FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 04/19/ :58 PM INDEX NO /2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 11 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/19/2017

Transkrypt

1 1 of 18

2 2 of 18

3 LNJK?G? =INKM MB? LM;M? H?P RIKE =INHMR H?P RIKE8 =IGG?K=C;F >COCLCIH m ( =B;HA? B?;FMB=;K? ( IJ?K;MCIHL* FF=* ( ( JaV^ci^[[* ( ( +V\V^chi+ ( ( P?<G> B?;FMB =IKJ,* ( >Z[ZcYVci, ( Q CcYZm Hd, UUUU C,;,L, JVgi UUUU +7584)16< JaV^ci^[[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ IeZgVi^dch* FF= (qjav^ci^[[r dg q=]vc\z BZVai]XVgZr) Wg^c\h i]^h VXi^dc V\V^chi >Z[ZcYVci PZWG> BZVai] =dge, (qpzwg>r) [dg YZXaVgVidgn* ^c_jcxi^kz* VcY di]zg gza^z[ VcY VaaZ\Zh Vh [daadlh8 6)<=9-7. <0- )+<176 /, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ VcY PZWG> VgZ evgi^zh id i]z ;bzcyzy VcY KZhiViZY >ViV F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci (Vh VbZcYZY* i]z qf^xzchz ;\gzzbzcir), M]Z evgi^zh ZciZgZY ^cid i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ^c 0..6, >jg^c\ i]z izgb* i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci egdk^yzh PZWG> i]z g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz YViV XdaaZXiZY Wn =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ, M]Z izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ZcYh 0./6, Hdil^i]hiVcY^c\ i]z jexdb^c\ izgb^cvi^dc YViZ* PZWG> ]Vh gz[jhzy id VX`cdlaZY\Z i]vi ^ih g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]^h YViV ZcYh 0./6 VcY ]Vh [jgi]zg ^begdezgan ViiZbeiZY id ZmigVXi dc\d^c\ evnbzcih [gdb hjwa^xzchzzh [dg i]z Xdci^cjZY jhz d[ i]z YViV [daadl^c\ i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, 0, L^cXZ /774* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ VcY-dg ^ih egzyzxzhhdgh ]VkZ egdk^yzy ]ZVai]XVgZ XaV^b hjwb^hh^dc hzgk^xzh VcY di]zg VYb^c^higVi^kZ* gzkzcjz* VcY evnbzci XnXaZ hdaji^dch id evndgh VcY egdk^yzgh ^c i]z ]ZVai]XVgZ ^cyjhign, M]gdj\] ^ih egdk^h^dc d[ hzgk^xzh* =]Vc\Z / 3 of 18

4 BZVai]XVgZ gzxz^kzh egdizxizy ]ZVai] ^c[dgbvi^dc (Vh YZ[^cZY Vi 23 s /4.,/.1) (qjbcr) [gdb ^ih ]ZVai]XVgZ ^cyjhign XjhidbZgh, M]gdj\] XdcigVXih l^i] bvcn d[ ^ih XjhidbZgh* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh hzxjgzy i]z g^\]i id jhz YViV VhhdX^ViZY l^i] ]ZVai]XVgZ XaV^bh id XgZViZ YZ+^YZci^[^ZY YViV (q>z+cyzci^[^zy >ViVr) ^c Xdbea^VcXZ l^i] i]z BZVai] CchjgVcXZ JdgiVW^a^in VcY ;XXdjciVW^a^in ;Xi (qbcj;;r), =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ i]zc a^xzchzh i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id i]^gy+evgin a^xzchzzh [dg YZkZade^c\ Veea^XVi^dch* egdyjxih* dg hzgk^xzh [dg i]z egdk^h^dc d[ ]ZVai]XVgZ dg [dg jhz ^c gzhzvgx], 1, 0..6* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ \gvcizy id PZWG> Vc ZmXajh^kZ a^xzchz id Zmead^i i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV (qb^hidg^xva >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViVr) Yjg^c\ i]z izc+nzvg izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci [dg XZgiV^c Veea^XVi^dch* egdyjxih* dg hzgk^xzh, JjghjVci id i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* PZWG> hjwa^xzchzy i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id i]^gy evgi^zh VcY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ Y^hig^WjiZY i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id i]dhz hjwa^xzchzzh, 2, PZWG>ph g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ZcYh 0./6* l]zc i]z ^c^i^va izc+nzvg izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ZcYh, Cc Vci^X^eVi^dc d[ i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh WZZc cz\di^vi^c\ l^i] egdhezxi^kz i]^gy+evgin a^xzchzzh (=]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh) id ZchjgZ i]z^g Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy VXXZhh id i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg PZWG>ph a^xzchz izgb^cvizh, Md bzzi ^ih egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZghp czzyh* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ eavch id a^xzchz Wdi] i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV VcY i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV i]vi =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ l^aa Xdci^cjZ id \ZcZgViZ V[iZg i]z izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ZcYh, 3, LiVgi^c\ ^c ;j\jhi 0./4 VcY Xdci^cj^c\ i]gdj\] idyvn* PZWG> gzezvizyan ]Vh b^hhivizy id ^ih Zm^hi^c\ XjhidbZgh (l]^x] VgZ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh) i]vi ZkZc V[iZg i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* PZWG> ldjay Xdci^cjZ id WZ i]z hdaz 0 4 of 18

5 hdjgxz d[ B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV dwiv^czy Wn PZWG> Yjg^c\ i]z izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, PZWG> gzezvizyan VcY ^cvxxjgvizan ]Vh hivizy i]vi* jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* ^i l^aa gziv^c i]z ZmXajh^kZ g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ZkZc V[iZg 0./6 izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, =av^b^c\ i]vi ^i l^aa WZ qi]z dcan \VbZ ^c idlc*r PZWG> ]Vh YZbVcYZY izch d[ b^aa^dch ^c i]z V\\gZ\ViZ d[ ^begdezg edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh l]^x] VgZ Vi g^h` d[ adh^c\ VXXZhh id i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, <ZXVjhZ i]zhz egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh czzy Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy VXXZhh id i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV* PZWG>ph ^begdezg YZbVcYh VgZ XVjh^c\ ^bbzy^viz YVbV\Z VcY ^c_jgn id =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ* l]^x] ]Vh i]z hdaz VcY ZmXajh^kZ edhi+izgb^cvi^dc g^\]i id a^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, 4, M]gdj\] ^ih XVbeV^\c d[ b^h^c[dgbvi^dc* PZWG> ]Vh hinb^zy =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph Z[[dgih id ZciZg ^cid edhi+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz V\gZZbZcih l^i] i]zhz egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh id [VX^a^iViZ V hzvbazhh igvch^i^dc d[ hzgk^xzh VcY ZchjgZ V Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy [adl d[ >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id XjhidbZgh, =dcigvgn id ^ih dc\d^c\ b^hgzegzhzcivi^dch* PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ Vcn g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY ]Vh cd g^\]i id gzxz^kz edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb i]z hjwa^xzchzzh, 5, Cc a^\]i d[ PZWG>ph Xdci^cjZY b^hhivizbzcih* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ hzz`h V YZXaVgVi^dc [gdb i]^h =djgi i]vi8 (^) PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ Vc ZmXajh^kZ a^xzchz id i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 (^^) =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh i]z hdaz g^\]i id a^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 (^^^) PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ i]z g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci dg di]zgl^hz XdbbZgX^Vaan Zmead^i i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+ CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^c V bvcczg ^cxdch^hizci l^i] i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 (^k) PZWG> YdZh cdi 1 5 of 18

6 ]VkZ i]z g^\]i id edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb hjwa^xzchzzh d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [dg jhz d[ i]vi B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 (k) PZWG> ]Vh WgZVX]ZY i]z ^bea^zy XdkZcVci d[ \ddy [V^i] VcY [V^g YZVa^c\ ^cxdgedgvizy Vh V bviizg d[ avl ^cid i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 (k^) PZWG> idgi^djhan ]Vh ^cizg[zgzy l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzzh V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 VcY (k^^) PZWG> ]Vh Zc\V\ZY ^c jc[v^g XdbeZi^i^dc ^c k^davi^dc d[ HZl Rdg` avl Wn hzz`^c\ ^bezgb^hh^waz edhi+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz [ZZh [gdb jhzgh d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+ CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ [jgi]zg hzz`h id Zc_d^c PZWG>ph idgi^djh XdcYjXi VcY id gzxdkzg bdczivgn gza^z[, <0-8)9<1-; 6, JaV^ci^[[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ IeZgVi^dch* FF= ^h V a^b^izy a^vw^a^in XdbeVcn dg\vc^ozy VcY Zm^hi^c\ jcyzg i]z avlh d[ i]z LiViZ d[ >ZaVlVgZ* l^i] ^ih eg^cx^eva eavxz d[ Wjh^cZhh adxvizy Vi 1.33 FZWVcdc J^`Z* HVh]k^aaZ* MZccZhhZZ 150/2, M]Z hdaz bzbwzg d[ JaV^ci^[[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ IeZgVi^dch* FF= ^h =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ BdaY^c\h* CcX,* V XdgedgVi^dc dg\vc^ozy VcY Zm^hi^c\ jcyzg i]z avlh d[ i]z LiViZ d[ >ZaVlVgZ* l^i] ^ih eg^cx^eva eavxz d[ Wjh^cZhh adxvizy Vi i]z MZccZhhZZ VYYgZhh VWdkZ, 7, Ic ^c[dgbvi^dc VcY WZa^Z[* >Z[ZcYVci PZWG> BZVai] =dge, ^h V XdgedgVi^dc dg\vc^ozy VcY Zm^hi^c\ jcyzg i]z avlh d[ i]z LiViZ d[ >ZaVlVgZ* l^i] ^ih eg^cx^eva eavxz d[ Wjh^cZhh adxvizy Vi 173 BjYhdc LigZZi* HZl Rdg`* HZl Rdg` /../2, 2=91;,1+<176 )6, >-6=- /., M]^h =djgi ]Vh _jg^hy^xi^dc dkzg i]^h VXi^dc jcyzg =JFK s 1../ WZXVjhZ Vc VXijVa* egzhzci* VcY _jhi^x^vwaz XdcigdkZghn Zm^hih WZilZZc i]z evgi^zh* VcY ejghjvci id 00 H,R, =dbe, =dyzh K, ' KZ\h, i^i, 00* s 0.0,5.* WZXVjhZ i]z XaV^bh Vg^hZ dji d[ Wjh^cZhh YZVa^c\h VcY 2 6 of 18

7 YZXaVgVidgn dg Zfj^iVWaZ gza^z[ ^h hdj\]i VcY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ hzz`h b^aa^dch ^c YVbV\Zh* ZmXajh^kZ d[ ejc^i^kz YVbV\Zh* ^cizgzhih* Xdhih* Y^hWjghZbZcih VcY XdjchZa [ZZh, //, M]^h =djgi ]Vh _jg^hy^xi^dc dkzg >Z[ZcYVci PZWG> jcyzg =JFK ss 1./ VcY 1.0 WZXVjhZ >Z[ZcYVci PZWG> igvchvxih Wjh^cZhh ^c i]z LiViZ d[ HZl Rdg`* WZXVjhZ V hjwhivci^va edgi^dc d[ i]z VXih VcY db^hh^dch \^k^c\ g^hz id i]^h VXi^dc dxxjggzy ^c HZl Rdg`* VcY WZXVjhZ i]z XdcigVXi \dkzgc^c\ i]^h Y^hejiZ XdciV^ch V HZl Rdg` X]d^XZ+d[+aVl egdk^h^dc, /0, OZcjZ ^h egdezg ^c HZl Rdg` =djcin jcyzg =JFK ss 3./ VcY 3.1(V) WZXVjhZ Vc V\gZZbZci WZilZZc i]z evgi^zh [^mzh HZl Rdg` =djcin Vh i]z eavxz [dg ig^va VcY WZXVjhZ >Z[ZcYVci PZWG> bv^civ^ch ^ih eg^cx^eva d[[^xz ^c HZl Rdg` =djcin,.)+<=)4 *)+3/97=6, 1' <HE 9EJAQIMLPHIN *EQSEEL QHE 8AOQIEP /1, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ^h V azvy^c\ egdk^yzg d[ ]ZVai]XVgZ izx]cdad\n hdaji^dch, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ XdccZXih evndgh VcY egdk^yzgh i]gdj\] V hzxjgz czildg`, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph czildg` gzvx]zh e]nh^x^vch VcY egdk^yzgh d[ bzy^xva hzgk^xzh* Vh lzaa Vh kvg^djh \dkzgcbzci V\ZcX^Zh VcY XdbbZgX^Va dg\vc^ovi^dch gzhedch^waz [dg evnbzci d[ hjx] bzy^xva hzgk^xzh, M]gdj\] kvg^djh XdcigVXi^c\ VggVc\ZbZcih l^i] ^ih XjhidbZgh* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph czildg` hzgkzh Vh V \ViZlVn [dg ZaZXigdc^XVaan gdji^c\ ]ZVai]XVgZ+gZaViZY igvchvxi^dch, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph czildg` ^h ^cizgdezgvwaz l^i] di]zg czildg`h VcY hjeedgih gzva+i^bz* czvg gzva+i^bz VcY WViX] igvchvxi^dch, M]Z czildg` egdk^yzh hjeedgi [dg ]ZVai]XVgZ [^cvcx^va VcY VYb^c^higVi^kZ igvchvxi^dch* ^cxajy^c\ egz+vji]dg^ovi^dc* Za^\^W^a^in* XaV^bh hjwb^hh^dc* XaV^bh hivijh* VcY ZaZXigdc^X gzb^iivcxz VYk^XZ, /2, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ jhzh i]z YViV XdaaZXiZY i]gdj\] ^ih czildg` id ^begdkz VcY ZcVWaZ WZiiZg ]ZVai]XVgZ* bv`z W^aa^c\ bdgz Z[[^X^Zci* VcY gzyjxz i]z Xdhi d[ XVgZ, ;h VaadlZY 3 7 of 18

8 jcyzg XdcigVXih l^i] bvcn d[ ^ih XjhidbZgh VcY ^c Xdbea^VcXZ l^i] BCJ;;* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ YZ+^YZci^[^Zh i]z YViV ^i bv^civ^ch VcY a^xzchzh i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id XjhidbZgh ^c i]z ]ZVai]+ hzgk^xzh ^cyjhign [dg jhz ^c YZkZadebZci d[ egdyjxih id ^begdkz YZa^kZgn d[ XVgZ VcY id [VX^a^iViZ gzhzvgx], /3, PZWG> ^h V egdk^yzg d[ ]ZVai] ^c[dgbvi^dc hzgk^xzh id XdchjbZgh* e]nh^x^vch* VcY di]zg ]ZVai]XVgZ egd[zhh^dcvah* ZbeadnZgh* VcY ]ZVai] eavch, PZWG> d[[zgh ejwa^x VcY eg^kviz dca^cz edgivah* bdw^az eavi[dgbh* VcY ]ZVai]+[dXjhZY ejwa^xvi^dch id Zc\V\Z XdchjbZgh* e]nh^x^vch* VcY di]zg ]ZVai]XVgZ egd[zhh^dcvah, /4, Cc dg 0..6* egzyzxzhhdgh d[ PZWG> VcY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ* BFMB =dgedgvi^dc VcY?<L GVhiZg FF=* ZciZgZY ^cid Vc ;bzcyzy VcY KZhiViZY >ViV F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, M]Z evgi^zh VbZcYZY i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci dc dg VWdji GVn /* 0./.* ^c ;bzcybzci id ;bzcyzy VcY KZhiViZY >ViV F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci (XdaaZXi^kZan* Vh VbZcYZY* YZ[^cZY VWdkZ Vh i]z qf^xzchz ;\gzzbzcir), /5, Nedc ^c[dgbvi^dc VcY WZa^Z[* BFMB =dgedgvi^dc Vhh^\cZY ^ih g^\]ih jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci id PZWG>* VcY PZWG> VhhjbZY BFMB =dgedgvi^dcph dwa^\vi^dch jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ejghjvci id Vc ;hh^\cbzci VcY ;hhjbei^dc ;\gzzbzci YViZY IXidWZg 0.* 0..6, /6, Ic dg VgdjcY DVcjVgn /* 0./3*?<L GVhiZg FF= bzg\zy ^cid?byzdc <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh* FF=* l]^x] VhhjbZY i]z g^\]ih VcY dwa^\vi^dch d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, Ic dg VgdjcY DVcjVgn /* 0./4*?bYZdc <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh FF= X]Vc\ZY ^ih cvbz id =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ IeZgVi^dch* FF=, 4 8 of 18

9 11' <HE 9EJERALQ <EOKP MF QHE 4ICELPE )GOEEKELQ /7, JjghjVci id i]z izgbh d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* PZWG> ]Vh i]z g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id XjhidbZgh ^c i]z a^[z hx^zcxzh VcY XdchjbZg bvg`zih [dg ^cxdgedgvi^dc ^cid jhz[ja egdyjxih* hzgk^xzh* VcY Veea^XVi^dch VcY [dg jhz ^c gzhzvgx], 0., JjghjVci id i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* PZWG> Y^Y cdi Y^hig^WjiZ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id i]z hjwa^xzchzzh, KVi]Zg* PZWG> ZciZgZY ^cid V\gZZbZcih l^i] i]z hjwa^xzchzzh* VcY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ Y^hig^WjiZY i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV Y^gZXian id i]dhz hjwa^xzchzzh, 0/, M]Z a^xzchz \gvci [gdb =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ id PZWG> ^h hzi [dgi] ^c LZXi^dc 0,/ d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* Zci^iaZY qf^xzchz AgVci*r l]^x] egdk^yzh* ^c gzazkvci evgi8 GVhiZg FF= S=]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZT VcY i]z <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh?ci^i^Zh ]ZgZWn \gvci id BFMB SPZWG>T i]z [daadl^c\ g^\]ih VcY a^xzchzh (i]z qf^xzchzr)* l^i] i]z g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz ^c VXXdgYVcXZ l^i] LZXi^dc 0,38 (V) Vc ^ggzkdxvwaz* ZmXajh^kZ* ldgayl^yz* ezgezijva a^xzchz id jhz* Xden* bdy^[n* Y^heaVn* Y^hig^WjiZ VcY Zmead^i i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id YZkZade* bvg`zi* egdbdiz* hzaa* egdk^yz VcY XdbbZgX^Va^oZ i]z [daadl^c\,,, SZcjbZgViZY Veea^XVi^dch* egdyjxih* dg hzgk^xzht, S=]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZT VcY i]z <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh?ci^i^Zh bvn cdi jhz <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh >ViV [dg Vcn ejgedhz l^i]^c i]z hxdez d[ SPZWG>Tph ZmXajh^kZ a^xzchz jcyzg i]^h LZXi^dc 0,/(V), (W) Vc ^ggzkdxvwaz* cdc+zmxajh^kz* ldgayl^yz* ezgezijva a^xzchz id jhz* Xden* bdy^[n* Y^hig^WjiZ VcY Zmead^i i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^c Vcn di]zg bvcczg* Veea^XVi^dc* egdyjxi dg hzgk^xz cdi XdkZgZY ^c LZXi^dc 0,/(V),,,, 00, NcaZhh VaadlZY id WZ VjidbVi^XVaan ZmiZcYZY* i]z izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ^h a^b^izy id izc nzvgh, LZXi^dc 4,/ d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* Zci^iaZY qmzgb*r egdk^yzh8 M]^h ;\gzzbzci h]vaa WZXdbZ Z[[ZXi^kZ dc i]z?[[zxi^kz >ViZ VcY h]vaa Xdci^cjZ ^c Z[[ZXi [dg V ezg^dy d[ izc (/.) nzvgh [gdb i]z YViZ ]ZgZd[ jcazhh izgb^cvizy Vh egdk^yzy ^c i]^h ;gi^xaz OC (qmzgbr), M]ZgZV[iZg* i]^h 5 9 of 18

10 ;\gzzbzci h]vaa VjidbVi^XVaan gzczl [dg Vc VYY^i^dcVa [^kz (3) nzvg izgb jcazhh Z^i]Zg evgin \^kzh cdi^xz id i]z di]zg evgin Vi azvhi dcz ]jcygzy VcY ilzcin (/0.) YVnh WZ[dgZ i]z ZcY d[ i]z MZgb d[ ^ih YZX^h^dc cdi id gzczl i]^h ;\gzzbzci, 01, M]Z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci Vahd ^cxajyzh V a^b^izy hjgk^kva XaVjhZ hzi [dgi] ^c LZXi^dc 4,2 d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* Zci^iaZY q?[[zxi d[ MZgb^cVi^dc*r l]^x] egdk^yzh8 Nedc i]z izgb^cvi^dc dg Zme^gVi^dc d[ i]^h ;\gzzbzci* ZVX] evgin h]vaa gzijgc egdbeian Vcn =dc[^yzci^va Cc[dgbVi^dc (Vh YZ[^cZY WZadl) d[ i]z di]zg evgin ^c hjx] evginph edhhzhh^dc, Hdil^i]hiVcY^c\ i]z izgb^cvi^dc dg Zme^gVi^dc d[ i]^h ;\gzzbzci* i]z Veea^XVWaZ g^\]ih VcY dwa^\vi^dch ^c ;gi^xazh OCCC* Q* QC* QCC* VcY QCCC VcY LZXi^dch 0,4* 2,/(W)* 3,0* 3,1 ([dg i]z ezg^dy hivizy i]zgz^c)* 3,2 ([dg i]z ezg^dy hivizy i]zgz^c)* VcY 4,2 h]vaa hjgk^kz izgb^cvi^dc dg Zme^gVi^dc d[ i]^h ;\gzzbzci, 02, IcZ d[ i]z ]VcY[ja d[ egdk^h^dch i]vi hjgk^kzh izgb^cvi^dc ^h LZXi^dc 0,4 d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* Zci^iaZY q=dci^cjzy NhZ d[ >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV*r l]^x] egdk^yzh* ^c evgi8 S=]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZT VcY i]z <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh?ci^i^Zh ]ZgZWn V\gZZ i]vi* id i]z ZmiZci cdi di]zgl^hz egd]^w^izy Wn ;eea^xvwaz FVl VcY hjw_zxi id i]z izgbh hzih Sh^XT [dgi] ^c LZXi^dc 2,/(W)* SPZWG>T,,, bvn gziv^c >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^c ezgezij^in VcY h]vaa ]VkZ cd dwa^\vi^dc id S=]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZT dg i]z <jh^czhh LZgk^XZh?ci^i^Zh id ejg\z* YZaZiZ* dg gzcyzg Vcn >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^cvxxzhh^waz, LjW_ZXi id LZXi^dc 0,1* SPZWG>T,,, bvn XdbW^cZ >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV l^i] >ViV [gdb di]zg hdjgxzh, 03, M]Z ^c^i^va izc+nzvg izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ZcYh 6* 0./6* VcY i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci izgb^cvizh dc i]vi YViZ ^[ Z^i]Zg evgin \^kzh Vi azvhi dcz ]jcygzy VcY ilzcin (/0.) YVnhp VYkVcXZ cdi^xz d[ ^ih YZX^h^dc cdi id gzczl, P]^aZ PZWG>ph a^b^izy g^\]ih jcyzg LZXi^dc 0,4 d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci id gziv^c i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV hjgk^kzh* PZWG>ph g^\]i ^c LZXi^dc 0,/ id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV YdZh cdi hjgk^kz izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, PZWG> ]Vh cd g^\]i jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci id ZmigVXi edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb i]z hjwa^xzchzzh [dg i]z Xdci^cjZY jhz d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, 6 10 of 18

11 111' <HE 1KNELDILG <EOKILAQIML MF QHE 4ICELPE )GOEEKELQ ALD?EB5,UP 1KNOMNEO )QQEKNQP QM <HSAOQ +HALGE 0EAJQHCAOEUP -FFMOQP QM -TEOCIPE 1QP 8MPQ&<EOKILAQIML 9IGHQP 04, Cc dg VgdjcY DVcjVgn 0./4* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ WZ\Vc cz\di^vi^dch l^i] Wdi] PZWG> VcY egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh id VggVc\Z [dg hjx] egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh id ]VkZ Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy VXXZhh id >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg i]z ^c^i^va izc+nzvg izgb d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, L^cXZ i]vi YViZ* PZWG> ]Vh Zc\V\ZY ^c V b^h^c[dgbvi^dc XVbeV^\c Wn bv`^c\ gzezvizy b^hhivizbzcih VcY b^hgzegzhzcivi^dch ^c i]z bvg`zieavxz gz\vgy^c\ i]z evgi^zhp gzavi^kz g^\]ih edhi+izgb^cvi^dc id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, <n Yd^c\ hd* PZWG> ]Vh ]VgbZY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ Wn YZeg^k^c\ ^i d[ i]z WZcZ[^ih d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY ^cizg[zg^c\ l^i] ^ih VW^a^in id ZmZgX^hZ ^ih edhi+izgb^cvi^dc g^\]ih jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ PZWG> ]Vh XgZViZY Xdc[jh^dc ^c i]z bvg`zieavxz Wn i]gzvizc^c\ id ]^cyzg i]z ^bedgivci ldg` d[ i]z hjwa^xzchzzh ^c YZkZade^c\ ^begdkzy VcY bdgz Z[[^X^Zci ]ZVai]XVgZ egdyjxih VcY hzgk^xzh VcY ^c XdcYjXi^c\ gzhzvgx], 05, Cc dg VgdjcY DjcZ 0./4* PZWG> [VahZan XaV^bZY id dcz d[ i]z hjwa^xzchzzh d[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV i]vi PZWG> ldjay WZ i]z dcan hjeea^zg d[ B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, M]^h XaV^b gjch XdbeaZiZan XdjciZg id i]z izgbh d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, 06, Cc dg VgdjcY ;j\jhi 0./4* PZWG> WZ\Vc id i]gzvizc ^ih hjwa^xzchzzh (l]^x] VgZ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz edhi+izgb^cvi^dc XjhidbZgh) Wn hzz`^c\ edhi+izgb^cvi^dc [ZZh [gdb i]zb* XaV^b^c\ i]vi* jedc izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci 0./6* PZWG> ldjay ]VkZ ZmXajh^kZ Xdcigda d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV VcY ldjay ]VkZ i]z hdaz g^\]i id qzmead^ir VcY XdbbZgX^Va^oZ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, PZWG> i]gzvizczy i]vi i]z dcan lvn hjwa^xzchzzh XdjaY jhz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV egzk^djhan a^xzchzy id 7 11 of 18

12 i]zb Wn PZWG> lvh [dg Z^i]Zg i]z hjwa^xzchzzh dg =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ id hvi^h[n PZWG>ph [^cvcx^va YZbVcYh, 07, Cc dg VgdjcY >ZXZbWZg 0./4* PZWG> ZmZXji^kZh i]gzvizczy i]vi PZWG> ldjay [dgxz i]z bvg`zi id evn l]vizkzg eg^xz PZWG> bvn YZX^YZ id YZbVcY [dg i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, 1., Cc dg 0./5* i]zhz i]gzvih [gdb PZWG> ^cizch^[^zy, ;gdjcy i]^h i^bz* V egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzz ^c[dgbzy =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ i]vi PZWG> ]VY YZbVcYZY ^begdezg edhi+izgb^cvi^dc [ZZh [dg i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, NcVWaZ id V[[dgY i]z VYYZY Xdhi* i]z egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzz Vh`ZY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ^[ ^i ldjay ]Zae YZ[gVn i]z Xdch^YZgVWaZ VYYZY ZmeZchZ Wn evn^c\ V edgi^dc d[ i]z VYY^i^dcVa edhi+izgb^cvi^dc [ZZh [dg i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV i]vi PZWG> lvh YZbVcY^c\, 1/, PZWG> Vahd iday V egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZg i]vi* ZkZc V[iZg i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* i]z XjhidbZg ldjay ]VkZ cd X]d^XZ Wji id Xdci^cjZ id a^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [gdb PZWG>* i]vi PZWG> ldjay Xdci^cjZ id WZ i]z hdaz hdjgxz d[ B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV* VcY i]vi PZWG> ldjay gzbv^c i]z qdcan \VbZ ^c idlcr [dg B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, 10, PZWG> [jgi]zg VYk^hZY =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ i]vi* jcazhh =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ V\gZZY id PZWG>ph gzczlva izgbh* PZWG> ldjay jhz ^ih VaaZ\ZY qzmxajh^kzr g^\]ih id [dgxz i]^gy evgi^zh id evn PZWG> [dg B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV Vi i]z g^h` d[ adh^c\ VXXZhh id hjx] B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, LeZX^[^XVaan* PZWG> hivizy i]vi ^i ldjay YZbVcY 3.& d[ i]z egz+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz [ZZ ^c RZVg / edhi+izgb^cvi^dc9 1/& d[ i]z egz+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz [ZZ ^c RZVg 0 edhi+izgb^cvi^dc9 VcY 03& d[ i]z egz+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz [ZZ ^c RZVg 1 edhi+izgb^cvi^dc, /. 12 of 18

13 11, Md hide PZWG>ph dc\d^c\ ^cizg[zgzcxz l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph g^\]i id a^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY id ZchjgZ V hzvbazhh edhi+izgb^cvi^dc igvch^i^dc* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh WZZc az[i l^i] cd VaiZgcVi^kZ Wji id [^az i]^h VXi^dc [dg YZXaVgVidgn* ^c_jcxi^kz* VcY di]zg gza^z[, Ci ^h Xg^i^XVa i]vi =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzxz^kz i]^h gza^z[ l^i]dji YZaVn, +7=6< 1(,-+4)9)<79@ 2=,/5-6< 12, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzezvih VcY gzvaaz\zh ZVX] VcY ZkZgn VaaZ\Vi^dc hzi [dgi] ^c evgv\gve]h / i]gdj\] 11 Vh i]dj\] [jaan hzi [dgi] ]ZgZ^c, 13, ;c VXijVa VcY _jhi^x^vwaz XdcigdkZghn ]Vh Vg^hZc VcY cdl Zm^hih WZilZZc =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ VcY PZWG> Vh id i]z evgi^zhp XdcigVXijVa g^\]ih* Yji^Zh* VcY dwa^\vi^dch VcY Vh id l]zi]zg =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh i]z g^\]i id a^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV l]zc i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci izgb^cvizh, 14, NcYZg i]z ZmegZhh izgbh d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* PZWG>ph g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV l^aa izgb^cviz 6* 0./6, ;[izg i]vi YViZ* PZWG> l^aa Zc_dn dcan i]z a^b^izy hjgk^kva g^\]i id gziv^c i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV Vh hzi [dgi] ^c LZXi^dc 0,4 d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, ;[izg i]vi YViZ* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ l^aa Zc_dn i]z hdaz VcY ZmXajh^kZ g^\]i id a^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV id i]^gy evgi^zh, PZWG> gz[jhzh id VX`cdlaZY\Z VcY ^h VXi^kZan ^cizg[zg^c\ l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph g^\]i ^c i]^h gz\vgy, 15, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh ^cxjggzy W^aa^dch d[ YdaaVgh ^c ZmeZchZh id YZkZade VcY bv^civ^c ^ih ZmiZch^kZ ]ZVai]XVgZ czildg` i]gdj\] l]^x] i]z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^h XdaaZXiZY, M]Z >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ]Vh WZZc Vc ^ckvajvwaz gzhdjgxz [dg ^begdk^c\ i]z egdk^h^dc d[ ]ZVai]XVgZ hzgk^xzh VcY [dg XdcYjXi^c\ gzhzvgx], =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh gzan dc i]z // 13 of 18

14 Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy VXXZhh id =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [dg i]z^g ^bedgivci ldg`, 16, Md ZchjgZ i]z Xdci^cjZY VcY jc^cizggjeizy VXXZhh id B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [dg i]zhz egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ bjhi ZciZg ^cid a^xzchz V\gZZbZcih l^i] i]zb WZ[dgZ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci izgb^cvizh 0./6, M]gdj\] ^ih b^hhivizbzcih gz\vgy^c\ i]z izgbh d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY i]gzvih d[ Y^hgjei^dc* PZWG> hd [Vg ]Vh hinb^zy =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph Z[[dgih, 17, ;h V gzhjai* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ hzz`h V YZXaVgVidgn _jy\bzci hivi^c\ ^ih g^\]ih jcyzg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, +7=6< 11( *9-)+0 7. < , +7>-6)6< 7. /77,.)1<0 )6,.)19,-)416/ 2., =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzezvih VcY gzvaaz\zh ZVX] VcY ZkZgn VaaZ\Vi^dc hzi [dgi] ^c evgv\gve]h / i]gdj\] 17 Vh i]dj\] [jaan hzi [dgi] ]ZgZ^c, 2/, Cbea^ZY Wn avl ^cid i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ^h V XdkZcVci d[ \ddy [V^i] VcY [V^g YZVa^c\ Wn l]^x] PZWG> egdb^hzy cdi id Yd Vcni]^c\ id YZeg^kZ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ d[ i]z WZcZ[^ih d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci, 20, PZWG>ph YZbVcY [dg edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb ^ih hjwa^xzchzzh [dg i]z Xdci^cjZY jhz d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [daadl^c\ i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ^h YZeg^k^c\ VcY i]gzvizch id Xdci^cjZ id YZeg^kZ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ d[ i]z WZcZ[^ih d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* cvbzan i]vi* [daadl^c\ i]z izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ VcY cdi PZWG> ldjay ]VkZ i]z g^\]i id a^xzchz VcY di]zgl^hz XdbbZgX^Vaan Zmead^i i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV, /0 14 of 18

15 21, PZWG>ph WgZVX] d[ i]z ^bea^zy XdkZcVci d[ \ddy [V^i] VcY [V^g YZVa^c\ ^cxdgedgvizy Wn avl ^cid i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci ]Vh XVjhZY VcY l^aa Xdci^cjZ id XVjhZ YVbV\Z id =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ^c i]z b^aa^dch d[ YdaaVgh* l^i] i]z ZmVXi Vbdjci id WZ YZiZgb^cZY Vi ig^va, +7=6< 111( <79<17=; 16< ?1<0 897;8-+<1>- *=;16-;; )6, +76<9)+<=)4 9-4)<176; 22, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzezvih VcY gzvaaz\zh ZVX] VcY ZkZgn VaaZ\Vi^dc hzi [dgi] ^c evgv\gve]h / i]gdj\] 21 Vh i]dj\] [jaan hzi [dgi] ]ZgZ^c, 23, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh iv`zc hizeh VcY ^cxjggzy h^\c^[^xvci ZmeZchZh id ZhiVWa^h] Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzzh d[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci 6* 0./6, 24, PZWG> ]Vh ^cizg[zgzy l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch Wn b^hgzegzhzci^c\ id egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh i]vi PZWG> ]Vh i]z ZmXajh^kZ g^\]i id a^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ZkZc V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY YZbVcY^c\ ^begdezg edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih i]vi PZWG> ]Vh cd g^\]i id YZbVcY, PZWG> ]Vh ZmZgiZY jc[v^g ZXdcdb^X egzhhjgz Wn [VahZan hivi^c\ i]vi hjwa^xzchzzh l^aa ]VkZ id evn i]zhz dc\d^c\ edhi+izgb^cvi^dc [ZZh id a^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci VcY Wn ViiZbei^c\ id [dgxz =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ id evn ^[ i]z hjwa^xzchzzh VgZ i]zbhzakzh jcvwaz id hvi^h[n i]zhz YZbVcYh, 25, PZWG>ph ^begdezg XdcYjXi ^h cdi _jhi^[^zy dg eg^k^az\zy ^c Vcn lvn, PZWG>ph b^hgzegzhzcivi^dch id egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzzh VcY ^begdezg YZbVcYh [dg Xdci^cjZY edhi+ izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih id jhz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ]VkZ ^c_jgzy =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] i]^gy evgi^zh Wn YZiZgg^c\ i]zb [gdb ZciZg^c\ ^cid edhi+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz V\gZZbZcih l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ, /1 15 of 18

16 26, PZWG> ]Vh ^cizg[zgzy l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] egdhezxi^kz XjhidbZgh [dg =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [dg i]z ejgedhz d[ XVjh^c\ ZXdcdb^X ]Vgb id =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ Wn egzkzci^c\ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ [gdb a^xzch^c\ ^ih >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci izgb^cvizh gvi]zg i]vc hzz`^c\ id hzxjgz Vcn az\^i^bviz ZXdcdb^X VYkVciV\Z [dg ^ihza[, 27, ;h V Y^gZXi VcY egdm^bviz gzhjai d[ PZWG>ph lgdc\[ja XdcYjXi* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh hj[[zgzy VcY Xdci^cjZh id hj[[zg ^ggzevgvwaz ^c_jgn, 3., ;h V Y^gZXi VcY egdm^bviz gzhjai d[ PZWG>ph lgdc\[ja XdcYjXi* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh hj[[zgzy VcY l^aa Xdci^cjZ id hj[[zg YVbV\Zh ^c i]z b^aa^dch d[ YdaaVgh* l^i] i]z ZmVXi Vbdjci id WZ YZiZgb^cZY Vi ig^va, +7=6< 1>( )? =6.) <1<176 3/, =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzezvih VcY gzvaaz\zh ZVX] VcY ZkZgn VaaZ\Vi^dc hzi [dgi] ^c evgv\gve]h / i]gdj\] 3. Vh i]dj\] [jaan hzi [dgi] ]ZgZ^c, 30, PZWG> ]Vh hdj\]i id b^hveegdeg^viz i]z ZmXajh^kZ g^\]i d[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ id a^xzchz VcY XdbbZgX^Vaan Zmead^i i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci 6* 0./6* l]^x] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh XdaaZXiZY VcY egzevgzy [dg a^xzch^c\ Vi \gzvi ZmeZchZ VcY avwdg, PZWG>ph ViiZbeih id b^hveegdeg^viz =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph g^\]i id a^xzchz i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci 6* 0./6 VgZ ^c WVY [V^i], 31, Cc Yd^c\ hd* PZWG> ]Vh hdj\]i id jc[v^gan XdbeZiZ l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ^c i]z bvg`zi [dg i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci 6* 0./6, /2 16 of 18

17 32, ;h V Y^gZXi VcY egdm^bviz gzhjai d[ PZWG>ph lgdc\[ja XdcYjXi* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh hj[[zgzy VcY Xdci^cjZh id hj[[zg ^ggzevgvwaz ^c_jgn, 33, ;h V Y^gZXi VcY egdm^bviz gzhjai d[ PZWG>ph lgdc\[ja XdcYjXi* =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh hj[[zgzy VcY l^aa Xdci^cjZ id hj[[zg YVbV\Zh ^c i]z b^aa^dch d[ YdaaVgh* l^i] i]z ZmVXi Vbdjci id WZ YZiZgb^cZY Vi ig^va, 89)@ PB?K?@IK?* JaV^ci^[[ =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ gzhezxi[jaan gzfjzhih i]vi i]^h =djgi8 ;, >ZXaVgZ i]vi PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ Vc ZmXajh^kZ a^xzchz id B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 <, >ZXaVgZ i]vi =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZ ]Vh i]z hdaz g^\]i id a^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 =, >ZXaVgZ i]vi PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ i]z g^\]i id hjwa^xzchz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci dg di]zgl^hz XdbbZgX^Vaan Zmead^i i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV ^c V bvcczg ^cxdch^hizci l^i] i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 >, >ZXaVgZ i]vi PZWG> YdZh cdi ]VkZ i]z g^\]i id edhi+izgb^cvi^dc evnbzcih [gdb hjwa^xzchzzh d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV [dg jhz d[ i]vi YViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9?, >ZXaVgZ i]vi PZWG> ]Vh WgZVX]ZY i]z ^bea^zy XdkZcVci d[ \ddy [V^i] VcY [V^g YZVa^c\ ^cxdgedgvizy Vh V bviizg d[ avl ^cid i]z F^XZchZ >ZXaVgZ i]vi PZWG> idgi^djhan ]Vh ^cizg[zgzy l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] egdhezxi^kz a^xzchzzh d[ B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV V[iZg izgb^cvi^dc d[ i]z F^XZchZ ;\gzzbzci9 A,?c_d^c PZWG> [gdb ^cizg[zg^c\ l^i] =]Vc\Z BZVai]XVgZph egdhezxi^kz Wjh^cZhh VcY-dg XdcigVXijVa gzavi^dch l^i] egdhezxi^kz B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV a^xzchzzh9 i]vi PZWG> ]Vh Zc\V\ZY ^c jc[v^g XdbeZi^i^dc ^c k^davi^dc d[ HZl Rdg` avl Wn hzz`^c\ ^bezgb^hh^waz edhi+izgb^cvi^dc a^xzchz [ZZh [gdb jhzgh d[ i]z B^hidg^XVa >Z+CYZci^[^ZY >ViV9 /3 17 of 18

18 C, IgYZg PZWG> id evn XdbeZchVidgn YVbV\Zh ^c i]z b^aa^dch d[ YdaaVgh* l^i] i]z ZmVXi Vbdjci id WZ YZiZgb^cZY Vi ig^va9 VcY D, IgYZg hjx] di]zg VcY [jgi]zg ezgbvczci VcY ^cizg^b Zfj^iVWaZ gza^z[ Vh i]^h =djgi YZZbh _jhi VcY egdezg, >ViZY8 HZl Rdg`* HZl Rdg` ;eg^a 1* 0./5 GIKKCLIH FFJ <n8u-h- D, ;azmvcyzg FVlgZcXZUUUUUUUUU D, ;azmvcyzg FVlgZcXZ GIKKCLIH FFJ 03. P, 33 i] LigZZi HZl Rdg`* HZl Rdg` /../7 MZaZe]dcZ8 (0/0) DVbZh J, <ZccZii* = /462 GIKKCLIH FFJ 203 GVg`Zi LigZZi =Va^[dgc^V 72/.3 ;cygzl LZgl^c GIKKCLIH FFJ /031/ B^\] <aj[[ >g^kz Lj^iZ /.. LVc >^Z\d* =Va^[dgc^V 70/1. '<<7960>; 179,5-46<411 (3-620 )0-5< <476;& **( /4 18 of 18