Conducting Internal Corporate Criminal Investigations

Transkrypt

1 Conducting Internal Corporate Criminal Investigations Daniel M. Purdom Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP 4343 Commerce Court Suite 415 Lisle, Illinois

2 ,HG>M=LCGA 1GL?JG;E,HJIHJ;L?,JCFCG;E 1GN?KLCA;LCHGK DGHRK UL 6UTZKTZY <TZXUJ[IZOUT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ( 6UXVUXGZK >OGHOROZ_ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ( DU 6UTJ[IZ ZNK <T\KYZOMGZOUT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ) 4J\GTZGMKY UL <T\KYZOMGZOUT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ) 7OYGJ\GTZGMKY UL <T\KYZOMGZOUT%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ) 6UTJ[IZOTM ZNK <T\KYZOMGZOUT%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ZNK CZXGZKM_%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% * 8SVRU_KK FGXTOTM %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% + FOZTKYY <TZKX\OK]Y %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% + 6UTLROIZY GTJ?[RZOVRK BKVXKYKTZGZOUTY %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% + :GZNKXOTM GZOUT UL 7UI[SKTZY%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%, DUV UL ZNK <T\KYZOMGZOUT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% - 4ZZUXTK_ & 6ROKTZ AXO\ORKMK%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% - FGO\KX UL AXO\ORKMK%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%. FUXQ$AXUJ[IZ 7UIZXOTK %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% / FNGZ ZU 7U FOZN <T\KYZOMGZOUT BKY[RZY %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% / COMTOLOIGTZ 9KJKXGR CZGZ[ZKY %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 0 6UTIR[YOUT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% (

3 1GLJH>M=LCHG ;OMN RK\KR IUXVUXGZK JKIOYOUT SGQKXY# H_ ZNKOX \KX_ TGZ[XK# GXK [Y[GRR_ GMMXKYYO\K VXUHRKS UL ZNK SUYZ JOLLOI[RZ ZGYQY LGIOTM G ]NOZK IURRGX IXOSOTGR JKLKTYK GZZUXTK_ OY ZU JKSUTYZXGZK ZU IUXVUXGZK SGTGMKSKTZ ZNGZ \OXZ[GRR_ K\KX_ SUJKR UL IUXVUXGZK VXUHRKS YUR\OTM IU[RJ XKY[RZ OT JOYGYZKX ]NKT G IUXVUXGZOUT LGIKY GRRKMGZOUTY UL IUXVUXGZK IXOSOTGR ]XUTMJUOTM% AXUYKI[ZUXY GTJ JKLKTYK GZZUXTK_Y IGT VXU\OJK G ROZGT_ UL IGYKY ]NKXK GRRKMGZOUTY UL XKRGZO\KR_ OTYOMTOLOIGTZ ]XUTMJUOTM ]KXK SOYNGTJRKJ H_ IUXVUXGZK SGTGMKSKTZ XKY[RZOTM OT S[IN SUXK YKXOU[Y IXOSOTGR IUTJ[IZ UX YOMTOLOIGTZ IO\OR ROGHOROZ_% DNOY GXZOIRK ]ORR LUI[Y UT ZNK IUTJ[IZOTM UL GT OTZKXTGR IUXVUXGZK OT\KYZOMGZOUT GTJ NU] ZU G\UOJ ZNK T[SKXU[Y VOZLGRRY ZNGZ IU[TYKR SG_ KTIU[TZKX%,HJIHJ;L? 3C;<CECLP ;OYZUXOIGRR_ IU[XZY NG\K NKRJ IUXVUXGZOUTY IXOSOTGRR_ ROGHRK H_ GVVR_OTM ZNK XKYVUTJKGZ Y[VKXOUX JUIZXOTK OT ZNK IXOSOTGR IUTZK^Z% 8GXR_ OT ZNK Z]KTZOKZN IKTZ[X_ ZNK C[VXKSK 6U[XZ NKRJ ZNGZ ZNK GIZ UL ZNK GMKTZ# ]NORK K^KXIOYOTM ZNK G[ZNUXOZ_ JKRKMGZKJ ZU NOS %%% SG_ HK IUTZXURRKJ# OT ZNK OTZKXKYZ UL V[HROI VUROI_# H_ OSV[ZOTM NOY GIZ ZU NOY KSVRU_KX GTJ OSVUYOTM VKTGRZOKY [VUT ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT LUX ]NOIN NK OY GIZOTM! ")5F 0?A; #5>CA1< 1>4 &"+"+" EB".>9C54,C1C5B! )() E%C% +/( GZ +0+!(0 0"% 6UXVUXGZK IXOSOTGR XKYVUTYOHOROZ_ NGY HXUGJKTKJ YOTIK ZNK KGXR_ VGXZ UL ZNOY IKTZ[X_% 6U[XZY NG\K K^ZKTJKJ IUXVUXGZK XKYVUTYOHOROZ_ LUX ZNK GIZY UL GT_ UL OZY GMKTZY [TRKYY ZNUYK GIZY GXK ZUZGRR_ [TXKRGZKJ ZU ZNK KSVRU_SKTZ XKRGZOUTYNOV% DNK RG] KYYKTZOGRR_ VXKY[SKY ZNGZ GT_ GIZO\OZ_ H_ GT KSVRU_KK OY JUTK ]OZN YUSK OTZKTZ ZU HKTKLOZ ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT GZ RKGYZ OT VGXZ% DNK IUXVUXGZOUT SG_ LOTJ VXUZKIZOUT OT ZNUYK ROSOZKJ OTYZGTIKY ]NKT ZNK KSVRU_KK#Y OTZKTZ OY ZU YURKR_ HKTKLOZ NOSYKRL GTJ IU[RJ TUZ HKTKLOZ ZNK YZUIQ NURJKXY%,55.>9C54,C1C5B E" #9>3?CC1! -/0 9%)J )*/!(YZ 6OX% (0/)"2 6KXZ% JKTOKJ +,, E%C% GT_ OTJO\OJ[GR GIZUX ]NU NGY VKXYUTGR OT\UR\KSKTZ OT IXOSOTGR IUTJ[IZ X[TY ZNK XOYQ UL IXOSOTGR ROGHOROZ_% <T ZNK IUXVUXGZK GXKTG# OTJO\OJ[GRY SG_ GRYU HK IXOSOTGRR_ I[RVGHRK LUX GIZO\OZ_ ]NKXK ZNK_ ]KXK TUZ VKXYUTGRR_ OT\UR\KJ H[Z ]NKXK ZNK_ LGRR [TJKX ZNK JUIZXOTK UL XKYVUTYOHRK IUXVUXGZK ULLOIKX%" DNK JUIZXOTK HGYOIGRR_ OSVUYKY UT IUXVUXGZK ULLOIKXY ZNK XKYVUTYOHOROZ_ LUX ]XUTMJUOTM ]NKXK ZNK_ SOMNZ NG\K HKKT OT G VUYOZOUT ZU G\UOJ ]XUTMJUOTM H_ YUSKUTK ]OZNOT ZNK IUXVUXGZK INGOT UL IUSSGTJ% 9UX JK\KRUVSKTZ UL ZNOY JUIZXOTK B55! 75>5A1<<G!."," EB" $?CC5AF5938! *) E%C% )..!(0+*"2 #1A?<5>5 *A?4D3CB #?=@1>G EB".>9C54,C1C5B! (+ 9%)J -(!+ZN 6OXI[OZ"2.>9C54,C1C5B EB" *1A;! +)( E%C% -,/!(0.,"% 4 T[SHKX UL LKJKXGR YZGZ[ZKY NG\K IUJOLOKJ ZNK IUTIKVZ UL XKYVUTYOHRK IUXVUXGZK ULLOIKX% CKK 6RKGT FGZKX 4IZ GTJ ZNK 6RKGT 4OX 4IZ 4SKTJSKTZ!(00 "% DNKYK RG]Y GZZKSVZ ZU OJKTZOL_ ]NGZ XOYQ G XKYVUTYOHRK IUXVUXGZK ULLOIKX YNU[RJ QTU] GTJ ZNKT NURJ ZNGZ ULLOIKX ZU GT GLLOXSGZO\K J[Z_ UL IGXK IUTIKXTOTM ZNUYK ZNK YZGTJGXJ OY IRUYK ZU YZXOIZ ROGHOROZ_ LUX OTJO\OJ[GR IXOSKY% DNK (00( 9KJKXGR CKTZKTIOTM :[OJKROTKY GZOUTY L[XZNKX K^VGTJKJ ZNK ROGHOROZ_ UL H[YOTKYY KTZOZOKY GTJ LURRU]KJ ZNK LKJKXGR ZXKTJ UL VRGIOTM ZNK H[XJKT UL YKRL$VUROIOTM GTJ YKRL$ XKVUXZOTM [VUT H[YOTKYY UXMGTO GZOUTY% (

4 DNK 9KJKXGR CKTZKTIOTM :[OJKROTKY VRGIK G VXKSO[S UT H[YOTKYY UXMGTO GZOUTY NG\OTM OT VRGIK G IUXVUXGZK IUSVROGTIK VXUMXGS ]NOIN KYZGHROYNKY IUJKY UL IUTJ[IZ GTJ KLLKIZO\K KTLUXIKSKTZ UL ZNUYK IUJKY UL IUTJ[IZ% DNK :[OJKROTKY SGQK IRKGX ZNGZ IUXVUXGZOUTY ]NOIN NG\K IUSVROGTIK VXUMXGSY ]NOIN KLLKIZO\KR_ YKRL$VUROIK GTJ YKRL$XKVUXZ ]ORR XKIKO\K TUZ UTR_ RKYYKX IXOSOTGR VKTGRZOKY [VUT IUT\OIZOUT# H[Z GRYU YNU[RJ XKIKO\K LG\UXGHRK IUTYOJKXGZOUT ]NKT VXUYKI[ZUXOGR JKIOYOUTY GXK SGJK% FNKZNKX Y[IN JOYIXKZOUT OY# OT LGIZ# K^KXIOYKJ OY G SGZZKX UL S[IN JKHGZK% DNK HXUGJ Y]KKV UL IUXVUXGZK ROGHOROZ_ LUX GIZY UL GT_ GMKTZ UL ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT OT IUTP[TIZOUT ]OZN ZNK YUSKZOSKY JXGIUTOGT OSVGIZ UL IUXVUXGZK YKTZKTIOTM M[OJKROTKY SGQK OZ SGTJGZUX_ LUX IUXVUXGZK SGTGMKSKTZ ZU W[OIQR_ XKYVUTJ ZU GT_ GRRKMGZOUT UL ]XUTMJUOTM ]OZNOT ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT% 9H,HG>M=L LB? 1GN?KLCA;LCHG 4 VXUGIZO\K IROKTZ ]NKT IUTLXUTZKJ ]OZN GRRKMGZOUTY UL ]XUTMJUOTM ]ORR ]OYN ZU JKGR ]OZN ZNUYK GRRKMGZOUTY OT G JOXKIZ SGTTKX% 6UXVUXGZK SGTGMKSKTZ SG_ ]OYN ZU IUTJ[IZ OZY U]T OTJKVKTJKTZ OT\KYZOMGZOUT% DNOY ]KRR$SKGTOTM GIZ IGT RKGJ ZU SUXK YK\KXK INGXMKY UL UHYZX[IZOUT UL UL ZNK SUYZ JOLLOI[RZ XKYVUTYOHOROZOKY UL IUXVUXGZK IU[TYKR OY ZU SGQK IRKGX ZU SGTGMKSKTZ ZNGZ GT OTJKVKTJKTZ GTJ ZNUXU[MN OT\KYZOMGZOUT H_ IU[TYKR# GRZNU[MN [TVRKGYGTZ# OY ZNK UTR_ XKGYUTGHRK GVVXUGIN ]NKT IUTLXUTZKJ ]OZN GRRKMGZOUTY UL YKXOU[Y ]XUTMJUOTM% +>N;GL;A?K H@ 1GN?KLCA;LCHG FN_ YNU[RJ ZNK OT\KYZOMGZOUT HK IUTJ[IZKJ3 DNK IUTJ[IZ HKOTM OT\KYZOMGZKJ SG_ NG\K IO\OR UX IXOSOTGR XGSOLOIGZOUTY% 4 VXUVKXR_ IUTJ[IZKJ OT\KYZOMGZOUT ]ORR NKRV ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT ZU W[OIQR_ RKGXT ]NGZ NGVVKTKJ GTJ ]N_ OZ NGVVKTKJ% FNKXK ZNK GRRKMGZOUTY GXK XGOYKJ H_ G VUZKTZOGR VXO\GZK ROZOMGTZ# OZ OY OSVUXZGTZ ZU W[OIQR_ GYYKYY ZNK K^ZKTZ UL ZNK GRRKMKJ VXUHRKS GTJ ZU GJJXKYY ZNGZ VXUHRKS OT GT KLLUXZ ZU G\UOJ IO\OR ROGHOROZ_% <T ZNK IXOSOTGR IUTZK^Z# ZNK OT\KYZOMGZOUT SG_ GRRU] ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT ZU UHZGOT G T[SHKX UL HKTKLOZY% DNKYK HKTKLOZY OTIR[JK VUYYOHRK XKJ[IZOUT OT IXOSOTGR VKTGRZ_# \GXOU[Y RKTOKTI_ VXUMXGSY GTJ GMXKKSKTZY TUZ ZU VXUYKI[ZK% 4RZNU[MN ZNK 9KJKXGR CKTZKTIOTM :[OJKROTKY UTR_ VXU\OJK XKJ[IZOUTY OT LOTKY ]NKXK G IUXVUXGZK IUSVROGTIK VXUMXGS NGY HKKT OT VRGIK VXOUX ZU ZNK IXOSOTGR GIZO\OZ_ OT W[KYZOUT# MXKGZ JOYIXKZOUT OY MO\KT ZU VXUYKI[ZUXY ZU SGQK ZNK JKIOYOUT ]NKZNKX ZU ZNKYK JKIOYOUTY GXK OTLR[KTIKJ H_ ZNK ]G_ ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT JKGRY OTZKXTGRR_ ]OZN GRRKMGZOUTY UL ]XUTMJUOTM% DNK OTOZOGZOUT UL G ZNUXU[MN OTZKXTGR OT\KYZOMGZOUT ]OZN IUXXKIZOUT UL GT_ VXUHRKS GTJ JOYIOVROTGX_ GIZOUT ZGQKT ]OZN XKYVKIZ ZU GT_ ]XUTMJUOTM SG_ \KX_ ]KRR OT[XK ZU ZNK HKTKLOZ UL ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT ]NKT VXUYKI[ZUXOGR JKIOYOUTY GXK SGJK% -CK;>N;GL;A?K H@ 1GN?KLCA;LCHG 4T_ OTZKXTGR OT\KYZOMGZOUT GRYU XOYQY ZNK VUYYOHOROZ_ UL [TIU\KXOTM GJJOZOUTGR ]XUTMJUOTM UX OJKTZOL_OTM XKRK\GTZ JUI[SKTZY ]NOIN SG_ K\KTZ[GRR_ GOJ ZNK MU\KXTSKTZ UX G VXO\GZK ROZOMGTZ OT VXUYKI[ZOTM ZNKOX IRGOS GMGOTYZ ZNK IUXVUXGZOUT% )

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