elit`:ocic oeciple 15 daeyzd ilra z`,'mi`nh'd z` wx `iadyzlrezdm`cecnlep`mikixvm`rixkdlf`wxe,e`lm`mixg`miyp`lmxbywfpdlrdzlrdl`miyp`l ixtqa minbt e`vny eprhy dl` ike.ecqtda exky `vi e` exkya ecqtd `vi lydtyami`iwazeidlmikixvdfkxaclewylick?dfkote`axacdz`elwy eid m` ipwteqne,ok eyr `l iicbpzny ip` gehae,oeira eze` `exwle xtqd xvepy,ixtq ly eny ly zixarl minebxzd xgany ipayeg.ok zeyrl mileki e`xw xeqi`d gqepa ixd.epkez ly dpaddîi`l mehtniq `ed,ilbp` mya clepe 'text ly xn`na oke,c"qyz"oirnd"ay dkxrdae,"lecb ziiyr" mya ixtq z` ezeedzd"-iyilymyaxakdpeki"pazekdixacae,"lecblyelecib"ede`xw,al... 16 "lecbly (b,eh mixac) 'jcihnyzjig`z`jldidixy`e' z` xdhl iznbnde iccvîcgd oeiqip"aize`miy`d`li"pazekdygnyip` mi`pwlymiaizkzi"trmilreteli`kmdilecbel`xyiinkgzbvdicilrxtqd zgz milret mdy l`xyi ilecb z`,e"g,izny`d `l ip`y wx `l."mikeyge eidy izazk xak dlrnl ok`.jka mze` miy`d in llk rcei ippi`,miaizkz dxecdnd iabl mby zeidl lekie,"zpweznd dxecdnd" iabl mze` enixy mdy dn z`"iznbne iccvîcg" ote`a enbxzyk,mippelznd mze` enix zixewnd izazk ixd.dxfd dtyd z` mi`xew mpi`y eply milecbd xear ixtqa e`xw mikqpm`elit`-eze`xiykd,xtqdz``xwenvray,jeapxhyaxdydlrnl al 'text mpn`.'oixcdnl' did `l xykddy zinipep`d ezgiy it lr i"p azekl i`xew mipaxd ly dcreed xagy,"oirnd"a hhevy itk,ez`vxd jeza xidvd l"f owfdid`ed)l"vfoiihyt`bilfaxd,aiyil`axdoxnzcewtadnwedyzilbp`d jxerdy cr z`fk zeihlgda did dfd xykdde,xtqd z` xiykd,(dcakpe dcreed dwcvdmeyoi`':dzidoiihyt`f"xdlyepeyl"(7miileyzxrd,104'nr)xird ok`;`xwirnmixedhldxdhsiqenwxxtqdal'textxn`yenk`l`,oekpeppi`dfy.mixedhd z` `nhn xtqdy mikq` `cixb gekieed myl "q"yd zeibeqa ield miig axd oe`bd iyecig" xtqd zncwda,uilxb lcpn axd eli`e wtqila,eraewazeyrllicbd,ixtqlrfeajtey`eddae,c"qyzxc`axe`l`ivedy ji`" xtqd my z` mbxzl "oekp xzei"y,zilbp`d dtya zwdaend ezeignen it lr..."lecb ziiyr" xeqi`d oeyla riteny itk enbxzln(!ynn inixet mebxz)"dxiixw miyer 15 16 93

,oiihyt`axdlyoiiprndeazknlymelivicizgzyidpde."'xtqdz`xeq`l :`ed dpde. 17 elek xeaivde i"p azekd zricil ezenlya e`iadl i`cky ipayegy w"tlb"qyz[zah'f]ybiexcql'dmei.`"hily aiyil` i"xbd x"xden'eke dxezd xy xic`d oe`bd ceak,aehlkzkxaemely icilribd`ldnmeyne,aiyil`y"ixbdlyepernlmeyxx`ecaglypazknd:ab`jxc z` izxarde,a"dx`a ixewiaa epnn wzrd izbyd okn xg`l miyceg dxyr wx!oxn.eil` wzrdd 17 94

.ze`ik dxweda x"zk y"c ixg` xtq"d zyxt `ide,c`n a`ek oipra izrc zeegl x"zk mya ipel`y xy`l izyxcp ipipra axrzdln biizqn ippd icern.xe`l i"p iwvpnw ozp'x b"dxd `ivedy"ixezqidd jexk df oipr izrc itly oeikn mle`.mda lthl miknqend md xecd ilecby llkd,l`xyia dxwi dgtynl miaxa mipt zpalde zeticx,zevnyda mbe,ynn ytp gewta.dfdoipraizrczeegliytpldaegd`exip`okl `lmlerne,y"xiewdaenmkgcinlz`ede,eixerpnceri"pozp'xaxdz`xiknip`.miigep`mditnxy`zexecdilecblymceakarebtle"gezrclrdlr miyp`ne`,l"vfi"xbdeia`nrnyyynne``edextqa`ian`edyhxtehxtlk,zexecdipe`blymznewxeriyarebtle"gmzrclrdlr`lmlernyy"xiedxezipa ilmirecimdn`aexc`aex.mrnyyitkuxnpweicalaiwyitkxqni"pozp'xaxde miiepiya minrtl,daiyid ilzek jeza dtl`dtn mixqnp eidy itk inelrinin cer.zepey ze`gqepae milw.l"pdxtqdxeq`ldwcvdmeyoi`yizrcitl.cerda`clsiqep`lemelyaenrz`jxaijxazimydydlitzip`e ä dax dxwedae zecicia oiihytr ield bilf oxd` mifexg xyr dyely za dgilq z`vnp dpyd y`x axr ly zegilqa :meiqle ä fexg lka."jzad` dxxer `p`" milina dligznd,ilaad dnly ici lr dxaegy ziriaxde,zg` lka milin yng zelikn zepey`xd yely xy`,zexey rax` opyi ohiitd xga oey`xd fexga.deeg` zaxew ly xekf` ea yiy weqt hehiv dpid,l`xyillkoial,ohiitd,epiaxxeyyqgidz`ecilrx`zlickdeeg`lyweqt oiay qgil dvilnk el miynyn deeg`d iweqt mixg`d eifexg xyr mipya la` eizelitz z` ef jxca ilaad dnly epax dptn jk.lekiak,l`xyi enrl d"awd :iriaxd fexgd ly zepexg`d zexeyd izya l`xyi llk cra minyay epia`l zexeyd izya,"'l`xyi jig` xn` dk' / l`d ze`lzd lk z` zrci dz`,oepg" jig` inc lew'/ miwele miken jicar dpd meiîmei":iyingd fexgd ly zepexg`d iilr ellebzi jingx" :ixiyrd fexgd ly zepexg`d zexeyd izyae,"'miwrev ä."'ilg`kjpziin'/ila`mgpnk ik,jipiraxf,xviefmrldeeg`zaxiwd"awdlqgiil,epiidc,dfxac`dil`e -(a"ryixbpzegpnoiir)eizeixalycici`xwpd"awdy`ede,jknxzeiepivn micici oia la`,`edi my lecbe oehw,zegtd lkl,mig` oia ik,denz xzei dfe miyp` zenya `ed giky xac eixevil xveid ly deeg`dy cer mi`exe!oeieey dxew dig`e,le`y zy` mrepig`e,oc dhnl jnqig` oebk,"g`" dlnd zakxen mda.epcari rxfl,clep mrl g` dpekn,eny jxazi,'dy ixd. 18 ipeliyd.mdizenewna mdizenyl"`xwn zrc" yexita oiir 18 95

,ezenlya iyiyd fexgd z` hhv`,dgilqd zpada ef zillk dncwd xe`le :oldlck jicaerejicxenalcgixewqlhian/jceak`qiklrjzaya,dqkmein.'jcihnyzjig`z`jldidixy`e'/jicbeaz`ynlralkuebp iptlmixaerea,dpydy`xmeinyd"awdllltzdl`iddffexgaohiitdzpeek d"awd dabi,d`lde,licadl l`xyi mbe minrd mb zg` dxiwqa eceak `qik ip`e.hinyil`xyienrlymdizeaegz`eli`e,miaiigmdydnlkminrdz`n mipy ray e`ln df sxegay oeiv jez i"p azekd zaebzl izaebz z` miiqn oeiliba,jkitl.ea zeprl wiqtdl onfd ribdy ipxeaqe,ixtq lr xeqi`d z`vedl,azekdiptaizywaz`gheyip`,r"yzoqipycegaxe`l`veiy,"oirnd"lydf :ilaaddnlyiaxlyeheitlydf`xtxticilr,mdipinlmippelzndlkiptas`e -milbxlemiklnldqkmein,`p`/:miwreviinclewizaebzixg`!minlerl ehinyd mkig`îz` mklîyi xy`e/,mipy ray uwn,dhiny eyr iwvpnw i"xbda ozp ä ä ä!`xnbd ecx`t c"xn dnlrp `l `iad g"dixl'znyp' zxin` zlebq qegii lr xn`na'oirnd' ly oexg`d oeilba mzkn z"eyaecx`tceciax ixacz`(1 'rd49'nr)dxrda `"hilylhqaxd epnndnlrpylrdnze,`xnba"iglkznyp"gaylxewnoi`ybi'iqg"e`cecl."iglkznypxn`opgeiiax,xiydzkxai`n":`,giwmigqt'qnazyxetn`xnb znyp"zxin`lrocmy'ceclmzkn'at"cxixdy,xneld`xpezdinzayiile `liglkznyplydfgayc`edrecidpde":azkdflre,zayzlitza"iglk siqedl ebdpy zetqezd x`y lka enk weqt epic jkle,xwire llk q"ya `vnp epnn fnx `vnp `ly s` dpde.`"tx 'iq x`eanke,eze` oixifgn oi` olek lry `nlra `nrhn gazyil xn`y jexa oia exicqdl mixcqnd e`vn mewn,cenlza zxiyl edeknq mixvn z`ivi oiprn ea yie li`edc,xkfpd oniqa xehd `iady q"ya mewn `vnp `ly,dxexa ezpeek k"`e."mixvn z`ivi oipr `idy mid seqa exne`l q"ya xkfpy jkn eixac lr `iyew oi`e,dlitza df gay xikfdl.gqt ly dcbdd seqadxrdad"gzrcdegiz"eyaxeviwaazkokyiz`vnz`fiazekxg`e.d'iq izxpk iginr 96

zxzgna `ad apb oipra daebz `ad apb oicy heyty inya `aed (100 'nr a 'lb p jxk) oexg`d 'oirnd'a ceqiyoeik,mikenqoicziaeploi`ydfdonfambbdepebxedlxzenyzxzgna xzen xqen mb ixdy,mipnfd lka zbdep scex zbixde,scex `edy `ed xzidd epi`ymixaeqyiyeamirbetmi`pwyzinx`lrealdnecepi`e.dfdonfabexdl `l` mibdep mpi` zeytp ipice,yper jxca bxdp zinx` lreay,dfd onfa bdep zlvd meyn `edy scex ok oi`y dn,zifbd zkyla miayei lecbd oicd ziayk.mn`l mitcexyk mibxed xaere ohw mbe,scxpd aezky oic lky,r"eyd `le df oic `iad `"nxd wxy jkl mrh izazky dne :ze`nbec dnk dfl aezk`,miwqetd ede`iad `l mizirl yexita dxeza,dleqtdpydlkdaayeiydkeqy,ikd"c`,ascaeazkydkeq'qez'ir `le 'nba riten `l df oice.dpyd lk ly ezia `le `pngx xn` dkeqc yxetn xacy ixd,'qezd lr miwleg mpi`y d`xpy zexnl mipey`xa.miwqetd eazk `l dxeza riten df oic.dlila `le meia zeidl dkixv dpyd y`xa xtey zriwz `l m"anxdy d`xpe.m"anxa `aen epi` j`,` 'rq gtwz 'iq r"eya dfe,dxeza zeyxetnd zekldd lk z` azek epi` `ed mby meyn e`iad ycegae `,hk xacna dxeza yxetn meia zeidl jixv xtey zriwzy eyrz`ldcearzk`lnlkmkldidiycew`xwnyceglcg`airiayd m"anxd eazk meia `weec alel zlihp oicy s`e ;mkl didi drexz mei ixtoey`xdmeiamklmzgwledxezaaezkys`i'ldalel'ldnfwxta zrayn oey`xd mei yxtzdl ozip 'oey`xd mei'y xyt`,'eke xcd ur okoi`ydn.dlilemeilleky,zrlzrnepiid'mei'ao`kdpeekde,minid did`lzrlzrnldpeekdm`y,dlil`lemeidpeekdmeidy'drexzmei' m"anxde.'mkl didi drexz ycega cg`a' `l` 'drexz mei' zeidl jixv dxeza`xew'cg`lkdidiy,'dxezdpyn'xtql`xwy,ezncwdaokazk.'mdipiaxg`xtqzexwljixvepi`edfa`xewjkxg`edligzazkay ur zigydl xeqi` enk,m`iad `ly mipic ce`n daxd yi r"eya dpde zevn oke.y"iir,dfa dpkq yiy e w"q fhw 'iq c"ei f"ha `aede,lk`n 'iq n"eg ly oexg` oniqa d`iad r"eyde,xeha d`aed `l dwrn ziiyr.g"e`xehaoke.ekzoniqaxnbpellkadfkoniqoi`xehae,fkz 'nba exn`y dnngikedl yidfd onfamb bdepyzxzgna apboic xwirdpde li`ed,`ax mdn laiw `le miapbd exifgde,zxzgna el eapb `axy r oixcdpq miwoi`y`veif"dfazxzgnoicoi`m`dpde.edpipwmincayaxceitnwitpe - minelyzn xhet bbeya mb n"calwy s`e!zxzgna apeba dipin daxca dil aiigepi`ys`ybbeyazayayicbsxeye`bbeyamc`bxedoebkwxdfyd`xp.`..a.b 97

,dzin aiegn zxzgna `ad apb oi` la`,dilr oiaiigy dxiar xar n"n dzin,zxzgna`edydrydze`aebxedlozipywx-daipbdxg`apbdz`oibxedoi`y wxtyix`"rxdy,rcz.n"calwo`koi`dfdonfaebxedlozip`ldyrnlm`e n"ne,eamirbetmi`pwyn"calwyqpwaiigepi`diebqpe`dyazkzexrpel` xazqny s`e.wtqn ea mirbet mi`pw oi`y oeik qpwa aiig dieb wtq qp` m` wxye`dzinaiigm`oiawlgljixv,wtqnn"calwyiiebwtqmc`bxedm`y gk 'iq oyegd zevwn di`x yi,ok xn`p `l m` s`e.ebxedl ozip dry dze`a opicary cifna bxd la`,bbeya bxda df dqitz liren n"calway dny azky xengdyperdeleyreli`kaygpzxzgnae,dqitzliren`lxengdyperdeilr yiy xexa ixd.qtzy meyn mlhp `le `ax xifgd okle,ebxedl ozip ixdy.n"calw bxacleb dingp onlf axd ä ä ä o"anxde m"anxd zehiya daege zekf cenil mi`penygd 'zekln' lr `ly zexnly, 1 mi`penygd zekln ly zeiziiral ezxrda qgiizd ohw i"xd m"anxdyibcnz`flka,irackdxezdipiclrdxny`laexle,cecziandziid oze` lk zeklnd meiw z` llek mibbeg ep` eze`y dkepgd qpn ifkxn wlgy eteqa j`,"daeg cenil"a zexrd dnk siqedl mewn yi c"prl. 2 mipyd miiz`n.mzeklnlr,zekfcenilambxacly.100-102'nr(r"yz zah) a,p'oirnd',"!?'l`xyil zekln dxfge'" -"zeklnxcdybepxiarnepklrcnre"weqtdlrk,`il`ipcaazki"yxs`yoiivp `ede,'ebel`xyilrnoeiybepxiarndopgeioaedizznzircendxdaeqiqalrwfgzie" mb jk."mipenygd ipa eixg` erxf lke `ed didi xeabe xy ik,l`xyia zekln xcd,sqkmiyly ixkyz` elwyie 'dikxca zkllmkipira aeh m`" :ci,`i dixkf,w"cxa,zg`dpyi`penyg`xwpdedizznmdel`e,cqglymiklneklnydpymiylylfnx mdaeidm`e,dpy`"lixd,dpyg"iepaoernye,mipyyyepaozpei,mipyyyepadcedi zeil`ehw`dn mb mlrzdl oi`."dpen` ikln eklny dpy 'l eyrp mixqg miyceg.130-143 'nr,(a"pyz) c zexe` illh,"zexewna l`xyi zpicn" ixn`na 'ir,mixacay,"m"anxd zpyna mi`penygd zeklne dkepg qp",hiidcpefb a"x df `yepa y"na r"re dkelne dpedk",uxeey l`ipc ;my zexrdae,137-145 'nr,(c"qyz) `i zexe` illh zl`yl",l"pd ;13-26 'nr (iptb 'i :jxr) 'l`xyi ldw' uaewa,"zi`penygd dtewza (oxhy'n:jxr) ` jxk'dizecleze dne`' uaewa,"mi`penygd zeklnl miyextd zecbpzd.39-39'nr 1 2 98

rcinde) m"anxd iptl eid miixehqid mixtq dfi` mircei eppi`y zexnl aeyg,(mvnevn ziqgi `ed mi`penygd zekln `yepa l"fg zextqa zeklnd ly dkldd zxinya minbtd z` ahid rci m"anxdy yibcdl lk ea eidy ipy ycwna": 3 zeipynd yexita epeylk,dpy miiz`n mze`a iptl mikled eid `l miklnde,zrciy enk,minlyen izla mipiprd mipyd miyiyl wx `l aeiga m"anxd qgiizn z`f lka..."dxyid zxeqnd,eziy`xa lecbd odk opgeie,oerny,ozpei zepy) ziqgiîdpebdd zeklnd ly mipyd miiz`n lkl s` `l`,herind mdy (oey`xd qtixb`e oeivnely.dnecke mipeeizn,miwecv ly oehly ellky envr m"anxdy yibcdl yi,ohw i"xd i"r e`aedy o"anxd ixacl sqepa m`.dcedi hayn epi`y jln zklnd xeqi`a o"anxdn xzei s` xingn 4 "mdia`[awri] zrc lr mixaer"y mrhn xqe` o"anxd xeqi `l" zkxaa xeqi` `id cec zian zekln zripny rnyn m"anxd itl,"dcedin hay zzl lkez `l" e`ld xe`iza!dpen`d ixwirn cg`a dxitk s`e,`ziixe`c 5 "ixkp yi` jilr,jln oi`": 6 cgein ote`a zeevnd xtqa m"anxd jix`n rxfnececrxfn`l`,mi`iapdlkoec`d"repiaxdynzxezoin`iyinl opixwixkpzeklnoiiprl-cakpdrxfddfzlefn`edyinlke.caldnly azk dpen`d ixwir b"i geqipa ok enk."ea wtq oi` x`ean dfe...dia 7 m"anxd dnly rxfne cecn `l` l`xyil jln oi`y dfd ceqid llkne" lkae."ei`iapixacae'daxtkdfixdefddgtyndoiprawlegdlke,`wec eid mi`penygdy miinrt m"anxd yibcn da,dkepg'ldl dgiztdn z`f eziitive ezlitz mr cgiy mi`ex,"mipdkd on jln ecinrd"ye mipdk,zilnipin zeklnl elit` lecb jxr m"anxd wiprn zil`ici`d zeklnl!cec zian dppi` m` elit`e dcaerdzeaiygz`oiivn`edyjkaxzeiazhleadfoipram"anxdzrc efd zeklndy jenqa cin yibcn `edyk mb "l`xyil zeklnd dxfg"y efd zeklndy xxazdy ixg` elit`,xnelk."ipyd oaxegd cr" wx dkynp dneiwz`flka,bebgldnlroi`xakdpaxegmrdxe`kle,zipnfdzid.1.2.3.gt`w i"xd mebxz t"r,b"n `"t `nei m"anxl zeipynd yexit.i,hn ziy`xa o"anx.eh,fi mixac.aqy z"l zeevnd xtq xg`ly,c"da"tzekxa'ldm"anx'ire.a"idceqid`"ni"toixcdpqm"anxln"dit oi`y":siqed`edezaegici`vi`ln"dkxaacecziazeklnxn``lyinlkyoiivy."cec zia zekln zxfga `l` dxenbdngp 3 4 5 6 7 99

zexnl,meid cr mibbegy qpa aeyg wlg `ed "dpy miiz`n lr xzi". 8 'dle`bc `zlgz`' my dziid `l xexiaay zixwird zlrezdy,mixg` zenewna mb m"anxd yibcn dkepg'lda enk zexyt`d z` dgihand zipicn ze`nvr `id zeiekln ceariy zwqtda s`) "giynd zeni" xwir z` d`ex `ed jka ;zeevn miiwle dxez cenll 9 azek `ed daeyz 'lda.(cec oa giyn zrted iptly dialya df iptne" zeiklnn egepiy ick,giynd zenil mdinkge mdi`iap l`xyi lk ee`zp eaxie,rebxn mdl e`vnie,obedk zevnae dxeza weqrl odl zegipn opi`y jixvy mb mewn eze`a xikfd m"anxdy d`xi my oiirnd mpn`..."dnkga dynlaexwd`eapalecbednlynxzeidxezalecbceczianjlncenriy mvr `ed xwirdy,mikln 'lda mbe my mb,enekiq jezn xexa j`,epax mlere,dfdmlerd`edgiyndzenila`": 10 jelniinxy`nxzeizeklnd minkg exn` xake.l`xyil xefgz zeklndy `l`,jled ebdpnk."cala zeikln ceariy `l` giynd zenil dfd mlerd oia oi` mipey`xd mda mi`apzny zeaehd lky", 11 daeyz'lda m"anxd ixacn mb gken ok zenil l`xyi oda oipdpy,sebay mixacl `l` opi` l`xyil mi`iapd mi`a,xaca wtq cer did m`."l`xyil dlynnd aeyzy onfa giynd giynd jlnk `akek xa z` ddfn `ed ma,mikln 'lda m"anxd ixac `li`ceeayzexnl, 12 "execinkglk"e`aiwriaxzecritlril`ivphet mgly jka ic - d`eapa dynl aexw `l mbe dnkga dnlyn lecb did.xzeia zilnipin elit`,ze`nvr biyde zipelig(`) zekln dticry m"anxdn xexiaa dler,elld zecewpd lk mekiql yie,zeixkep zeieklnl ceariy xy`n,zipnf(b) elit`e cec zian dppi`y(a) s`e.efzeklnlydneiwmvrz`bebgls`.4 wgvil d`eyn,"ztqep zelb didz `ly ze`ceede bevxd axd,l"fg lr":iixn`na r"re,(bxaqc `"xd:jxer) ezxihtl dpy miying ze`lna bevxd ield `"ixl oexkif xtq,a"g bk xdev,"daihpxhl`k zelbd z` ze`xl wiqtpy i`ck";40-49'nr,h"qyz,milyexi.55-66'nr,(e"qyz,sxeg).a"dh"tdaeyz'ld.a"d a"it mikln'ld.f"dg"tdaeyz'ld ilecbe l`xyi lk enice" b"d d"t ziprz 'lda eixacl deeyd.b"d `"it mikln 'ld yibcdldvexm"anxdywtqoi`j`,"giyndjlnd`edy(minkgdlk`l=)minkgd,mzenkdkldyeixage`aiwr'xzbxcallkdzid`lherindzrcdze`ymikln'lda d"i`xdixn`n'ire.`xcxyki``lcmeynxeceze`amdizeewzdnybzd`lm`s` zn`zxezikep`migeha...ltp`akekxae,lykpezryaoefgdyiptn`weece":203'nr."dxvminrtmewz`le,`aejleddfdxezde,dlxez`eaiyecwdtaxy` 8 9 10 11 12 100

13 '`miawndxtqa.`yepamiakndlrdlecbzekfcnllyi,xen`dlkzexnl epxga":zeklnk mzlynn z` xicbdl `l ecitwd edizzn ipay minrt dnk gken xkfenjynda.( 14`l,h,`miawndxtq)"...y`xlexyleplzeidlmeid(ozpei=)ja 15 (g,bi,my)`iyplxgapoernyy,(br,h,my)mrdz`hteyozpeiy hily `edye,`ad xeca qepwxed opgei ly zerahna s`.'jln'n ueg lkd,(fi,ci,my) ux`d zhlgen dgixa jka yie, 16 "micedid xag y`xe lecb odk" :x`ezd riten oiicr jilr zzl lkez `l"n) m"anxd ly dgkezd ixac znerl,xnelk.dkelnd x`ezn ipay d`xpk dzid ze`ivnd,("dcedin hay xeqi `l"n) o"anxde ("ixkp yi` dnn mb dler `yepl zeyibxd.miklnk mnvr z` xizkdln erpnp `weec edizzn mlerl lecb odkle `iypl oerny mdl zeidl eze`p mipdkde micedid ike" aezky `edmpehlyyyexitaexicbdmdxnelk, 17 (`n,ci,my)"zn``iapmewixy`cr mixge`n zexeca wx.cec zian giynd jlnd z` gynie `iap `eaiy cr ipnf 18 qeleaehqix` mixne` yi) miryxd mi`penygd i`v`v efird mixg` j`.zeklnd x`ez z` mnvrl zgwl( 19 i`pi xcpqkl` mipreh diddfe":z`fddxiaraeig`edcediz`yxetnamiy`dlo"anxdaygmpn` egkzyp md `lnl`e,oeilr iciqg eid ik,ipy ziaa eklny mi`penygd yper owfd i`penyg ipa rax` ik,lecb yper eyprp k"tr`e,l`xyin zevnde dxezd."axgamdiaie`ciaeltpmzglvdemzxeablkmrdfxg`dfmiklendmiciqgd zixarl oiicr mbxez `ly meyn miawnd xtq z` o"anxd d`x `l d`xpk j` mipey`xd zexeca mi`penygd ebdpzd jk lr rciy ilay okziy jk, 20 zipeein x`yl ezexyka laewnd '` miawn xtq oia dpgadd lre,llka mipevigd mixtqd lr xeyi`a wqt) aq 'iq,` wfad d`xnk z"ey 'ir,xzei wtwetn mxewny miawnd ixtq w"qmy`"xbde,c'rqenx'iqc"eia`"nxde,a"da"tf"r'ldam"anxd.(il`xyiy"xd jynda 'ir j`.dxf dcear ixtqa `ed mipevigd mixtqa `exwl xeqi`dy ewqt,hi.l"nk`e,21 dxrda '`i"re,"bidpnlexyl":mbxez,h"iyz`"z,mehxdy"`i"r.a"vxz`"z,`pdk'`'cdn."bidpnle y`xl",c"qyz milyexi,hxettx."eplyen did dz`":mbxz hxettx.322'nr,my x`ezaj`,"`yiadfeonbx`yali"y(bnmy)aezkmpn`.lyen:hxettxmbxzdts`.`xwp`ljln.45'nr,h"iyz`"z,a(oexhivl"y:zixarlmebxz)l`xyiinkgixac,uxb'v.324'nr hxettx'ir xikdmpn`.xewn`lemebxz`linn`idy,myoeylawiic`l`nyd`xm`elit`e` izi`xe" ziy`xal ely dncwda xikfd ixdy,miipevigd mixtqdn wlg zegtl o"anxd "dnly znkg" xtqn hhvn `ed f`e,"dnlyc `zax `znkeg `xwpd mbxeznd xtqd z`y oiivn,fh,ek `xwie,o"anxd lr eizexrda,lreery c"gx.miipevigd mixtqay `edy oetiqei xtqn `l` miawnd xtqn `l o"anxd rci zi`penygd zekln lr eizerici 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 101

jln mdilr miniwn l`xyiy t"r`" :envra my rivdy oexztl m`zda weica,zeklncedmdilrdidi`ly,oze`migyenoi`-drydjxevitkmihaydx`yn."eidi mixheye mihtey enk `l` cbpzd`eddxwnlkae,miawndxtqz`xikd`lm"anxdmbygipdlxiaq onfd ceai`"k jkl qgiizde,dixehqid ixtqae miipevigd mixtqa d`ixwl x`ezdn egxa edizzn ipay rci `l `ed mby okîm` okzi. 21 "milha mixaca."jln" hay wgvi ix` btx'nr,dle`bd xtqa'ir,"oeixeb oa sqei" mixg` zenewnae,"miinexd xtq" my dpkn,hn ziy`xa lr eyexita exikfd mby siqedl ozipe,lreery g"xd'cdn o"anxd iazka zeclezn c,al ziy`xa lr o"anxd xikfn xg` mewna.`,el oihib lr eiyecigae,`l my s`e,"mixtqa mqxetne epizeax ixaca xkfen" exewnk oiivne mi`penygd zia.oetiqeia exewn oa ixtq oke,oipin ixtq exn`-'mipevigd mixtqe'":`"n i"t oixcdpq m"anxl n"dit zlrez`lednkgmdaoi`y"dq`xtl`"ipiprnzeifdamixtqxaigyi`didy`xiq dyitzd - dnciwde m"anxd",qex i"ix lv` 'ir."milha mixaca onfd ceai` `l`.529-542'nr,(odk'i:jxr) dixehqide dxag,"m"anxd ly zixehqidd 21 ä ä ä ely epi` a"ivpd ly dhinyd qxhpew ly eivg oilxa miig iax ly miizkldd eiazk eqtcp,g"qyz milyexia,miizpyk iptl zeaeyzl zepia.miig znyp z"ey mya,mixcedn mikxk drax`a a"ivpd ly epa,odipia mixeftd mipiiprnd miixehqidd miazknle,zeaeygde zeaxd zeizkldd oilxag"xdaiynbx'iqdrcdxeijxkayeazkna:icnldriztndricizxzzqn z"eya qtcpy,ely dhinyd qxhpewa a"ivpd eia` ixac lr dywdy cg` axl lydipydzivgndlkyelxqene-(ep'iqixg`,c"pxzdyxee,awlg)xacaiyn ly eznizg xg`l zeritend "onfd ipaxn daxd dpde" milindn,df qxhpew :l"fe!a"ivpl zkiiy dpi`,oniqd seqay iwvael axd l` daeyzl cre - a"ivpd iazk z` mixcqnde,d"dllvf b"de`n oe`bd `a` xnn epi` xn`nd df lk" dnizgedgiztmeyilaqexhpewddfmkezae`vn 1 l"foe`bd`a`xnlyycewd c"a` f` 'idy,zeilbxn lyrd ryedi 'n lecbd axdl `ede - extqa eqitcde g"xd xikfdy itk,(oli` xa) xi`n 'xe awri dipae,mixn-diza ezbxegî'en`' md `ld azkp oke.(40-44'nr,f"nyzixyz,`zxaegdljxk'gxfndxe`')xg`azknaoilxa."dipae d"dllvf oe`bd zy` z`veda":z"eyd xrya 1 102