TRZY KONCEPCJE ISTNIENIA 1

Transkrypt

1 TRZY KONCEPCJE ISTNIENIA 1 Wà$'<6à$:S75Ï)(:6.,.WRNWRSRGHMPXMHVLPyZLüRSUREOHPDW\FHLVWQLHQLDQDSHZQRPR*HF]XüVL]ZROQLRQ\] RERZL]NX F]\QLHQLD ]DVWU]H*H ]DUyZQR QD WHPDW SRGVWDZRZRFL WHJR ]DJDGQLHQLD Z PHWDIL]\FHMDNLQDWHPDW]ZL]DQ\FK]QLPWUXGQRFL:V]DNSUREOHPDW\NDLVWQLHQLDZFKRG]L± explicite lub implicite ± Z ND*G GHILQLFM PHWDIL]\NL SRF]\QDMF RG $U\VWRWHOHVRZVNLHJR RNUHOHQLD ILOR]RILL SLHUZV]HM MDNR QDXNL ]DMPXMFHM VL E\WHP MDNR E\WHP NRF]F QD,QJDUGHQRZVNLHM SURSR]\FML UR]XPLHQLD PHWDIL]\NL MDNR QDXNL SRZLFRQHM EDGDQLX LVWRW\ IDNW\F]QLHLVWQLHMFHJRZLDWD$OHWH*QLHPDWUXGQLHMV]HJRSU]HGPLRWXUR]ZD*D:\QLNDWRMX* ] MHJR V]F]HJyOQHM QLHXFKZ\WQRFL SRUyZQ\ZDOQHM ERGDM MHG\QLH ] QLHXFKZ\WQRFL F]DVX R NWyU\P Z $XJXVW\Q Z\SRZLHG]LDá RZR Vá\QQH ]GDQLH ³&]\P *H ZLF MHVW F]DV" -HOL QLNW PQLH R WR QLH S\WD ZLHP -HOL S\WDMFHPX XVLáXM Z\WáXPDF]\ü QLH ZLHP 2 0yZLF R LVWQLHQLX RGZRá\ZDü VL PXVLP\ GR MHJR GRZLDGF]HQLD GDQHJR ND*GHPX ] QDV ] RVREQD ± L RSUDFRZ\ZDüMHQDZáDVQRGSRZLHG]LDOQRü0yZLF]DRQLPLS\WDMFRQLHLQQ\FKQLJG\QLH EG]LHP\PRJOLE\üSHZQLF]\UR]SUDZLDP\GRNáDGQLHRW\PVDP\P1DZHWM]\NQDPWXQLH sprzyja: greckie einai,ádflvnlh esse czy niemieckie sein, FKRüVUyZQRZD*QLNDPLSROVNLHJR LVWQLHüREURVá\WDNPQRJRFLZ\MDQLHLQWHUSUHWDFMLNRPHQWDU]\ZLGRF]Q\FKMX*FKRüE\Z SURSR]\FMDFKLFKWáXPDF]HQLD*HVDPRUR]H]QDQLHVLZQLFKZ\PDJDG]LRVREQ\FKEDGD 3RGVWDZRZH S\WDQLH MDNLH PXVLP\ SRVWDZLü EU]PL SR SURVWX ³&R WR ]QDF]\ LVWQLHü E\ü" $ FLOHM &R WR ]QDF]\ ³LVWQLHü E\ü Z QDMF]\VWV]\P D ]DUD]HP QDMEDUG]LHM SRGVWDZRZ\P]QDF]HQLXWHJRVáRZD"1DMF]\VWV]\PWR]QDF]\XFKZ\FRQ\PEH]VSURZDG]HQLD JR GR ]QDF]H LQQ\FK GR LQWHUSUHWRZDQLD Z ZLHWOH F]DVRZQLNyZ ORJLF]QLH Sy(QLHMV]\FK V]WXF]QLH WZRU]RQ\FK IXQNWRUyZ LWS OHF] GRZLDGF]RQ\FK Z MDVQHM DXWRQRPLF]QHM LQWXLFML samego jest. I w najbardziej SRGVWDZRZ\PWR]QDF]\WDNLPNWyUHSU]\VáXJXMHtemu,co jest w VSRVyE QDMSHáQLHMV]\ IXQGDPHQWDOQ\ RG NWyUHJR LQQH VSRVRE\ LVWQLHQLD MHOL Z RJyOH V V ]DOH*QHOXESRSU]H]SRUyZQDQLH]NWyU\PVWDMVL]DUyZQRZLGRF]QHMDNL]UR]XPLDáH ']LHMH ILOR]RILL HXURSHMVNLHM WR QLH W\OH MDN VG]Lá Heidegger, dzieje zapomnienia LVWRWQHJRVHQVX³LVWQLHQLD ³E\FLD LOHFLJUy*QRURGQ\FKMHJRLQWHUSUHWDFMLZNWyU\FKZ\QLNX GRFKRG]LáRLVWQLHQLHGRXVXZDQLDJRQDGDOV]\SODQOXEFDáNRZLWHJR]PLHQLHQLDJRWDN*HSR SURVWX]QLNá]SRODZLG]HQLD$OHE\á\ZKLVWRULLILOR]RILLHXURSHMVNLHMFKZLOHNLHG\UHIOHNVMDQDG LVWQLHQLHP QDSUDZG VLJDáD V]F]\WyZ RQR VDPR ]D XFKZ\W\ZDQH E\áR Z VZ\P SHáQ\P jakkolwiek tajemniczym blasku. 3RMDZLHQLHVL ILOR]RILF]QHMUHIOHNVMLQDG LVWQLHQLHP Z\]QDF]\áR UyZQRF]HQLH SRF]WHN GRMU]DáHMZLDGRPHMVZ\FK]DGDLVZHJRSRZRáDQLDILOR]RILF]QHMP\OLHXURSHMVNLHM3LNQLH QDSLVDá R W\P F]áRZLHN NWyU\ QLH E\á ³IDFKRZ\P ILOR]RIHP DOH NWyUHJR NRQWDNW ] U]HF]\ZLVWRFLQDFHFKRZDQ\E\áJáELGRMDNLHMQLHND*GHPXGDQHMHVWVL]EOL*\ü 1 2GF]\WZ\JáRV]RQ\ZGQLXVW\F]QLDUZED]\OLFH22'RPLQLNDQyZZ.UDNRZLHZF]DVLHXURF]\VWRFLNX czci Z7RPDV]D]$NZLQX7HNVW]RVWDáRSXEOLNRZDQ\Z:6WUy*HZVNLIstnienie i sens, Znak, Kraków V,7G]LNXMHZ\GDZQLFWZX³=QDN ]D]JRGQDXPLHV]F]HQLHWHNVWXQDQDV]HMVWURQLH 2 Z$XJXVW\Q:\]QDQLD;,F\WZJWáXPDF]HQLDZ.Kubiaka, Warszawa 1978, s

2 ³3U]\FKRG]L PL QD P\O ± F]\tamy w napisanym przez ks. Aleksandra Fedorowicza /LFLHGR Przyjaciela±*HPHWDIL]\NDMHVWQLF]\PLQQ\PMDNUH]XOWDWHPLQWHQV\ZQHJRSU]H*\FLD U]HF]\ZLVWRFL VZRMHJR ZáDVQHJR LVWQLHQLD L WHJR ZV]\VWNLHJR FR QDV RWDF]D -HVW RQD SUyE ]DPNQLFLDZNDWHJRULDFKSRMüWHJRZLHONLHJRZVWU]VXNWyU\SU]H*\ZDUR]XPQDLGRUHIOHNVML ]GROQDLVWRWD SU]\ ]HWNQLFLX VL ] U]HF]\ZLVWRFL 0R*QD SU]H*\ü FDOH *\FLH L QDSLVDü G]LHáR ILOR]RILF]QH D QLH ]DXZD*\ü WHJR *H VL MHVW QLH SU]H*\ü Z VRELH ZSURZDG]DMFHJR Z ]GXPLHQLH NRQWDNWX ] LVWQLHQLHP >@ )HE\ PyF ILOR]RIRZDü WU]HED ZSU]yG SU]H*\ü WR FR SU]H*\á QDJL *UHN OH*F QD JRUF\P SLDVNX QDG PRU]HP 3DWU]\á QD ]LHORQH NRQWXU\ Z\VS\ ]DWRSLRQHZVáRFXQDEáNLWQLHED6á\V]DáOHNNLHFKOXSRWDQLHIDOLNWyUDUD]SRUD]SRGELHJDáD REOHZDMF PX QRJL FLHSá ZRG L QDJOH ]UR]XPLDá *H MHVW :VWU]VDMFD SUDZGD U]HF]\ZLVWRFLZGDUáDVLZMHJRZLDGRPRüSRSU]H]RF]\LXV]\ZFLVNDáDVLND*G\PSRUHP UR]JU]DQHM VNyU\ 3R UD] SLHUZV]\ SU]H*\á Z SHáQL U]HF]\ZLVWRü ZLDWD NWyU\ JR RWDF]Dá U]HF]\ZLVWRüVZHJRZáDVQHJRFLDáDVZRMHMP\OL:VWDáL]DF]áDVLILOR]RILD%H]WDNLHJRF]\ LQQHJR SU]H*\FLD PHWDIL]\F]QHJR QLH PD L QLH EG]LH ILOR]RILL ZH ZáDFLZ\P WHJR VáRZD znaczeniu 3 Tyle ks. Aleksander )HGRURZLF] 3U]\JRWRZDQL MHJR JáERN UHIOHNVM ZUyüP\ ponownie do naszego podstawowego pytania ³&RWR]QDF]\LVWQLHü" 1 3LHUZV]D NRQFHSFMD LVWQLHQLD NWyUD SRMDZLD VL Z RGSRZLHG]L QD WR S\WDQLH SRFKRG]L RG 3DUPHQLGHVD±MHGQHJR]W\FK*UHNyZNWyU]\QLHW\ONRNáDGOLSRGZDOLQ\PHWDIL]\NLHXURSHMVNLHM DOHLRGUD]XMDNE\ZEá\VNXREMDZLDMFHJRQDWFKQLHQLDGRSURZDG]LOLMGR]DZURWQ\FKZ\*\Q DEVWUDNF\MQHJRP\OHQLD ³,VWQLHMFHMHVWLMHVWGODQLHPR*OLZHE\QLHE\áRQLHLVWQLHMFHQLHMHVWLQLHPR*HE\ü 3R]RUQLH ]GDQLD WH PyZL EDUG]R QLHZLHOH SU]HFLZVWDZLDM W\ONR jest nie jest, w RU\JLQDOHQLHSUHF\]XMQDZHWSRGPLRWXVZ\FKHJ]\VWHQFMDOQ\FKRU]HF]H$SU]HFLH*ZáDQLH G]LNL WHPX SU]HFLZVWDZLHQLX ]RVWDáR XFKZ\FRQH F]\VWH LVWQLHQLH 7\P FR PR*H E\ü przeciwstawione istnieniu, jest jedynie nicqlhpr*olzhgrsrp\ohqlddsu]hflh*qlh]egqhgr WHJR E\ Z RJyOH PyF Z\UD]Lü WR QDMEDUG]LHM SRGVWDZRZH GRZLDGF]HQLH Z NWyU\P XFKZ\WXMHP\WR*HFRMHVWJest, a nie nie jest. Jest i tylko jest. Wykluczenie istnienia wszelkiej QHJDW\ZQRFL SURZDG]L GRVWZLHUG]HQLD*H WR FR MHVW PXVLE\üDEVROXWQLHWR*VDPH]VRE=DFKRG]LWR*VDPRüPLG]\LVWQLHQLHPLW\PFRMHVWJG\* sens jestqlhgrsxv]f]d*dgqhjr]uy*qlfrzdqld=gdmhvrelhvsudz*hwrfrwxpyzlmhvwmx* SHZQGRüGDOHNRLGFLQWHUSUHWDFMP\OL3DUPHQLGHVDMHGQDN*HEH]MDNLHMLQWHUSUHWDFMLZ RJyOHRWHMP\OLPyZLüVLQLHGD7RWH*VG]*HQDS\WDQLH³FRWR]QDF]\LVWQLHüE\ü" PR*QD w duchu Parmenidesa RGSRZLHG]LHü E\ü ]QDF]\³E\üWR*VDP\P =WHJRZ\QLNDMGDOV]HZQLRVNL$EVROXWQDWR*VDPRüZ\NOXF]DZV]HONQLHWR*VDPRü Z\UD*DMFVLZUy*QLF\]PLHQQRFLZLHORFLJest E\WXMFHJRVSUDZLDZLF]HMHVWRQRQLH ]Uy*QLFRZDQHZHZQWU]QLHQLH]PLHQQHMHGQRLMHG\QH1LHGDVLJRSR]QDüLQDF]HMQL*SU]H] F]\VW NRQWHPSOXMF P\O $OHE\WQLH MHVW MHM SU]HGPLRWHP 0\OHü ± ]QDF]\ P\OHü E\FLH VNRURMHGQDNE\FLHMHVWDEVROXWQLHSURVWHLZ\NOXF]DMFHZV]HONLHUy*QLFHZ\NOXF]DüPXVLWDN*H Uy*QLFPLG]\VREVDP\PDP\O-HOLWHG\LVWQLHMHP\OLLVWQLHMHE\WWRPXV]E\ü]HVRE WR*VDPH,VWRWQLH r \ýsd U YRŸ Y DU YUŸ1DLŸLYDLP\OHüERZLHPL E\üMHVWW\PVDP\PDOEREDUG]LHMGRVáRZQLHWRVDPRLVWQLHMHGODP\OHü i dla E\ü.,VWQLHMFHD]DUD]HPDEVROXWQLHWR*VDPHQLHGRSXV]F]DMX**DGQHJRS\WDQLDRSRGVWDZ 3.VLG]$OHNVDQGHU)HGRURZLF]5R]ZD*DQLDLP\OL3R]QDPallottinum 1971, s.254 i 255 2

3 VZHJRLVWQLHQLDRMHJRUDFM]DVDGûp±B. Sam byt, ro ŸDY MHVWGODVLHELHSRGVWDZ0\O QLH]QDMGXMHWXUDFMLGRSRVWDZLHQLDMDNLHJRNROZLHNS\WDQLD³,VWQLHMFHMHVW LQLFSRQDGWR 7DN RWR MX* QD VDP\P SRF]WNX ]RVWDáR X]\VNDQH PR*OLZLH QDMF]\VWV]H D ]DUD]HP QDMEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQLHSRP\ODQHSRMFLHE\WXLVWQLHQLD0\OHXURSHMVNDQLHUR]VWDQLHVL]QLP MX* QLJG\ EG]LH SU]\ZLHFDáR MHM MDNR QDMZáDFLZV]\ SU]HGPLRW P\OHQLD ± D ]DUD]HP ZH]ZDQLHGRQLHXVWDQQHJR]JáELDQLDMHJRWDMHPQLF\=DSDPLWXMHP\WNRQFHSFMMDNRSLHUZV] ]WU]HFKNWyU\PSRZLFRQHVQDV]HUR]ZD*DQLDE\ü±WRE\üWR*VDP\P 2 $OHZW\PVDP\PF]DVLHZNWyU\PVZNRQFHSFME\WXZ\SUDFRZ\ZDá3DUPHQLGHVSRMDZLáDVL P\O LQQD RSDUWD QD UDG\NDOQLH RGPLHQQ\P GRZLDGF]HQLX LVWQLHQLD,VWQLHQLH WR SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLPVWDZDQLHVLLQLHXVWDQQD]PLHQQRü-HGQRüU]HF]\ZLVWRFLQLH]DVDG]DVLQDF]\P VWDW\F]Q\P OHF] MHVW ] LVWRW\ VZHM G\QDPLF]QD MDN SHáHQ G\QDPL]PX SRGREQ\ GR ZLHF]QLH QLHVSRNRMQHJR RJQLD MHVW U]G]F\ ZLDWHP /RJRV 7DN Z QDMZLNV]\P VNUyFLH VWUHFLü E\ PR*QDZL]MU]HF]\ZLVWRFLUR]WDF]DQSU]H]+HUDNOLWD 2Q VDP Z VZ\P M]\NX VNUyWRZ\P DIRU\VW\F]Q\P L SHáQ\P SU]HQRQL VWDUD VL QLH W\ONR XFKZ\FLü VDP IHQRPHQ LVWQLHQLD VWDZDQLD VL ]PLDQ\ DOH L ]JáELü MHJR ]DVDG NWyU XSDWUXMHZZDOFHSU]HFLZVWDZQ\FKVLáWZRU]F\FKVNGLQGQLHUR]HUZDOQMHGQRü ³%yJMHVWGQLHPLQRF]LPLODWHPZDONLSRNRMHPV\WRFLLJáRGHPL ulega zmianom WDNMDNRJLHNWyU\]PLHV]DQ\]UR*Q\PLNDG]LGáDPLQD]\ZDVLUy*QLHVWRVRZQLHGR]DSDFKX ND*GHJR]QLFK ³ZV]\VWNRMHVWMHGQRFLWRFRSRG]LHORQHLQLHSRG]LHORQHVWZRU]RQHLQLHVWZRU]RQH PLHUWHOQHLQLHPLHUWHOQHORJRVZLHF]QRüRMFLHFV\QEyJVSUDZLHGOLZRü ³-HGQ\PLW\PVDP\PMHVWZQDV*\ZHLXPDUáHWRFRF]XZDLWRFRSLPáRGHLVWDUH SRQLHZD*WHU]HF]\VWDMVLSRVZHM]PLDQLHWDPW\PLDWDPWH]QRZSRVZHM]PLDQLHVWDMVL tymi 4 Na pytanie: co to znaf]\lvwqlhü+hudnolwpyjáe\zlfrgsrzlhg]lhüvárzdplbergsona: ³LVWQLHü]QDF]\]PLHQLDüVL $OH]GDQLHWRX]DVDGQLDLQDF]HMQL*%HUJVRQFKRüQLHSRZLHWHJR ZSURVW GD GR ]UR]XPLHQLD *H X SRGVWDZ ]PLHQQRFL OH*\ NRQIOLNW NWyU\ RVWDWHF]QLH PXVL E\ü NRQIOLNWHP PLHG]\ E\ü L QLHE\ü 7DN Z ND*G\P UD]LH ]LQWHUSUHWXMH Z ODSLGDUQ\P VIRUPXáRZDQLXMHJRP\O$U\VWRWHOHVªavra Ÿivai 1ai BŸLYDL : wszystko jest i nie jest.. 1LHE\WQLHZ\NOXF]DVL]E\WHPSU]HFLZQLHZFKRG]LZMHJRLVWRWZ\WUFDMFJRW\PVDP\P] MHJRQLHUXFKRPRFLQLH]PLHQQRFL]HVWDW\F]QHM3DUPHQLGHVRZVNLHMMHGQRFL )LOR]RIHPNWyU\Z\FLJQáZV]\VWNLHNRQVHNZHQFMH]ILOR]RILL+HUDNOLWDGRSURZDG]LáMH GR ]DZURWQ\FK Z\*\Q PHWDIL]\F]QHJR P\OHQLD L ZUHV]FLH QD LFK SRGVWDZLH ]EXGRZDá VZyM ZáDVQ\V\VWHP±E\á+HJHO³1LHPDDQLMHGQHJR]GDQLD+HUDNOLWD±PyZLáZVZ\FKVá\QQ\FK Z\NáDGDFK]KLVWRULLILOR]RILL±NWyUHJRQLHXZ]JOGQLáE\PZVZRLPV\VWHPLH 1LH]QDF]\WR ZV]DN*HE\XMHJRSRGVWDZOH*DáDW\ONRP\O+HUDNOLWD+HJHOQDOH*\GRW\FKILOR]RIyZNWyU]\ PDM QLH]Z\NOH JáERNLH SRF]XFLH ZL]L ] ILOR]RILF]QD WUDG\FM : W\P WDN*H ] WUDG\FM QDMRGOHJOHMV] 2ERN +HUDNOLWD +HJHO VWDZLD 3DUPHQLGHVD ] MHJR LGHDáHP P\OHQLD XFKZ\WXMFHJR QDMF]\VWV]H D ]DUD]HP QDMEDUG]LHM DEVWUDNF\MQH SRMFLH E\WX *G\ +HJHO SU]\VWSL GR WáXPDF]HQLD RVWDWHF]Q\FK XZDUXQNRZD VWDZDQLD VL ]PLDQ\ RGZRáD VL GR SU]HFLZLHVWZDF]\VWHJR%\FLDLF]\VWHJR1LFNWyUH±]JRGQLH]+HUDNOLWHPDRGPLHQQLHQL*X 4 &\WZJ)LOR]RILDVWDUR*\WQD*UHFMLL5]\PXWHNVW\Z\EUDáLZVWSHPSRSU]HG]Lá-DQLegowicz, Warszawa 1968, s

4 3DUPHQLGHVD ± QLH Z\NOXF]DM VL OHF] WZRU] MHGQRü 3DUPHQLGHVRZVND ]DVDGD WR*VDPRFL RJUDQLF]RQD SLHUZRWQLH GR VDPHJR E\WX ]RVWDMH UR]FLJQLWD QD E\W L MHJR SU]HFLZLHVWZR REHMPXMH Z Z\*V]HM GLDOHNW\F]QHM L ± MDN PyZL +HJHO ³QLHVSRNRMQHM MHGQRFL E\FLH L QLHE\FLH%\WL1LF3U]\SRPQLMP\MDNEU]PLSRF]WNRZHD]DUD]HPQDMEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZH WZLHUG]HQLDRWZLHUDMFHJáyZQ\]UE+HJORZVNLHMNauki logiki Wissenschaft der Logik: ³%\W F]\VW\ E\W ± EH] MDNLFKNROZLHN GDOV]\FK RNUHOH : VZRMHM QLHRNUHORQHM EH]SRUHGQLRFLUyZQDVLWHQE\WW\ONRVRELHVDPHPXD]DUD]HPQLHMHVWF]\PFRQLHUyZQD VLWHPXFRLQQHQLHPD*DGQHMUy*QRFLDQLZVRELHVDP\PDQLQD]HZQWU]VLHELH%\WWHQ± JG\E\Z\Uy*QLDQRZQLPMDNLHRNUHOHQLHOXEWUHüDOERJG\E\]RVWDáG]LNLWHPX]DáR*RQ\MDNR Uy*Q\ RG F]HJR LQQHJR ± QLH PyJáE\ E\ü XWU]\PDQ\ Z VZRMHM F]\VWRFL %\W MHVW F]\VW QLHRNUHORQRFL L SXVWN -HOL PR*QD WX PyZLü R RJOGDQLX ± WR QLH PR*QD Z QLP niczego RJOGDüDOERLQDF]HMPyZLFMHVWW\PF]\VW\PSXVW\PRJOGDQLHPVDP\P3RGREQLHQLHPDZ QLP QLF]HJR R F]\P PR*QD E\ P\OHü DOER LQDF]HM PyZLF MHVW W\ONR VDP\P SXVW\P P\OHQLHP%\WQLHRNUHORQDEH]SRUHGQLRüMHVWIDNW\F]QLHNiczymLQLF]\PZLFHMDQLQLF]\P PQLHMQL*1LF 5 :W\PWUXGQ\PWHNFLHSUDZLHND*GHVáRZRZ\PDJDáRE\NRPHQWDrza. Przede wszystkim: MDN WáXPDF]\ü QLHPLHFNLH Sein? F]DVRZQLNRZR F]\ U]HF]RZQLNRZR" =D SU]\NáDGHP $ /DQGPDQDPyZL%\W$OHZ\GDMHVL*HZáDFLZV]HE\áRE\VáRZR%\FLH%\WRZDQLHDQDZHW Istnienie: wszak Heglowskie Sein znajduje swoje historyczne zakorzenienie w einai 3DUPHQLGHVD0R*HMHGQDNWHUPLQ³LVWQLHQLH ]DFKRZDüQDOH*\GRE\FLDRNUHORQHJRDasein, w NWyU\P ZSUDZG]LH PRPHQW\ E\FLD L QLF]HJR ]DZLHUDM VL WDN*H NWyUH MHGQDN VDPR SU]HFLZVWDZLDVLRNUHORQHPXQLHLVWQLHQLX" %\FLHL1LFVQDMZ\*V]\PLDEVWUDNWDPL]DUD]HPMHGQDNVUHDOQ]DVDGZV]\VWNLHJRFR MHVW : SHZQ\P VHQVLH SU]HNUDF]DM ]QDQH PR*OLZRFL SR]QDQLD MHOL WH PLDá\E\ E\ü RJUDQLF]RQH GR SR]QDZDQLD SRMFLRZHJR %\FLH L 1LF V SU]HGPLRWDPL F]\VWHM P\OL DOH rozumianej raczej jako intuicja. Anschauung QLH MDNR MDNLNROZLHN G\VNXUV 5yZQRF]HQLH V WDN*H PRPHQWDPL NWyUH ZDUXQNXM ZV]HONLH RNUHORQH LVWQLHQLH ZV]DN ± MDN PyZL +HJHO ³QLJG]LHDQLQDQLHELHDQLQD]LHPLQLHPDWDNLHJR&]HJRNWyUHE\QLH]DZLHUDáRZVRELHREX momentów Bytu Niczego. Pierwszym przejawem tej jedni jest VWDZDQLHVLEGFHUXFKHP ³EH]SRUHGQLHJR ]DQLNDQLD MHGQHJR ] GUXJLP 'DOV]\P MHM SU]HMDZHP MHVW VDPR RNUHORQH istnienie, DaseinNWyUH±ZSU]HFLZLHVWZLHGRQLHRNUHORQHJR6HLQMHVWE\FLHPRNUHORQ\P NRQNUHWQ\P L GODWHJR XMDZQLDM VL Z QLP RG UD]X OLF]QH RNUHOHQLD Uy*QRURGQH VWRVXQNL PLG]\MHJRPRPHQWDPL 6 +HJORZVNUHIOHNVMQDGSUREOHPDW\N%\WXL1LF]HJRSRGMáZQDV]\FKF]DVDFKMartin +HLGHJJHU $OH SRGV]HGá GR QLHM RG LQQHM VWURQ\ QLH spekulatywnie, jak Hegel, lecz w SHUVSHNW\ZLHIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHJRGRZLDGF]HQLD$UyZQRF]HQLHVWDQáZQRZ\PUDG\NDOQLH WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQ\P SXQNFLH Z\MFLD DNFHSWXMF WR FR EH]SRUHGQLR GDQH SRV]XNXMH FRUD] GDOV]\FKXZDUXQNRZDMHJRPR*OLZRFL &]árzlhn GDQ\ MHVW VDPHPX VRELH MDNR ³E\W SU]\WRPQ\ HJ]\VWXMF\ ³WX RWR MDNR Dasein:]DVLJXMHJREH]SRUHGQLHJRSR]QDQLD]QDMGXMVLRNUHORQHE\W\LVWQLHMFHU]HF]\± 6HLHQGHQ 2QH WR VWDQRZL JáyZQ\ SU]HGPLRW QDV]HJR FRG]LHQQHJR SUDNW\F]QHJR D WDN*H L QDXNRZHJR ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLD -HG\QLH Z U]DGNLFK Eá\VNDFK V]F]HJyOQHJR ZUF] HNVWDW\F]QHJR GRZLDGF]HQLDZLDWDXZLDGDPLDP\VRELH*HQLHZ\F]HUSXMHJRPQRJRüRNUHORQ\FKE\WyZ :VWU]VDMF\P SRF]XFLHP WUZRJL RG]\ZD VL FR FR SU]HNUDF]D MH ZV]\VWNLH FR UDG\NDOQLH Uy*QL VL RG QLFK QLH MHVW QLF]\P ] QLFK MHVW 1LF]\P ³1LFRü ± F]\WDP\ Z Czym jest metafizyka"qlhmhvwsu]hgplrwhpqlhmhvwrqdzrjyohe\whp1lfrüqlhqdgfkrg]lvdpdgod 5 G.W.F. Hegel Nauka logiki,su]hár*\álremdqlhqldplrsdwu]\á$gdplandman, tom I, Warszawa 1867, s Jw.s.97 i

5 VLHELH DQL RERN E\WX GR NWyUHJR E\ PLDáD QLHMDNR SU]\VWDZDü 1LFRü MHVW ZDUXQNLHP NWyU\ XPR*OLZLDXMDZQLHQLHVLZREHFOXG]NLHMSU]\WRPQRFLE\WXMDNRWDNLHJR1LFRüQLHWZRU]\SR SURVWX SRMFLD SU]HFLZVWDZQHJR GR SRMFLD E\WXDOH OH*\ X (UyGáD VDPHM LVWRW\ : E\FLX E\WX GRNRQXMHVLQLFRFLRZDQLHQLFRFL 7 %\FLH E\WX WR SRMHFLH MHVW WX QDMZD*QLHMV]H 7R GR %\FLD GRSURZDG]Lü PLDáR GRZLDGF]HQLH1LFRFL±WRSU]H]QLDFLOHMZQLHMZáDQLHPR*HVLRQRSU]HMDZLü=DF\WXMP\ raz jeszcze Heideggera: ³&]\VWHE\FLHLF]\VWH1LFVZLFWym samym. To zdanie Hegla pozostaje prawomocne. %\FLH L QLFRü ZVSyáWZRU] VL UD]HP DOH QLH GODWHJR*H ] SXQNWX ZLG]HQLD +HJORZVNLHJR SRMFLDP\OHQLD±]ELHJDMVLZVZHMQLHRNUHORQRFLOHF]GODWHJR*HVDPRE\FLHMHVWZVZHM LVWRFLHVNRF]RQHLXMDZQLDVLW\ONRZWUDQVFHQGHQFMLGRNRQ\ZDQHMSU]H]E\WSU]\WRPQ\NWyU\ SU]HNUDF]DE\WNXQLFRFL 8 ³/HF] E\FLH ± F]\P*H MHVW E\FLH" 2QR ± WR RQR VDPR 0\OHQLH PXVL Z SU]\V]áRFL QDXF]\üVLWHJRGRZLDGF]DüLWRZ\SRZLDGDü³%\FLH WRQLHMHVWDQL%yJDQL]DVDGDZLDWD %\FLHMHVWGDOHML]DUD]HPEOL*HMF]áRZLHNDQL*ZV]HONLE\WF]\EG]LHQLPVNDáD]ZLHU]G]LHáR V]WXNL PDV]\QD DQLRá F]\ %yj %\FLH MHVW W\P QDMEOL*V]\P /HF] EOLVNRü RZD SR]RVWDMH GOD F]áRZLHNDF]\PFRQDMGDOV]H&]áRZLHN]DZV]HLSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPWU]\PDVLE\WX0\OHQLH SU]HGVWDZLDMFE\WZL*HVLZSUDZG]LH]E\FLHPDOHQDSUDZGP\OLRQR]DZV]HE\WMDNRWDNL a nigdy bycie jako takie. 9 0XVLP\ SRSU]HVWDü QD W\FK F\WDWDFK XND]XMF\FK ]UHV]W MHG\QLH SLHUZV] ID] +HLGHJJHURZVNLHJR QDP\VáX QDG E\FLHP 1LHFKDM WR FR ]RVWDáR SRZLHG]LDQH GR WHM SRU\ Z\VWDUF]\GOD XZ\GDWQLHQLDU]HF]\GOD QDVZ WHM FKZLOL QDMZD*QLHMV]HM FKDUDNWHU\VW\NL GZyFK NRQFHSFMLLVWQLHQLD3LHUZV]D]QLFKRGJUDQLF]DMFQDMFLOHME\FLHRGQLHE\FLDLVSURZDG]DMF E\FLHGRWR*VDPRFLXQLHUXFKDPLDMHRGZUDFDVLRGZV]HONLHMZLHORFLL]PLDQ\DXWU]\PXMF SU\PDWF]\VWHJRP\OHQLDZSR]QDQLXWUDNWXMHGDQHZV]HONLHJRSR]DP\ORZHJRGRZLDGF]HQLD MDNR]áXG 'UXJD ZLHUQLHMV]D SHáQHPX GRZLDGF]HQLX DNFHQWXMH G\QDPLF]QRü E\FLD DOH E\ WR RVLJQüXWR*VDPLDMH]QLFRFLDOERMHOLWDNPR*QDSRZLHG]LHüSU]H]QLFRü³SU]HSURZDG]D 5yZQRF]HQLH WUDNWXMH WDN SRZVWDá MHGQL MDNR QDMRJyOQLHMV] ZV]HFKRJDUQLDMF ]DVDG ] NWyUHM E\W\ Z\áDQLDM VL MDN ]H VZHJR RVWDWHF]QHJR ZDUXQNX ] arche jak z apeironu Anaksymandra. &]\ MHVW NRQFHSFMD LVWQLHQLD NWyUD ]DFKRZXMF MHJR G\QDPLF]QRü SRWUDILáDE\ UyZQRF]HQLH SU]HFLZVWDZLü MH QLFRFL D X]QDMF MHJR SRZV]HFKQRü XVWU]HF VL SU]HG ]DWRSLHQLHPZRJyOQRFL" &LHQND QLWND LQWXLFML SR]ZDODMFHM OHG]Lü DQDORJLF]QH ]QDF]HQLD Z VáRZDFK LVWQLHQLH bycie, Sein, einai, ŸivaiZWOHMHQDPWHUD]GRJUDQLFPR*OLZRFL&]\QDGDOEG]LHP\PyZLOLR W\P VDP\P" :VSRPQLHOLP\ QD SRF]WNX *H GR URG]LQ\ SU]HG FKZLO Z\PLHQLRQ\FK VáRZ QDOH*\WDN*HáDFLVNLHesse.=QDMGXMHP\VLDZND*G\PUD]LHFKFHP\VL]QDMGRZDüZNUJX PHWDIL]\NL L WR QDZHW JG\E\P\ ± SRSU]H] Heideggerowskie rozumienie Sein, dotykali jej JUDQLF7HUD]ZUDFDP\GRMHMFHQWUXPE\XFKZ\FLüWU]HFLNRQFHSFMLVWQLHQLD±esse. 7 Martin Heidegger, %XGRZDüPLHV]NDüP\OHü(VHMHZ\EUDQH:\EUDáRSUDFRZDáLZVWSHPRSDWU]\á.U]\V]WRI Michalski, Warszawa 1977,s Jw.,s /LVWR³KXPDQL]PLH WáXPJ.Tischner, w:m.heidegger, op.cit.s.93. 5

6 3 &]\PMHVWLVWQLHQLH":VáXFKDMP\VLZRGSRZLHG(NWyUQDWRS\WDQLHGDMHZ7RPDV] 2WRIUDJPHQWDUW\NXáXNZHVWLLQuestiones disputatae De potentia Dei: To, co nazywam istnieniem (Quod dico esse)mhvwsruygzv]\vwnlhjrqdmgrvnrqdov]h$ Z\QLND WR VWG *H DNW MHVW ]DZV]H GRVNRQDOV]\ RG PR*QRFL (actus est semper perfectior potentia.d*gsu]hflh*rnuhorqirupsr]qdmhp\dnwxdoqlhw\onrg]lnlwhpx*hrqdlvwqlhmh (esse SRQLWXU ³&]áRZLHF]HVWZR F]\ ³RJQLVWRü PR*HP\ ZSUDZG]LH UR]SDWU\ZDü MDNR HJ]\VWXMFHZPR*QRFLPDWHULLDOERZG]LHOQRFLVSUDZF\DOERWH*ZLQWHOHNFLHWRMHGQDNFR SRVLDGDLVWQLHQLHGRSHáQLDVLSRSU]H]DNWLVWQLHQLD6WGZ\QLND*HWRFRQD]\ZDPLVWQLHQLHP MHVWDNWXDOQRFLZV]\VWNLFKDNWyZDG]LNL WHPXGRVNRQDáRFL ZV]\VWNLFKGRVNRQDáRFL1LH QDOH*\MHGQDNVG]Lü*HGRWHJRFRQD]\ZDPLVWQLHQLHPPR*HE\üGRGDQHFRFRE\áRE\RGH bardziej istotne (formaliusl RNUHODáRE\LVWQLHQLHMDNDNW RNUHOD PR*QRü LVWQLHQLH ERZLHP G]LNL NWyUHPX FR Z MDNLNROZLHN VSRVyE MHVW MHVW F]\P LVWRWRZR Uy*Q\P RG WHJR GR F]HJR GRGDMH VL MDNLHNROZLHN RNUHOHQLD 7RWH* QLH PR*QD GRGDü GR LVWQLHQLD QLF]HJR FR E\áRE\ ]HZQWU]QHZREHFQLHJRJG\*SR]DQLPQLHPDQLFSUyF]QLHE\WXNWyU\QLHPR*HE\üDQLIRUP DQLPDWHUL6WGLVWQLHQLHQLHPR*HE\üGHWHUPLQRZDQHSU]H]FRLQQHJRMDNPR*QRüSU]H]DNW OHF]UDF]HMMDNDNW SU]H] PR*QRü >@ 'ODWHJR WH* PyZL 'LRQL]\ Z2 LPLRQDFK ER*\FK *H FKRFLD* E\W\ *\MFH V V]ODFKHWQLHMV]H RG W\FK FR W\ONR HJ]\VWXM WR MHGQDN LVWQLHQLH MHVW V]ODFKHWQLHMV]HRG*\FLDE\W\R*\ZLRQHPDMERZLHPQLHW\ONR*\FLHDOHZUD]]*\FLHPPDM WDN*HLVWQLHQLH 7DN SU]HGVWDZLD VL Z QLHFR GRZROQ\P WáXPDF]HQLX WHNVW Z 7RPDV]D $ EU]PL WX SHZQH QXW\ QLHF]VWR VSRW\NDQH Z MHJR SLVPDFK 3U]HGH ZV]\VWNLP SU]HPDZLD Z SLHUZV]HM osobie:quod dico esse. &KFH ]DDNFHSWRZDü *H MHJR UR]XPLHQLH WHJR VáRZD MHVW LQQH QL* E\áR SU]\MPRZDQHGRWHMSRU\&]\*QLH]DXZD*DP\ZW\FK]GDQLDFKSRF]XFLDRGSRZLHG]LDOQRFL]D WR FR VL Z QLFK VWZLHUG]D L Z]LFLD RGSRZLHG]LDOQRFL QD VLHELH ± ]D QRZ SHUVSHNW\Z PHWDIL]\NLMDNDVLWXRWZLHUD".RQFHSFMLQLHGRVNRQDáRFLF]\FKRüE\W\ONRQLHRNUHOQRFLesse zostaje przeciwstawiona koncepcja radykalnie odmienna: To, co nazywam istnieniem,jest SRUyGZV]\VWNLHJRQDMGRVNRQDOV]H =DFKRZDMP\WNROHMQRüMDNSU]\MáZ7RPDV]QDSLHUZV]HPLHMVFHZ\VXQLWDMHVW GRVNRQDáRü LVWQLHQLD SRWHP SU]\FKRG]L X]DVDGQLHQLH WHJR VWZLHUG]HQLD LVWQLHQLH MHVW DNWHP 3RU]GHN ³Z\QLNDQLD SU]\MW\ Z X]DVDGQLHQLX MHVW WX Z\UD(QLH LQQ\ QL* SRU]GHN GRZLDGF]HQLD$RQRSR]ZDODPyZLüRGRVNRQDáRFLesseMDNRRF]\PEH]SRUHGQLRGDQ\P =ZUyüP\ XZDJ *H Z WHM F]FL ]GDQLD NWyUH X]DVDGQLD RZ GRVNRQDáRü QLH MHVW QDZHW SRZWyU]RQHVáRZResseXWR*VDPLHQLHLVWQLHQLDLDNWXSR]RVWDMHZGRP\OH1DWRPLDVWZ]GDQLX QDVWSQ\PGRNRQXMHVL]DELHJRGZURWQ\QLHX]DVDGQLDVLGRVNRQDáRFLLVWQLHQLDSRSU]H]DNW OHF]DNWXDOQRüZW\PSU]\SDGNXIRUP\SRSU]H]LVWQLHQLH5ROHVL]PLHQLDMJG\QDSRF]WNX PLHOLP\ RGZRáDQLH VL GR DNWX MDNR RF]\ZLVWHJR ZDUXQNX X]DVDGQLDMFHJR GRVNRQDáRü istnienia (actus est perfectior potentiawhud]vdprlvwqlhqlhx]dvdgqldgrvnrqdárüdnwx:\qlnd ]WHJR]UHV]WMHV]F]HMHGQRMHOLLVWQLHQLXSU]\SLVXMHVLGRVNRQDáRüQDWHM]DVDG]LH*Hactus est semper perfectior potentiasrgnuhodvluyzqrf]hqlh*hlvwqlhqlhmhvw]dzv]hdnwhpmhvwzlf DNWHP V]F]HJyOQ\P NWyU\ QLH PR*H Z MDNLP LQQ\P XNáDG]LH VWDü VL PR*QRFL MDN WR VL G]LHMHQS]IRUPNWyUDPLPR*HMHVWDNWHPZSRU]GNXLVWRW\MHVWUyZQLF]HQLHPR*QRFLZ stosunku do aktu esse): Nec intelligendum est, quod ei quod dico esse, aliquid addatur quod sit eo formalius...,vwqlhqlhmhvwdnwhp$ohlvwqlhqlhmhvwwdn*hzduxqnlhpdnwxdoqrflf]hjr1lfqlhpr*h E\üX]QDQH]DDNWXDOQHMHOLQLHMHVW7RLVWQLHQLHVWDQRZL*HFRMHVWDNWHP±QLHRGZURWQLH. 6

7 A wobec tego istnienie jest aktem par excellence, ZH ZáDFLZ\P ]QDF]HQLX VáRZD ³DNW ZV]\VWNLH LQQH DNW\ V W\ONR ³DQDORJLF]QH ZREHF DNWX LVWQLHQLD $NW MHVW ZLF LVWQLHQLHP LVWQLHQLHMHVWDNWHP'ODWHJRWRFRMHVWLQDF]HMQL*ZDNFLH±QDSUDZGQLHMHVWWR]DFRMHVWMHVW in actu 7DN RWR ] NUJX LVWQLHQLD ]RVWDMH Z\NOXF]RQD ZV]HOND SRWHQFMDOQRü ZLUWXDOQRü LQWHQFMRQDMQRü6WRSHZQHJRURG]DMXHJ]\VWHQFMHDOHMDNRHJ]\VWHQFMHQLHEGFHZDNFLHQLH PDMSUDZDGRPLDQDLVWQLHQLD,VWQLHQLHMHVW³HJ]\VWHQFMZDNFLH &RWRMHGQDN]QDF]\" 3U]HGHZV]\VWNLPPXVLP\Z\]E\üVLQDLZQHJRSU]HZLDGF]HQLD*HX]QDQLHWR*VDPRFL esse = actus jest ze strony Tomasza jedynie zastosowaniem Arystotelesowskiej teorii aktu- PR*QRFLGRZáDVQHMNRQFHSFMLLVWQLHQLD 3U]HGZV]HONWHRULQDOH*\XPLHFLüGRZLDGF]HQLH,QWXLFMH]ZL]DQH]SRMFLHPDNWX SRSURVWXRGVáDQLDMMDNVLRND]XMHMHGHQ]DVSHNWyZGRZLDGF]HQLDLVWQLHQLD2GVáDQLDMMHJR G\QDPLF]QRü7RFRQDSUDZGMHVWLVWQLHMHZVSRVyE]GROQ\GRV]F]HJyOQHMVDPRLVWQRFLGR XWU]\PDQLD VL Z VZ\P E\FLH -X* WR Z\PDJD PLQLPXP PHWDIL]\F]QHM ³HQHUJLL F]HJR Z URG]DMXVLá\³SRGWU]\PXMFHM E\W1LH]QDMG]LHP\MHMZesencjalnej strukturze bytu, albowiem VLáDWDQLHZDUXQNXMHZU]HF]\WHJRczymOXEFRRQDMHVWOHF]WR*HMHVWLjak jest. EvŸS\ŸLD WRSRJUHFNXZáDQLHDNW7U]HEDPLHüSLHUZRWQ³HQHUJL E\FLD E\E\üF]\P3RPLP\QD UD]LH SLHUZRWQ ³HQHUJL E\FLD E\ E\ü F]\P 3RPLP\ QD UD]LH QDU]XFDMFH VL WX S\WDQLH VNGVLWD³HQHUJLD ELHU]HDZLFG]LNLF]HPXMHVWWRFRMHVW=ZUyüP\XZDJQDMHV]F]HLQQ NRQVHNZHQFM WU]HED Z WHQ V]F]HJyOQ\ ZáDQLH ³HQHUJLF]Q\ VSRVyE E\ü F]\P E\ PyF QDU]XFLüVLMDNRLVWQLHMFHMDNRE\W±LGDüVL]QDOH(üGDüVLGRZLDGF]\üGDüVLRGVáRQLü 3R]QDQLHWHRUHW\F]QH³VSHNXODW\ZQH ZSU]HFLZLHVWZLHGRSUDNW\F]QHJRMHVWVSRZRGRZDQH ³QDU]XFHQLHP VL U]HF]\ XP\VáRZL NWyUHPX ³GDM VL MDNR DNW\ZQRü UXFK...intellectus speculativus [...] est quodammodo motus ab ipsis rebus, et ita res mensirant ipsum. 10.Na tym ZáDQLHSROHJDSUDZGD ktora jest warunkiem, a nie wynikiem poznania: Hoc est ergo quod addit verum supra ens, scilicet conformitatem, ut dictum est, sequitur cogbitio rei. Sic ergo entitas rei praecedit rationem veritatis, sed cognitio est quidam veritatis effectus 11 'ODWHJR7RPDV]PR*H ]DDNFHSWRZDü]DUyZQRWRFRPyZLRSUDZG]LHZ$XJXVW\Q(Verum est id quod est), MDNLZ Hilary (veritas est manifestativum et declarativum esse) 12 7DNRWRZUDFDP\GRSRMFLDSUDZG\ MDNRRGVáRQLFLD±manifestatio i do bytu jako pierwszego przedmiotu intelektu.,vwqlhqlh±xwu]\pxmfhcou]hf]\lqdu]xfdmfhvlmdnrvdprlvwqhmestf]hjrgrzldgf]dqhmhvw jako fakt7hjrvwzlhug]hqldqlhpdzwhnflhz7rpdv]ddohfk\edqlhpdzwsolzrfl*hwdn WRZáDQLHUR]XPLDá7RFRMHVWW\ONRin potentia materiae albo in virtute agentis, albo wreszcie in intellectu, QLH MHVW F]\P FR GRV]áR GR VZHJR ZáDVQHJR LVWQLHQLD GRNRQDáR VL MHGQ\P VáRZHP]DLVWQLDáRde facto.:nd*g\p]su]\wrf]rq\fkwxsu]\sdgnyzpdp\grf]\qlhqld] HJ]\VWHQFMZQDMGRNáDGQLHMV]\PUR]XPLHQLXVáRZDex-sistere:FRNROZLHNMHVWZPR*QRFLF]\ to biernej, czy czynnej, czy wreszcie w intelekcie, jako przedmiot czysto intencjonalny, FKRFLD*E\MX*MDNR]DPLDUSURMHNWF]HJRU]HF]\ZLVWHJR±MHVWFLJOH³QDXWU]\PDQLX F]HJR LQQHJRMHVW]DZV]HF]\PZ\áDQLDMF\PVLDOHQLH]GROQ\PGRVWDQLDVLVDPRG]LHOQ\P-HV]F]H LQDF]HMVZHJRIXQGDPHQWXE\WRZHJRQLH]QDMGXMHZVRELHMDNRZáDVQHJResse, lecz zawsze w esse F]HJR GUXJLHJR, WDNLHM ZáDQLH HJ]\VWHQFML D UDF]HM WDNLP HJ]\VWHQFMRP JG\* UR*QH PRJ E\ü LFK modi, SU]HFLZVWDZLD VL LVWQLHQLH GRSHáQLDMFH L GRSHáQLRQH RNUHORQH UyZQRF]HQLHMDNRactus i jako perfectio-dnrzádvqhlvwqlhqlhf]hjrunumquodque est suum proprium essemhvwuyzqlhlqg\zlgxdoqhlqlhsrzwdu]doqhmdnwrf]hjrmhvwlvwqlhqlhpzlfhm± WR G]LNL QLHPX ZáDQLH RZR FR MHVW F]\P QDSUDZG LQG\ZLGXDOQ\P QLHSRZWDU]DOQ\P 10 De veritate,1 2c 11 Jw.,1, 1c 12 -Z6]HU]HMQDWHQWHPDW]RE7U]\Z\PLDU\SUDZG\Z:áDG\VáDZ6WUy*HZVNL,VWQLHQLHLZDUWRü.UDNyZ s

8 jedynym.,vwqlhqlhmhvwzlf]dzv]hlvwqlhqlhpf]hjr&rlvwqlhmfh±wre\wens. Istotowa strona E\WXDZLFWRFRELHU]HP\SRGXZDJRGSRZLDGDMFQDS\WDQLH³FRWRMHVW" QDU]XFDQDPVL bardziej SLHUZV]RSODQRZRQL*MHJRLVWQLHQLH³)HMHVW F]HJRMHJRLVWQLHQLHGDQHMHVWZSUDZG]LH UyZQLHEH]SRUHGQLRDOHLQDF]HM±WDNEDUG]RLQDF]HM*HVDPEH]SRUHGQLRüGDQLDRZHJR³*H MHVW RGNU\ZDP\QLHNLHG\±U]HF]SDUDGRNVDOQD± GURJ UHIOHNVMLJG\ XZLDGDPLDP\ VRELH L* ³QDU]XFHQLHVL QDPF]HJRNROZLHNE\áRE\QLHPR*OLZHJG\E\SRSURVWXQLHLVWQLDáR,VWQLHQLH ³SU]HQLND LVWRWDOHQLHXWR*VDPLDVL]QL$U\VWRWHOHV]DXZD*\áUy*QLFPLG]\S\WDQLHP³FR MHVW" L ³F]\ MHVW" DOH QLH GRVWU]HJá NRQLHF]QRFL RGUy*QLHQLD LVWRW\ L LVWQLHQLD ³&]áRZLHN L ³F]áRZLHNLVWQLHMF\ WRZHGOHQLHJRMHGQRLWRVDPR'OD7RPDV]DWDZáDQLHUy*QLFDVWDQLHVL QDMZD*QLHMV]D ]H ZV]\VWNLFK hoc auten quod est esse, in nullis creaturae ratione perfecte inchuditur; cuiislibet enim creaturae esse est aliud ab eius quidditate 13 Nie ma tu potrzeby rozwijania 7RPDV]RZHM WHRULL UHDOQHM Uy*QLF\ PLG]\ LVWRW D LVWQLHQLHPZE\FLHUR*Q\PRG%RJD$OHGODXZ\GDWQLHQLDMHV]F]HMHGQHJRXMFLDesse musimy SRVWDZLüS\WDQLHRUROMDN VSHáQLDRQRZFDáRFL F]HJRLVWQLHMFHJRDZLFZNRQNUHWQ\P E\FLH2GSRZLDGDMFQDWRS\WDQLH7RPDV]RGZRáXMHVLZ\UD(QLHGR$U\VWRWHOHVRZVNLHMWHRULL DNWX L PR*QRFL -HOL FR MHVW G]LNL VZHPX ZáDVQHPX LVWQLHQLX unumquodque est per suum proprium esse) WR ]QDF]\ WR L* UDFM IDNWX LVWQLHQLD WHJR F]HJR ³*H MHVW F]HJR MHVW SU]\VáXJXMF\PXDNWLVWQLHQLD:SRU]GNXZNWyU\PUR]ZD*DP\LPPDQHQWQVWUXNWXUE\WX WR VWZLHUG]HQLH MHVW RVWDWHF]QH 1LH MHVW RVWDWHF]QH JG\ SRVWDZLP\ GDOV]H S\WDQLH R UDFM SU]\VáXJLZDQLD F]HPX LVWQLHQLD D ZLHF JG\ ]DF]QLHP\ GRFLHNDü GODF]HJR Z RJyOH FR MHVW Teraz jednak niepokoi nas inna sprawa. 2WRX]\VNDOLP\V]HUHJWZLHUG]HQDWHPDWLVWQLHQLD±esse. Istnienie jest aktem istoty, ³LVWQLHQLH MHVW DNWHP ± HQHUJL ³LVWQLHQLH MHVW GRVNRQDáRFL -DNL FKDUDNWHU PDM WH WZLHUG]HQLD" :LG]LHOLP\ *H ]D ND*G\P ] QLFK NU\M VL MDNLH V]F]HJyOQH GRZLDGF]HQLD ] NWyU\FKND*GH]DVáXJXMHQDPLDQRGRZLDGF]HQLDPHWDIL]\F]QHJR$OHF]\G]LNLQLHPXDUDF]HM G]LNLQLPSU]HQLNQOLP\VZRLVWRüLVWQLHQLDF]\ZLHP\MX*F]\PRQRMHVW³VDPRZVRELH a wiec nie w aspekcie jakiegokolwiek jako DNWX IDNW\F]QRFL GRVNRQDáRFL" 1LF QLH VWRL QD SU]HV]NRG]LHSRVWDZLHQLDWDNLHJRS\WDQLD±DOHF]\MHVWPR*OLZDMDNDNROZLHNQDQLHRGSRZLHG(".D*GH ] SU]\WRF]RQ\FK SRZ\*HM WZLHUG]H PR*H E\ü UR]XPLDQH GZRMDNR MDNR DQDOLW\F]QH OXE MDNR V\QWHW\F]QH : SLHUZV]\P SU]\SDGNX Z\GRE\ZDá\E\ RQH RNUHORQH PRPHQW\ SU]\QDOH*QH ] NRQLHF]QRFL LVWQLHQLX L RNUHODMFH MH ³MDNR WDNLH,QDF]HM EH] QLFK LVWQLHQLH QLH E\áRE\ LVWQLHQLHP : GUXJLP SU]\SDGNX ]ZL]HN LVWQLHQLD VDPHJR ] QLPL E\áRE\ IDNW\F]Q\ZSUDZG]LHDOHE\áDE\GRSRP\OHQLDV\WXDFMDUDG\NDOQLHJUDQLF]QDXMDZQLDMFDW\ONR L Z\áF]QLH F]\VWH MHVW F]HJR SU]\ F]\P RZR FR E\áRE\ WDN*H SRG ND*G\P Z]JOGHP QLHRNUHORQH=GDQLH]De potentia: nihil auten potest addi ad esse quod sit extraneum ad ipso LQWHUSUHWRZDOLE\P\ZWHG\ZVHQVLHQDMEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQ\PUR]XPLHMFSU]H]extraneumND*G\ orzecznik QLHWR*VDP\ ] HVW D ZLHF QLH GRSXV]F]DMF GR SRVáX*HQLD VL MDNLPNROZLHN RU]HF]QLNLHPZ RJyOH :WHG\ ZV]HODNR WU]HED UyZQLH UDG\NDOQLH ]LQWHUSUHWRZDü GUXJ F]ü cytowanego tu zdania: cum ab eo (scil. esse W.S.) nihil sit extraneum nisi non-ens2gsrzlhg( RGZRáXMH VL ZLF GR QHJDFML ± L GR ³SRMFLD UDG\NDOQHJR QLHE\WX, MHVW WR MHG\Q\ VSRVyE RGSRZLHG]L MDNL MHVW WX Z RJyOH PR*OLZ\ 0yZLF REUD]RZR ]QDMGXMHP\ VL ³QD NUDFDFK bytu. Czyste jest XMDZQLDVLW\ONRLZ\áF]QLHZNRQWUDFLH]F]\VW\Pnie-jest wynikiem UDG\NDOQHJR SU]HNUHOHQLD XQLFHVWZLHQLD F]HJRNROZLHN 3RVWDZP\ ³NURSN QDG L ZáDFLZH UR]XPLHQLH LVWQLHQLD X]\VNDü PR*QD W\ONR SRSU]H] ZáDFLZH UR]XPLHQLH QLHLVWQLHQLD ± L RGZURWQLH 6 RQH LVWRWQLH QDMFLOHM ]H VRE VSU]*RQH DOH ± Z SHUVSHNW\ZLH PHWDIL]\NL Tomasza z $NZLQX±VSU]*RQHLQDF]HMQL*WRZLG]LHOL+HJHOF]\Heidegger. Czyste istnienie, 13 De veritate, 10, 12c. 8

9 bycie (Sein ± MHOL RF]\ZLFLH ZROQR VSURZDG]Lü esse i sein do wspólnego mianownika nie XWR*VDPLDVLZ*DGQ\PDVSHNFLH]F]\VW\PQLHLVWQLHQLHP(Nichts, NichtsseinSR]RVWDMRQHZ VZHMEH]Z]JOGQHMSLHUZRWQRFLDEVROXWQLHUDG\NDOQLHUy*QHFKRüZV]HONDSUyEDEOL*V]HJRLFK RSLVDQLDJUR]LRGUD]XQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZHPVSHNXODFMLSURZDG]FHMGRLFKXWR*VDPLHQLD&]\VWH jestqlhsrmdzldvlwdn*h³qdwoh³qlfrfl0yzlhqlhr³woh ZRGQLHVLHQLXGRQLFRFLMHVWMX*MHM LQWHUSUHWDFMSU]\GDQLHPMHMF]HJRFR³]LVWRW\ PXVLE\ü]QLHMUDG\NDOQLHZ\NOXF]RQH&]\VWH jest i czyste nie jest V MHGQDNRZR QLHRNUHORQH D MHGQDN PLPR WHM QLHRNUHORQRFL ]DFKRG]L PLG]\QLPLUy*QLFDQDMJáEV]DLQDMEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQDMDNGDVLZRJyOHSRP\OHü$UDF]HM MDNLHMSRP\OHüVLQLHGD7\ONRRQD]DVáXJXMHQDPLDQRUy*QLF\PHWDIL]\F]QHM-HMRSLVQLHMHVW PR*OLZ\ 6SUyEXMP\GRNRQDüMHV]F]HMHGQHJRSU]\EOL*HQLDEDGDQHMWXVSUDZ\=Dáy*P\*H]GDQia, R NWyU\FK PRZD³LVWQLHQLHMHVW V QLHMDNR DQDOLW\F]QH, ZUyüP\ GR WHNVWXZ 7RPDV]D EsseLVWQLHQLH±UR]XPLDQHMDNRDNWQLHZVHQVLHF]HJR³QDG LVWQLHQLHPDNWXDOL]XMF\PMH OHF]MDNRDNWXWR*VDPLDMF\VL]QLPDZLFLVWQLHQLHDNWQLHDNWLVWQLHQLDMHVWW\PF]HPXQLF QLHPR*HMX*]RVWDüSU]\GDQH0DMF]GROQRüDNWXDOL]RZDQLDF]HJRNROZLHNL³PLHV]DQLDVL ] F]\PNROZLHNVDPRQLHPR*HE\üSU]H]QLFDNWXDOL]RZDQH1LHPD*DGQHJRDNWX³SRQDG DNWHP LVWQLHQLDQLHPDDNWXZVWRVXQNXGRNWyUHJRRQRVDPRVWDüE\VLPRJáRPR*QRFL,VWQLHQLH DNW Z\NOXF]D PR*OLZRü SU]HMFLD Z MDNNROZLHN SRVWDü QLHDNWX F]\OL Z PR*QRü -DNR RVWDWHF]QH³GRSHáQLHQLH LVWQLHMFHJRE\WXZ\NOXF]DMDNLNROZLHNDNW³QDGVRE 7RFRMHVW LQDF]HMLVWQLHMFHE\Wjest w akciedoerqlhmhvwzfdoh&]\p³]hzqwu]q\p ZVWRVXQNXGR LVWQLHQLDDNWXMHVWW\ONRQLFRüMHJRVDPHJR7DN*HZW\PSU]\SDGNXMHVWWRRVWDWHF]QDLQWXLFMD MDNDMHVWQDPGRVWSQDJG\XVLáXMHP\XFKZ\FLüLVWQLHQLHMDNRLVWQLHQLH%\FLH±DOERUDG\NDOQH QLHE\FLH QLH Z VHQVLH MDNLHMNROZLHN SRWHQFMDOQRFL MDNLHJR kolwiek nie bycia takim oto czy LQQ\P OXE WH* QLHE\WX ZREHF WDNLHJR F]\ LQQHJR E\WX OHF] QLHE\FLH Z VHQVLH UDG\NDOQHJR SU]HNUHOHQLD LVWQLHQLD L UDG\NDOQHJR Z\NOXF]HQLD JR QLHE\FLH Z VWRVXQNX GR VDPHJR E\FLD (esse)qlh]doh*qlhrgwhjrmdnle\wrqrnrqvw\wxxmh 3U]HNUHOHQLHLVWQLHQLDE\FLDesseF]HJR MHVWRF]\ZLFLHUyZQRZD*QHXQLFHVWZLHQLX FDáRFLF]HJR LVWQLHMFHJR ± DZLFWHJR RWR NRQNUHWQHJR E\WX 1LHPR*QD ³RGMü F]HPX LVWQLHQLD Z WDNL VSRVyE E\ WR FR QLH SU]HVWDáR LVWQLHü Z VZHM FDáRFL E\ FRNROZLHN ] QLHJR ³]RVWDáR -DNLMHVWZREHFWHJR]ZL]HNLVWQLHQLDDNWX]W\PF]HJRMHVWDNWHP" -HOLMHG\Q³]HZQWU]QRFL ZREHFLVWQLHQLDMHVWQLFRünihil, to stosunek istnienia do MDNLHJRFRZUDPDFKLVWQLHMFHJRNRQNUHWXPXVLE\üVWRVXQNLHPQDMEDUG]LHMZHZQWU]Q\P,WDN ZLG]LWRZáDQLHZ7RPDV]Esse autem est illud quod est magis intimum cuilibet rei, et quod profundius omnibus inest, cum sit dormale respectu omnium quae in re sunt. 14. Wedle SRUyZQDQLDF]VWRX*\ZDQHJRSU]H]Z7RPDV]DLVWQLHQLHPDVLWDNGRLVWRW\MDNZLDWáRGR SU]H]URF]\VWHJR FLDáDdiaphanum ']LNLZLDWáX XMDZQLDVL VDPD QDWXUD SU]H]URF]\VWRFL ± DOH MHM MDNRü ] NROHL GHF\GXMH R FKDUDNWHU]H ZLDWáD NWyUH SU]H] QL SU]HQLND XOHJDMF VZRLVWHPX RJUDQLF]HQLX Z\QLNDMFHPX ] MHM QDWXU\ 0R*QRü RJUDQLF]D DNW NWyU\ M SU]H]Z\FL*D =DOH*QRü MHVW ZLF WX GZXVWURQQD FKRü QLH V\PHWU\F]QD ZREHF V]F]HJyOQHM ³Z\*V]RFL DNWXQDGPR*QRFL1LHPQLHMMHGQDNPR*QRüSU]\SRU]GNRZDQDDNWRZLLVWQLHQLX MHVWF]\PWDNZD*Q\P*HZáDQLHRGQLHMVWDQRZLFHMSU]HFLH*ZW\P]áR*HQLXLVWRWU]HF]\ ]DOH*\ VSRVyE LVWQLHQLD GDQHJR E\WX D Z NRQVHNZHQFML Uy*QRü LVWQLHQLD WHJR RWR E\WX RG ND*GHJRLQQHJRUy*QRüGHF\GXMFDRVZRLVW\PSOXUDOL]PLHHJ]\VWHQFMDOQ\PZLDWD =ZUyüP\ MHV]F]H XZDJ QD RVWDWQLH ]GDQLH DQDOL]RZDQHJR SU]H] QDV tekstu:..licet viventia sint nobiliora quam existentia, tamen esse est nobilius quam vivere, viventia enim non tantum habent via, sed cum vita simul habent et esse. Oto esse ujawnia tu jeszcze jeden swój DVSHNWDVSHNWZDUWRFLZW\PSU]\SDGNXZ\UD(QLHZDUWRFLRQW\F]QHMERGRW\F]FHMVWUXNWXU\ 14 67,DGSRGNUHOHQLDPRMH±:6 9

10 VDPHJRE\WXNRQNUHWXMDNRZDUXQNXMDNLHMNROZLHNLQQHMRQW\F]QHMZDUWRFL=DXZD*P\SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP*HPDP\WXGRF]\QLHQLD]GZLHPDSDUDPLSRMüviventia existentia, vita esse. ExistentiaWRRF]\ZLFLHSU]HGPLRW\PDWHULDOQHQLHR*\ZLRQH:KLHUDUFKLLE\WyZ]DMPXM RQHQL*V]HPLHMVFHDQL*HOLSU]HGPLRW\*\ZH$OHMHGQHLGUXJLHVQLHG]LNLWHPX*HNRQVW\WXXM MH WDNLH F]\ LQQH IRUP\ VXEVWDQFMDOQH IRUPD FLDáD QLHRUJDQLF]QHJR Z pierwszym,a forma RUJDQL]PX*\ZHJRZGUXJLPSU]\SDGNXOHF]*HNRQVW\WXXMMHHJ]\VWHQFMDOQLHtzn, VSUDZLDM*H VRNUHORQHDNW\LVWQLHQLD6DPDIRUPD*\FLDQLHMHVWUDFMLVWQLHQLDE\WX*\ZHJRGRNáDGQLHZ WDNLPVDP\PVWRSQLXMDNQLHMHVWQLPIRUPD³]Z\NáHJR FLDáDPDWHULDOQHJR-HOLWRFR*\ZH jest, WR GODWHJR *HSUyF]IRUP\ ± DNWX *\FLD PDWDN*HDNW LVWQLHQLD %H]QLHJR QLHW\ONR QLH E\áRE\ F]\P *\Z\P DOH E\áRE\ QLF]\P Z RJyOH,VWQLHQLH esse, jako warunek wszelkiej U]HF]\ZLVWHM Z SHáQL ]DNWXDOL]RZDQHM ZDUWRFL VDPR PXVL E\ü WUDNWRZDQH MDNR ZDUWRü -HOL SHáQLD optimum MDNLHM ZDUWRFL ]DOH*\ RG MHM UHDOL]DFML DNWDOL]DFML WD ]D GRNRQXMH VL Z\áF]QLHZRSDUFLXRLVWQLHQLHDNWLVWQLHQLDZROQRQDNRFXUD]MHV]F]HSRZLHG]LHüWRFR ]RVWDáRSRZLHG]LDQHQDSRF]WNX.hoc quod dico esse est actualitas omnium actuum, et propter hoc est perfectio omnium perfectionum. I jes]f]hmhgqr*g\$u\vwrwhohvpyzlárdnflhpldáqdp\olsu]hghzv]\vwnlpirup 'OD Z 7RPDV]D DNW WR SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP esse 7HRULD LVWRW\LVWQLHQLD VWDQRZL ZLF QLH W\ONR V]F]HJyOQ\ SU]\SDGHN RJyOQLHMV]HM WHRULL PR*QRFLDNWX 3U]HFLZQLH Z MHM ZLHWOH WHRULD PR*QRFLDNWX XOHJD ]DVDGQLF]HM PRG\ILNDFML VWDMH VL WHRUL E\FLD E\WX WáXPDF]F E\W Z DVSHNFLHWHJR*HMHVW1DW\PSROHJD]DVDGQLF]DUy*QLFDPLG]\P\OPHWDIL]\F]Q7RPDV]DD NRQFHSFM$U\VWRWHOHVD 4 =DQDOL]RZDOLP\W\ONRMHGHQNUyWNLWHNVWZ7RPDV]D$OHMX*QDWHMSRGVWDZLHXPLHP\MDNVL ]GDMH RGSRZLHG]LHü QD S\WDQLH NWyUH SRVWDZLOLP\ XSU]HGQLR RWR ]QDOH(OLP\ NRQFHSFM istnienia, wedle której: MHVWRQRF]\PLQG\ZLGXDOQ\PSU]\VáXJXMF\PZQLHSRZWDU]DOQ\VSRVyEWHPXLW\ONRWHPX konkretnemu bytowi, MHVW F]\P G\QDPLF]Q\P ]DUyZQR VDPR Z VRELH MDN L Z VWRVXQNX GR FDáRFL VWUXNWXU\ HVHQFMDOQHMNWyUDNWXDOL]XMH DZUHV]FLHZ\NOXF]DVLDEVROXWQLH]QLHE\WHP]QLFRFL]DFKRZXMFZ\áF]QLHGODVLHELH ZáDFLZHVHPDQW\F]QHRGQLHVLHQLHF]DVRZQLNDjest. 8SUDV]F]DM]DFDáRüQDV]\FKGRW\FKF]DVRZ\FKUR]ZD*DPRJOLE\P\QDVWSXMFRVWUHFLü trzy omówione koncepcje istnienia: ZHGOHSLHUZV]HM³LVWQLHü ]QDF]\³E\üWR*VDP\P ZHGOHGUXJLHM³LVWQLHü WRSU]HNUDF]DüE\WDW\PVDP\PWZRU]\üMHGQLE\FLDLniebycia; ZHGOHWU]HFLHM³LVWQLHü WRE\üDNWHPVSUDZLDMF\P*HFRjest,a nie QLHMHVWD]DUD]HPE\ü GRVNRQDáRFLZV]\VWNLFKGRVNRQDáRFL 3\WDQLHNWyUHWHUD]QD]DNRF]HQLHQDV]\FKUR]ZD*DPXVL]RVWDüSRVWDZLRQHEU]PLSRSURVWX NWyUD]W\FKNRQFHSFMLMHVWSUDZG]LZD"1LHRGZD*VLQDQLHRGSRZLHG]LHü$OHQLHFKZROQRPL EG]LH ]DSURSRQRZDü SHZQ SUyE NWyUD ± E\ü PR*H ± U]XFL QD WH WU]\ NRQFHSFMH ZLDWáR SR]ZDODMFHOHSLHMMH]UR]XPLHü 6WRLP\QDJUXQFLHPHWDIL]\F]QHJRGRZLDGF]HQLDU]HF]\ZLVWRFL:UR*Q\VSRVyEPR*HVLRQR REMDZLDüZPQLHMOXEEDUG]LHMX]DVDGQLRQ\FKSU]HZLDGF]HQLDFKZVWZLHUG]HQLDFKKLSRWH]DFK DOH WDN*H ± Z S\WDQLDFK -HGQR ] S\WD VWDZLDQ\FK ZREHF U]HF]\ZLVWRFL D UyZQRF]HQLH 10

11 X]DVDGQLRQ\FK MHM DXWHQW\F]QLH PHWDIL]\F]Q\P GRZLDGF]HQLHP ]RVWDáR SUHF\]\MQLH VIRUPXáRZDQHSU]H/HLEQL]DEU]PLRQR ³'ODF]HJRLVWQLHMHUDF]HMFRDQL*HOLQLF" 'RSRZLHG]P\XNU\WH]DáR*HQLHWHJRS\WDQLD dlaczego istnieje, VNRURPRJáRE\QLHLVWQLHü? 15 JHOLS\WDQLHWRMHVWLVWRWQLH]DVDGQLF]HZPHWDIL]\FHWRSRVWDZLHQLHJRZREOLF]XRZ\FK WU]HFK UR]SDWU\ZDQ\FK GRWG NRQFHSFML LVWQLHQLD PR*H SRJáELü QDV]H UR]H]QDQLH QD WHPDW LFK SUDZG]LZRFL3RGHMPLMP\WSUyE 3U]HGHZV]\VWNLPRND*HVL*HQLHPR*QDS\WDü³GODF]HJRMHVW" ZREHFE\WXNWyU\MHVW DEVROXWQLH WR*VDP\ ] VRE ³7R FR MHVW ± MHVW L QLH PR*H QLH E\ü : WHQ VSRVyE ]RVWDMH ]OLNZLGRZDQH]DáR*HQLHQDV]HJRS\WDQLDRSLHUDMFHVLQDGRZLDGF]HQLXPR*OLZRFLniebycia, nieistnienia,. Byt 3DUPHQLGHVD Z\NOXF]D ± MHGQ\P VáRZHP ± PR*OLZRü ]DS\W\ZDQLD R MHJR UDFMRQVDPMHVWUDFM]DVDGapx 3R]RVWDMHWHG\DOERRGU]XFLüWNRQFHSFME\WXDOER]D QLH]DVDGQHX]QDüS\WDQLHLZDUXQNXMFHMHGRZLDGF]HQLHLVWQLHQLD3\WDQLH³'ODF]HJRZRJyOH MHVWUDF]HME\WQL(OL1LF VWDZLDQDWRPLDVWexpressis verbis Heidegger. Czyni to w swej rozprawie Czym jest metafizyka? QDSLVDQHM Z URNX DOH ZUDFD GR QLHJR ZLHORNURWQLH Sy(QLHM QLHXVWDQQLHSRJáELDMF]DUyZQRVHQVVDPHJR]DS\W\ZDQLDMDNLGDZDQ\FKQDRGSRZLHG]L 3\WDQLH ³GODF]HJR MHVW MHVW S\WDQLHP R ]DVDG UDFM Grund. Postawione w okresie pisania Sein und Zeit GRSURZDG]LáRGRZQLRVNX*H]DVDGLVWQLHMFHJRE\WXSeiende, jest samo bycie Sein. :W\PNLHUXQNXLGZND*G\PUD]LHGRFLHNDQLDUR]SUDZ\Czym jest metafizyka? $OHJáEV]\QDP\VáQDGLVWRWSein XMDZQLD*HZJUXQFLHU]HF]\MHVWRQRW\PVDP\PFR Nichts. W tej perspektywie S\WDQLH GODF]HJR FR LVWQLHMH UDF]HM QL* QLH LVWQLHMH" WUDFL VZ GUDPDW\F]QRVWURüZV]DNZV]\VWNRFRMHVWX]DVDGQLRQHMHVW]DUyZQRSU]H]%\FLHMDNLSU]H] 1LF PXVL ZLF ] LVWRW\ VZHM E\ü L QLH E\ü+HLGHJJHU GRVNRQDOH ]GDMH VRELH ] WHJR VSUDZ 3\WDQLHRUDFMMHOLZRJyOHPDPLHüVHQVPXVLE\üQLHMDNRSU]HVXQLWHGDOHM:]DNRF]HQLX do napisanego po dwudziestu latach Wprowadzenia do tekstu Czym jest metafizyka?, Heidegger S\WD &RSR]RVWDMHZLNV]]DJDGNWR*HMHVWE\WF]\WR*HMHVWE\FLH" 6]XNDQLHUDFML%\FLD]PLHQLDVLVWRSQLRZRZSRV]XNLZDQLHUDFMLMHJR³Z\GDU]HQLDVL F]\³REMDZLHQLD :DUXQNLHPRWZDUFLDVL %\FLDMHVWVDPDRWZDUWRü %\FLHVWDMHVL REHFQH G]LNLZLDWáXNWyUHSURPLHQLRZDüPR*HMHG\QLHZZROQHMSU]HVWU]HQLSU]HZLWX:LFHMWRRQ XPR*OLZLD V]F]HJyOQ ³JU ZLDWáD L FLHQLD %\FLD L 1LFRFL 3U]HZLW MHVW WHG\ ZDUXQNLHP PR*OLZRFLLUDFMMHGQHJRLGUXJLHJR &]\PR*QDE\LüMHV]F]HGDOHM±LV]XNDüUDFMLSU]HZLWX":\GDMHVL*HQLH2GNU\WRü SU]HZLWX XWR*VDPLD VL ] SUDZG SUDZG Z QDMJáEV]\P L QDMZáDFLZV]\P ]QDF]HQLX VáRZD aletheia]qdf]fhjrsrsurvwxqlhvnu\wrü:qdxfhzilor]rillzp\ohqlxqlhpr*qdlügdohm DQL*HOL VLJD SUDZGD 2QD X]DVDGQLD RF]\ZLVWRü P\OHQLD ³'URJD L PHWRGD ZV]HONLHM P\OL ILOR]RILF]QHMNWyUDMDZQLHOXEQLHLG]LH]DZH]ZDQLHP³GRU]HF]\VDPHM SURZDG]LSU]H]ZROQ SU]HVWU]HSU]HZLWX SLV]H+HLGHJJHUZHVHMX.RQLHFILOR]RILLL]DGDQLHP\OHQLD 16 'RV]OLP\WHG\GRRVWDWHF]QHJRXZDUXQNRZDQLDPR*OLZRFLP\OHQLDDWDN*HGR(UyGáD PR*OLZRFLREMDZLHQLDVL%\FLD&]\MHGQDN±SR]ZyOP\VRELHQDWRS\WDQLH±QLH]DWUDFLOLP\ SRGURG]HLVWRWQHJRVHQVXLVWQLHQLD"&]\PHWDIRUDZLDWáDLSU]HZLWXQLHSU]HVáRQLáD±ZEUHZ LQWHQFML]MDN]RVWDáDX*\WD±]Z\NáHJRD]DUD]HPSRGVWDZRZHJRVHQVXVáRZDjest? Czy, w JUXQFLHU]HF]\QLHE\á\PXEOL*V]HLQWXLFMH]ZL]DQH]MHGQRFLE\FLDLQLF]HJRZ\NRU]\VWDQH przez Hegla i ZHZF]HQLHMV]HMP\OL+HLGHJJHUD"1LHNWyU]\P\OLFLHOH SR]RVWDMF\]UHV]W SRG ZSá\ZHPL urokiem filozofii +HLGHJJHUD ZUDFDM GR W\FK ZáDQLH LQWXLFML &]\QL WR P LQ ZLHONL 15 Por. dalej (cz.iii) rozdzial zasadnicze pytanie metafizyki HLGHJJHU.RQLHFILOR]RILLL]DGDQLHP\OHQLDtlum. Krzysztof 0LFKDOVNLZ'URJLZVSyáF]HVQHMILOR]RILL Z\EUDáLZVWSHPRSDWU]\á0DUHN-Siemek, Warszawa 1978, s

12 protestancki teolog Paul Tillich. Czytamy w jego Courage To Be. 17 Odwaga bycia(the courage to be) we wszystkich swych formach posiada, z samej siebie, FKDUDNWHUREMDZLDMF\8ND]XMHQDWXUE\WXXND]XMH*HVDPRDILUPDFMDE\WXMHVWDILUPDFME\WX MHVWDILUPDFMNWyUDSU]H]Z\FL*DQHJDFM:\UD*DMFVLPHWDIRU\F]QLHDND*GHWZLHUG]HQLHR E\FLH VDP\P MHVW EG( PHWDIRU\F]QLH EG( V\PEROLF]QH PR*QD SRZLHG]LHü *H E\W ]DZLHUD QLHE\WOHF]QLHE\WQLH]Z\FL*DJR³=DZLHUDQLH MHVWPHWDIRUPyZLF*HE\WREHMPXMHVDP VLHELH L WR FR MHVW PX SU]HFLZQH ± QLHE\W 1LHE\W SU]\QDOH*Q\ GR E\WX QLH PR*H E\ü RGH RGG]LHOQ\ 1LH PRJOLE\P\ QDZHW SRP\OHü ³E\WX EH] SRGZyMQHM QHJDFML E\W PXVL E\ü P\ODQ\MDNRQHJDFMDQHJDFMLE\WX2WRGODF]HJRRSLVXMHP\E\WQDMOHSLHMSRSU]H]PHWDIRU³VLá\ bycia (power of being) 6LáD MHVW PR*OLZRFL DNWXDOL]XMF E\W ZREHF RSRUX LQQ\FK E\WyZ *G\ PyZLP\ R VLOH VDPHJR E\WX ZVND]XMHP\ *H E\W DILUPXMH VLHELH SU]HFLZ QLHE\WRZL : QDV]HM G\VNXVML R RGZDG]H L *\FLX ZVSRPQLHOLP\ R G\QDPLF]Q\P UR]XPLHQLX U]HF]\ZLVWRFL SU]H]ILOR]RIyZ*\FLD7DNLHUR]XPLHQLHPR*OLZHMHVWW\ONRZWHG\MHOLDNFHSWXMHVLSRJOG*H QLHE\WSU]\QDOH*Q\GRE\WX*HE\WQLHPyJáE\E\üEH]QLHE\WXSRGVWDZ*\FLDSamoafirmacja E\WXEH]QLHE\WXQLHE\áE\QDZHWVDPRDILUPDFMOHF]QLHUXFKRPVDPRLGHQW\F]QRFL1LFQLH PRJáRE\ E\ü XMDZQLRQH QLF Z\UD*RQH QLF REMDZLRQH $OH QLHE\W Z\SURZDG]D E\W ] MHJR ]DPNQLFLD ]PXV]D GR DILUPRZDQLD VLHELH Z VSRVyE G\QDPLF]Q\ )LOR]RILD WUDNWRZDáD R dynamicznej VDPRDILUPDFML E\WX ]DZV]H JG\ SU]HPDZLDáD GLDOHNW\F]QLH V]F]HJyOQLH Z QHRSODWRQL]PLHX+HJODXILOR]RIyZ*\FLD7HRORJLDURELáDWRVDPRJG\WUDNWRZDáDQDVHULRLGH *\MFHJR%RJDZLGRF]QZVSRVyEQDMEDUG]LHMRF]\ZLVW\ZWU\QLWDUQHMV\PEROLFHZHZQWU]QHM *\FLD%RJD =DSDPLWDMP\WRRVWDQLHVWZLHUG]enie: nawet Bóg nie jest wolny od swoistej dialektyki E\WXLQLHE\WXZ\PDJDWHJR]DUyZQRMHJR³*\FLH MDN±ZV]F]HJyOQRFL±MHJR*\FLHZ7UyMF\,ZUyüP\±MX*SRUD]RVWDWQL±GRS\WDQLD³GODF]HJRUDF]HMMHVWFRDQL*HOLQLHMHVW" :WDNLPVIRUPXáRZDQLXQLH]QDMG]LHP\JRZWHNVWDFKZ7RPDV]D:\GDMHVLMHGQDN *H7RPDV]RZHGRZLDGF]HQLHLVWQLHQLDXSUDZQLDJRFDáNRZLFLHGRMHJRSRVWDZLHQLDZV]DNQD GRZLDGF]HQLXQLHNRQLHF]QRFL DOER LQDF]HMPyZLF SU]\JRGQRFL LVWQLHQLD RSDUWD MHVW MHJR PHWDIL]\ND EGFD QLF]\P LQQ\P MDN ZLHON SUyE ]QDOH]LHQLD NRQLHF]QHM UDFML IDNW\F]QHJR E\FLD ZLDWD -HGQD ] SLFLX GUyJ GRZRG]HQLD LVWQLHQLD %RJD WU]HFLD Z NROHMQRFL LFK wymienienia w 6XPPLH RGZRáXMH VL ZSURVW GR IDNWX SU]\JRGQRFL LVWQLHQLD ZLDWD MHJR IDNW\F]QHJRE\FLDLMHJRPR*OLZRFLQLHE\FLDUyZQRF]HQLH$SRGVWDZRZDSU]HVáDQNDWHMGURJL brzmi: quod possibile est non esse quandoque non est. 1DS\WDQLH³GODF]HJRMHVW" 7RPDV]RGSRZLHGODWHJR*HLVWQLHMH%\WZNWyU\P%\FLH XWR*VDPLDVL]MHJRLVWRW7RFRMHVWQDPGDQHZEH]SRUHGQLPPHWDIL]\F]Q\PGRZLDGF]HQLX to E\W\]NWyU\FKLVWRW\QLHZ\QLNDNRQLHF]QRüLVWQLHQLDDZLFE\W\NWyUHde facto VFKRü UyZQLHGREU]HPRJá\E\QLHE\ü%\W]NWyUHJRLVWRW\Z\QLND]NRQLHF]QRFLLVWQLHQLHQLHW\ONR QLHMHVWQDPEH]SRUHGQLRGDQ\MHVWGODQDVQLHGRSRMFLD 7DN RWR Z\FKRG]F ] WU]HFK NRQFHSFML LVWQLHQLD ³Z RJyOH GRWDUOLP\ GR GZyFK NRQFHSFML LVWQLHQLD DEVROXWQHJR 6WDQOLP\ X SURJX WDMHPQLF\ NWyUD Z\]QDF]D NUHV PHWDIL]\F]QHJR P\OHQLD 'ZLH NRQFHSFMH LVWQLHQLD V naszymi, tzn. ludzkimi koncepcjami. 0R*HP\MHGáXJRMHV]F]HEDGDüUR]WU]VDMFUR]ELHUDüUDFMHSU]HPDZLDMFH]DLSU]HFLZND*GHM ] QLFK $OH MHOL QDZHW QLH GRMG]LHP\ Z W\FK EDGDQLDFK GR NRFD QLH EG]LH WR ]QDF]\áR *H SUDZGDQLHLVWQLHMHOHF]W\ONR*HQLHSRWUDILP\MHMZSHáQLRVLJQü=WHJR]D*HQLHSRWUDILP\ MHMRVLJQüQLHPXVLZ\QLNDü*HQLHPR*HQDPE\üGDQD7RMHGQDNQLH]DOH*\MX*Z\áF]QLH RGQDVSRGREQLHMDNRGSLHOJU]\PDFKRüE\QDMEDUG]LHMZ\WUZDáHJRQLH]DOH*\EH]UHV]W\WR F]\RVWDWHF]QLHGRWU]HGRNRFDVZRMHMGURJL3yNLMHVWZGURG]HSHZQHMHVWGODW\ONRMHGQR*H MHV]F]H QLH RVLJQá FHOX 1D GURG]H SR]QDZDQLD ]QDF]\ WR SR SURVWX ZLHP *H MHV]F]H QLH 17 P.Tillich,The Courage To Be, New Haven 196o, s

13 wiem... Z7RPDV]ZDUW\NXOH10. kwestii De viritatepyzl³0gurüqlhsrohjdmhg\qlhqd W\PE\P\SR]QDOL*H%yJMHVWDeum essedohlqdw\pe\p\su]\eol*\olvlgrgrzlhg]hqld VL R 1LP WHJR F]\P MHVW quod HVW /HF] WHJR ZáDQLH SyNL MHVWHP\ Z GURG]H SR]QDü QLH MHVWHP\ZVWDQLHFK\EDRW\OHW\ONRRLOHSR]QDMHP\F]\P%yJQLHMHVW 5R]V]HU]HQLHP WHJR ZSURZDG]HQLD GR VSRWNDQLD PR*H E\ü WHNVW ³%yJ L ZLDW Z P\OL Z Tomasza z Akwinu, w: W. 6WUy*HZVNLIstnienie i sens, op.cit., s