THE APPLICATION OF THE COMPUTER IMAGE ANALYSIS METHODS IN ENVIRONMENTAL BIOMONITORING

Podobne dokumenty
Proposal of thesis topic for mgr in. (MSE) programme in Telecommunications and Computer Science

EXAMPLES OF CABRI GEOMETRE II APPLICATION IN GEOMETRIC SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH

Rozpoznawanie twarzy metodą PCA Michał Bereta 1. Testowanie statystycznej istotności różnic między jakością klasyfikatorów

QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF FINGERPRINT BIOMETRIC TEMPLATES

Fig 5 Spectrograms of the original signal (top) extracted shaft-related GAD components (middle) and

POLITECHNIKA WARSZAWSKA. Wydział Zarządzania ROZPRAWA DOKTORSKA. mgr Marcin Chrząścik

4. EKSPLOATACJA UKŁADU NAPĘD ZWROTNICOWY ROZJAZD. DEFINICJA SIŁ W UKŁADZIE Siła nastawcza Siła trzymania

Zakopane, plan miasta: Skala ok. 1: = City map (Polish Edition)

Akademia Morska w Szczecinie. Wydział Mechaniczny

STATISTICAL METHODS IN BIOLOGY

Forested areas in Cracow ( ) evaluation of changes based on satellite images 1 / 31 O

Metodyki projektowania i modelowania systemów Cyganek & Kasperek & Rajda 2013 Katedra Elektroniki AGH

Revenue Maximization. Sept. 25, 2018

The Overview of Civilian Applications of Airborne SAR Systems

Knovel Math: Jakość produktu

Latent Dirichlet Allocation Models and their Evaluation IT for Practice 2016

Zarządzanie sieciami telekomunikacyjnymi

Machine Learning for Data Science (CS4786) Lecture11. Random Projections & Canonical Correlation Analysis

Patients price acceptance SELECTED FINDINGS

Country fact sheet. Noise in Europe overview of policy-related data. Poland

Hard-Margin Support Vector Machines

PROCEEDINGS OF THE INSTITUTE OF VEHICLES 2(106)/2016 (12 pt)

Cracow University of Economics Poland. Overview. Sources of Real GDP per Capita Growth: Polish Regional-Macroeconomic Dimensions

Miedzy legenda a historia: Szlakiem piastowskim z Poznania do Gniezna (Biblioteka Kroniki Wielkopolski) (Polish Edition)

MaPlan Sp. z O.O. Click here if your download doesn"t start automatically

Streszczenie rozprawy doktorskiej

Instrukcja obsługi User s manual

Krytyczne czynniki sukcesu w zarządzaniu projektami

Helena Boguta, klasa 8W, rok szkolny 2018/2019

Wojewodztwo Koszalinskie: Obiekty i walory krajoznawcze (Inwentaryzacja krajoznawcza Polski) (Polish Edition)

photo graphic Jan Witkowski Project for exhibition compositions typography colors : : janwi@janwi.com


ROZPRAWY NR 128. Stanis³aw Mroziñski

Urbanek J., Jabłoński A., Barszcz T ssswedfsdfurbanek J., Jabłoński A., Barszcz T., Wykonanie pomiarów

DOI: / /32/37

SSW1.1, HFW Fry #20, Zeno #25 Benchmark: Qtr.1. Fry #65, Zeno #67. like

THEORETICAL STUDIES ON CHEMICAL SHIFTS OF 3,6 DIIODO 9 ETHYL 9H CARBAZOLE

Camspot 4.4 Camspot 4.5

Network Services for Spatial Data in European Geo-Portals and their Compliance with ISO and OGC Standards

TELEDETEKCJA ŚRODOWISKA dawniej FOTOINTERPRETACJA W GEOGRAFII. Tom 51 (2014/2)

DM-ML, DM-FL. Auxiliary Equipment and Accessories. Damper Drives. Dimensions. Descritpion

Conception of reuse of the waste from onshore and offshore in the aspect of


Auditorium classes. Lectures

POMIAR BIOKONCENTRACJI ZANIECZYSZCZEŃ W OCENIE SKAŻENIA ŚRODOWISKA, NARAŻENIA ORGANIZMÓW ORAZ PROGNOZOWANIU EKOLOGICZNYCH EFEKTÓW ZANIECZYSZCZEŃ

OPTYMALIZACJA PUBLICZNEGO TRANSPORTU ZBIOROWEGO W GMINIE ŚRODA WIELKOPOLSKA

INSPECTION METHODS FOR QUALITY CONTROL OF FIBRE METAL LAMINATES IN AEROSPACE COMPONENTS

EDYTA KATARZYNA GŁAŻEWSKA METALOPROTEINAZY ORAZ ICH TKANKOWE INHIBITORY W OSOCZU OSÓB CHORYCH NA ŁUSZCZYCĘ LECZONYCH METODĄ FOTOTERAPII UVB.

Domy inaczej pomyślane A different type of housing CEZARY SANKOWSKI

AKADEMIA MORSKA W SZCZECINIE WYDZIAŁ MECHANICZNY ROZPRAWA DOKTORSKA. mgr inż. Piotr Smurawski

European Crime Prevention Award (ECPA) Annex I - new version 2014

Wojewodztwo Koszalinskie: Obiekty i walory krajoznawcze (Inwentaryzacja krajoznawcza Polski) (Polish Edition)


Oceny oddziaływania na stan wód w rozumieniu RDW, a inne instrumenty oceny oddziaływania na środowisko

UMOWY WYPOŻYCZENIA KOMENTARZ

Compatible cameras for NVR-5000 series Main Stream Sub stream Support Firmware ver. 0,2-1Mbit yes yes yes n/d

Karpacz, plan miasta 1:10 000: Panorama Karkonoszy, mapa szlakow turystycznych (Polish Edition)

DUAL SIMILARITY OF VOLTAGE TO CURRENT AND CURRENT TO VOLTAGE TRANSFER FUNCTION OF HYBRID ACTIVE TWO- PORTS WITH CONVERSION

Politechnika Krakowska im. Tadeusza Kościuszki. Karta przedmiotu. obowiązuje studentów rozpoczynających studia w roku akademickim 2014/2015

Instructions for student teams

Presented by. Dr. Morten Middelfart, CTO

Ocena wpływu nasilenia objawów zespołu nadpobudliwości psychoruchowej na masę ciała i BMI u dzieci i młodzieży

Weronika Mysliwiec, klasa 8W, rok szkolny 2018/2019

Ocena potrzeb pacjentów z zaburzeniami psychicznymi

Selection of controller parameters Strojenie regulatorów

Wykaz linii kolejowych, które są wyposażone w urządzenia systemu ETCS

POLITECHNIKA ŚLĄSKA INSTYTUT AUTOMATYKI ZAKŁAD SYSTEMÓW POMIAROWYCH

ROZPRAWA DOKTORSKA. Model obliczeniowy ogrzewań mikroprzewodowych

DELTIM Sp. z o.o. S.K.A ul. Rząsawska 30/38; Częstochowa. Bumper bar X-Lander X-Move

Wykaz linii kolejowych, które są wyposażone w urzadzenia systemu ETCS

Formularz recenzji magazynu. Journal of Corporate Responsibility and Leadership Review Form

TYRE PYROLYSIS. REDUXCO GENERAL DISTRIBUTOR :: ::

Analysis of Movie Profitability STAT 469 IN CLASS ANALYSIS #2

Institutional Determinants of IncomeLevel Convergence in the European. Union: Are Institutions Responsible for Divergence Tendencies of Some

INSTYTUT GENETYKI I HODOWLI ZWIERZĄT POLSKIEJ AKADEMII NAUK W JASTRZĘBCU. mgr inż. Ewa Metera-Zarzycka

METODA OGÓLNEJ OCENY STANU ŚRODO- WISKA OBSZARÓW WIEJSKICH NA PODSTAWIE INFORMACJI Z BANKU DANYCH REGIONALNYCH GUS I OSZACOWAŃ PROGRAMU EMEP

SubVersion. Piotr Mikulski. SubVersion. P. Mikulski. Co to jest subversion? Zalety SubVersion. Wady SubVersion. Inne różnice SubVersion i CVS

Stargard Szczecinski i okolice (Polish Edition)

Dominika Janik-Hornik (Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny w Katowicach) Kornelia Kamińska (ESN Akademia Górniczo-Hutnicza) Dorota Rytwińska (FRSE)

Unit of Social Gerontology, Institute of Labour and Social Studies ageing and its consequences for society

Testy jednostkowe - zastosowanie oprogramowania JUNIT 4.0 Zofia Kruczkiewicz

Warsztaty Ocena wiarygodności badania z randomizacją

XXIII Konferencja Naukowa POJAZDY SZYNOWE 2018

Filozofia z elementami logiki Klasyfikacja wnioskowań I część 2

Rev Źródło:

Tychy, plan miasta: Skala 1: (Polish Edition)

ERASMUS + : Trail of extinct and active volcanoes, earthquakes through Europe. SURVEY TO STUDENTS.

SYNTEZA SCENARIUSZY EKSPLOATACJI I STEROWANIA

Evaluation of the main goal and specific objectives of the Human Capital Operational Programme

Cracow University of Economics Poland

TECHNOLOGIE OCHRONY ŚRODOWISKA (studia I stopnia) Derywatyzacja w analizie środowiskowej zanieczyszczeń typu jony metali i jony metaloorganiczne

Wprowadzenie do programu RapidMiner, część 5 Michał Bereta

Bow terminals Zaciski szynowe

Jazz EB207S is a slim, compact and outstanding looking SATA to USB 2.0 HDD enclosure. The case is

Uniwersytet Medyczny w Łodzi. Wydział Lekarski. Jarosław Woźniak. Rozprawa doktorska

ROZPRAWA DOKTORSKA. Mateusz Romanowski

Wprowadzenie do programu RapidMiner, część 2 Michał Bereta 1. Wykorzystanie wykresu ROC do porównania modeli klasyfikatorów

Mgr Paweł Musiał. Promotor Prof. dr hab. n. med. Hanna Misiołek Promotor pomocniczy Dr n. med. Marek Tombarkiewicz

Wojewodztwo Koszalinskie: Obiekty i walory krajoznawcze (Inwentaryzacja krajoznawcza Polski) (Polish Edition)

Lek. Ewelina Anna Dziedzic. Wpływ niedoboru witaminy D3 na stopień zaawansowania miażdżycy tętnic wieńcowych.

Transkrypt:

PIOTR LEWICKI, ROBERT MAZUR, KAMIL KASZTALSKI ** THE APPLICATION OF THE COMPUTER IMAGE ANALYSIS METHODS IN ENVIRONMENTAL BIOMONITORING ZASTOSOWANIE METOD KOMPUTEROWEJ ANALIZY OBRAZU W BIOMONITORINGU RODOWISKA A b s t r a c t Intensive development of computer techniques in the area of optics, optoelectronics and computer image analysis methods make scientific premises for the implementation of these solutions in other scientific disciplines. The application of image analysis in image diagnostics in medicine is at the moment on a high level of technological development and crucial in a proper medical diagnosis. The methods of image processing and analysis are developed, among others in: photogrammetry, geomatics, remote sensing, in GIS systems, in the analysis of the spectra of scanners, sonars, echo-sonars, photo-radars, in studying structures of materials, ground, etc. [1 3]. Unfortunately, there are still very few applications for the methods in the environmental protection and biomonitoring mentioned above. Most studies, apart from chemical analytics, are connected with the application of classic research methods based on visual observation [4, 5]. Thus it is so important to develop co-operation and studies on the possibility of the implementation of automatic methods based on computer image analysis in this field. Keywords: computer image analysis methods, image processing, automation S t r e s z c z e n i e Intensywny rozwój technik komputerowych w dziedzinie optyki, optoelektroniki oraz metod komputerowej analizy obrazu stwarza przesłanki naukowe dla wdra ania tych rozwi za w innych dziedzinach nauki. Zastosowanie analizy obrazu w diagnostyce obrazowej z zakresu medycyny znajduj si obecnie na wysokim stopniu rozwoju technologicznego i s wr cz nie zb dne dla prawidłowej diagnozy prowadzonej przez pracowników medycznych. Metody obróbki i przetwarzania obrazu s rozwijane np. w zakresie: Fotogrametrii, Geomatyki, Teledetekcji w systemach GIS, w analizie widm skanerów, sonarów, echosond, fotoradarów, w badaniu struktury materiałów, podło a, itd. [1 3]. Niestety nadal bardzo mało jest zastosowa dla ww. metod w zakresie ochrony rodowiska oraz w biomonitoringu. Wi kszo bada poza analityk chemiczn wi e si tu z wykorzystaniem metod badawczych klasycznych opartych na obserwacji wizualnej [4, 5]. Dlatego tak wa ne jest rozwijanie współpracy oraz bada nad mo liwo ci wdro e metod automatycznych opartych o komputerow analiz obrazu w tej dziedzinie. Słowa kluczowe: metody komputerowej analizy obrazu, przetwarzanie obrazu, automatyzacja PhD. Piotr Lewicki, Institute of Applied Informatics, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Cracow University of Technology. PhD. Robert Mazur, PhD. Kamil Kasztalski, AGH Uniwersity of Science and Technology, Cracow.

168 1. Introduction Recently, an intensive development of biological environmental monitoring methods has been observed [6]. The assessment of toxicity of samples taken from the environment requires a proper selection of a bioindicator [7], i.e. the organism particularly sensitive to specific pollutants and a toxic effect should include unambiguously interpretable symptoms [8]. Most biotests are based on classic methods involving visual observation. The researcher records and interprets the symptoms resulting from a toxic impact of pollutants on the indicator organisms. The development of new methods is mainly based on looking for new bioindicators or sensitive biological material (enzymes, physiological reactions etc.) [9, 10]. There are very few studies in the automation of classic methods to eliminate errors resulting from subjective records. Particular scientific premises are given here by the possibility of application of computer image analysis methods [11]. In many cases this would make it possible to objectively assess the analysis of toxicity of the studied sample. The attempts to make engineering projects, e.g. construct instruments for biotests are only possible if proper methods of image analysis are implemented to correctly assess toxic influence on the used bioindicator organisms. Just the assessment of proper image analysis procedures of the studied biological material makes the modified method semi-automatic [12]. The computer records the changes and marks the character of these changes; both qualitative and quantitative. Such solutions allow the quantified and objective assessment of the state of the studied material. The examples of such applications of computer analysis in biotests can be macroprograms in the Aphelion environment [11]: 1. Following the changes of the withdrawal of tentacles in Hydra vulgaris. In this method the compactness coefficient was applied as the measure in defining the toxic influence of the examined pollutants on these coelenterates. The selection of a coefficient describing the changes: 16S COMPACTNESS (1) L 2 where: L the object perimeter in the image points, S the number of points belonging to the object. This coefficient is included in the interval (0.1 > and takes value 1 for the ideal square. Such a definition was applied due to the fact that discrete geometry is used in the program. The constructed macro is extremely useful in on-line monitoring and gives satisfactory effects in defining toxic concentration of the studied pollutants. 1. The algorithm was prepared in two versions: the version for the analysis of a single image, the version for the automatic analysis of a series of images [11]. 2. The measurement of the area of the common duckweed Lemna minor leaves. Two versions of the algorithm for the macroprogram were prepared: the version for the analysis of a single image, the version for the automatic analysis of a series of images.

169 The created tool using techniques of computer image analysis meets all the established requirements: it returns a repetitive result the measurement error does not exceed 4.4% of the measured value, it is simple in use, it is relatively inexpensive [11]. 3. Studies of changes of the mean velocity in the test population of Daphnia magna [12] exposed to the selected toxin. 4. Detection of the movement of embryos in cocoons of Lymnaea stagnalis exposed to specific toxins [4, 5]. 5. Recognition of individuals in the population of Daphnia magna in the fluotox test and detection of individuals showing fluorescence at the exposure to the UV. The comparative assessment of the influence of the Brij group detergent on Lemna minor was made. The macroprogram written earlier for the measurement of the duckweed area was adjusted to experimental conditions. One should notice that measurement of the area by a standard (planimetric) method is very time- and work-consuming, and generates errors due to inadequacy of manual measurements). The studies carried out by means of the method of image analysis gave very accurate results, and did not require additional timeand work-consuming measurements. 1.1. Methods 1. Different dilutions of the Brij 58 detergent solutions were made in a geometric sequence with coefficient q = 1.25. 2. Populations of Lemna minor were introduced into every tray with the solution test, 10 individuals per each tray. Every test group was represented in 3 repetitions. 3. The images for each test group of Lemna minor were made (preserving constant, and established camera and distance options). 4. Every image was analysed in the Aphelion program and the obtained results made the mean area of the whole test population given in pixels (the macroprogram version for automatic analysis of the series of images was applied). 5. The program returns the results in the calculation sheet Excel. 6. The exposure to the effect of the toxicant in defined concentrations lasted 3 weeks, the images for each test group were taken in 5 measurement series. 7. The obtained results were compared within the groups, between the groups and with the control. The experiment was carried out in strictly controlled conditions, with the regime of the same parameters during photographing of each Lemna minor group. The possibility of evaporation of water from the solutions was prevented by covering all the trays with a glass sheet, not limiting access to the light, needed for vegetation. 1.2. Results Data in Table 1 present mean values of the area of the whole test population calculated for each test group represented in 3 repetitions. The result is given in pixels, thus it was very important to keep the same camera parameters of taking the images.

170 T a b l e 1 The measurement results (in pixels) of the mean area of the test Lemna minor population (3 repetitions), exposed to different concentrations of Brij 58 Concentration mg/l Series 1 Series 2 Series 3 Series 4 Series 5 A 44.00 5859.11 6068.33 6580.78 6644.22 7337.89 B 55.00 7711.29 8272.56 8102.56 8834.33 9633.11 C 68.75 6803.78 7467.00 7871.78 8067.89 8959.56 D 85.94 5981.00 5435.44 6582.44 6489.78 7169.67 E 107.42 4766.22 5277.56 5664.33 5686.33 6220.36 F 134.28 5011.67 5232.78 5557.78 5946.00 6496.50 G 167.85 5986.44 5456.33 5633.67 5839.22 6443.47 H 209.81 4901.22 4920.00 5224.44 5410.33 6208.11 I 262.26 5493.11 5587.22 6029.28 6734.00 7368.44 J 327.83 5663.39 5967.56 6287.00 7270.67 8065.89 K 409.78 6241.39 6691.33 7064.67 7539.22 8070.11 Control 0 5718.28 6154.56 6356.69 7058.33 7741.16 Area in pixels 10000,00 9000,00 8000,00 7000,00 6000,00 5000,00 4000,00 3000,00 2000,00 1000,00 0,00 A B C D E F G H I J K Con. toxicant concentration mg/l Series1 Series2 Series3 Series4 Series5 Fig. 1. The graph: the results of the mean area for all studied groups in 5 measurement series Rys. 1. Wykres: zestawienie wyników redniego pola powierzchni dla wszystkich badanych grup w 5 seriach pomiarowych

171 12000,00 10000,00 Area in pixels 8000,00 6000,00 4000,00 2000,00 0,00 A B C D E F G H I J K Con. toxicant concentration mg/l Series1 Series2 Series3 Series4 Series5 Fig. 2. The cumulated graph of: mean values of the area in each measurement series Rys. 2. Skumulowany wykres: redniej warto ci pola powierzchni w ka dej serii pomiarowej Growth in percentage % 500% 450% 400% 350% 300% 250% 200% 150% 100% 50% 0% A B C D E F G H I J K Con. Studied test groups Fig. 3. Dynamics of the growth in each test group within 5 measurement series Rys. 3. Dynamika przyrostu w ka dej grupie testowej w obr bie 5 serii pomiarowych 1.3. Discussion of the Results The analysis of measurement results within all the groups shows the growth of the surface area in each group. This is caused by the fact that applied concentrations of the Brij 58 detergent are not toxic for Lemna minor. Compared to the control there is a lack of

172 significant differences in growth dynamics for each test group. Each test population is characterized by the growth in time. One can plan subsequent experiments connected with the increase of concentration of the studied surfactant to determine a toxic concentration for Lemna minor, analysing dynamics of the growth of the studied water populations. The experiment carried out proves that the applied measurement tool correctly recognizes objects of Lemna minor. The result is the area for each test group. The macroprogram analyses the series of images from the defined catalogue, the obtained data are returned in an Excel calculation sheet. This makes a rich database, used in further statistic analyses referring to the studied objects. Because the difference between a single and serial version is only such that the images contained in one catalogue are cyclically processed by the algorithm for a single image, and the results are put in the calculation sheet only a single algorithm, as presenting the main idea of the analysis will be presented in detail. Below, in Fig. 4, the block scheme was presented for the created algorithm [11]. The algorithm starts from uploading the analysed image. Then a median filter is applied to reduce the noise. The next stage is transformation of the coloured image into a monochromatic one. The image is divided into RGB components. For further analysis a blue component was applied, because it gave the greatest contrast of the duckweed. In the next step the black top hat filter is applied to contrast the objects better. Then binarization is made (corrected entropy threshold) and small elements (much smaller than the duckweed plants, treated as noise) are removed image erosion + image reconstruction. The next phase is determining the region where the duckweed is. At this stage all the stuff prepared during the image acquisition has been used. The duckweed is in a round breaker whose edge is marked with a black lining (Fig. 5). Rys. 4. Schemat blokowy algorytmu detekcji rz sy Fig. 4. The block scheme of the duckweed detection algorithm Namely, this edge is used for determination of the circle within which the studied objects are found. After determining the region interesting to researchers, the surface area and the containing elements are calculated. The next action is making the outline of the objects recognized by the program to verify the correctness of their recognition by the user and giving the result [11].

173 Fig. 5. The image of the analysed object (tray with the Lemna minor population, the edge is marked black) Rys. 5. Zdj cie analizowanego obiektu (szalka z populacj Lemna minor z zaczernionym brzegiem) Fig. 6. Analysis process, according to the detection algorithm Rys. 6. Proces analizy zgodnie z algorytmem detekcji 2. Conclusions The new method gives promising results. It significantly increases the speed and accuracy of the analysis carried out. The modified biotest with the application of the computer image analysis is a semiautomatic method and makes is possible to make fully automatic instruments.

174 The repetitiveness of the results was on the level of 4.4%. In biological test the accepted error is in the confidence level of 0.05. As has been presented, the application of computer image analysis brings new measurement opportunities in the biotests applied so far. The application of computer image analysis methods supplements the biological tests with a possibility of studying parameters that used to be difficult to measure. Thus computer image analysis is a scientific discipline whose application in biotests can be a powerful tool to increase sensitivity and objectivity of these methods in water quality assessment. R e f e r e n c e s [1] W o j n a r L., K u r z y d ł o w s k i K.J., S z a l a J., Praktyka analizy obrazu, Polskie Towarzystwo Stereologiczne, Kraków 2002. [2] W o j n a r L., M a j o r e k M., Komputerowa analiza obraz, Fotobit Design, Kraków 1994. [3] W o j n a r L., T siorow s k i M., G dek A., Z a r z y c k a M., J a s i e w i c z B., K cki W., Zastosowanie kliniczne ilo ciowej oceny regeneratu kostnego na zdj ciach rentgenowskich, Przegl d lekarski, sup. Nr 4, 2002. [4] M a z u r R., L e w i c k i P., Application of the Computer Image Analyses in the Embryotests as a New Method of Water Biomonitoring, Polish Jorunal of Environmental Studies, Vol. 17, No. 3A, Olsztyn 2008, 409-412. [5] M a z u r R., L e w i c k i P., Zastosowanie metod analizy obrazu w testach toksyczno- ci ostrej na Lymnaea stagnalis L Materiały konferencyjne, III Krakowska Konferencja Młodych Uczonych, Fundacja Studentów i Absolwentów Akademii Górniczo- -Hutniczej Academica, Kraków 2008, 299-304. [6] M a z u r R., Rozprawa Doktorska, Monitoring wybranych zanieczyszcze wód przy zastosowaniu nowych kryteriów ekotoksykologicznych, AGH, Kraków 2008. [7] K u c z y ska A., W o l s k a L., N a m i e nik J., Zastosowanie biotestów w badaniach rodowiskowych, Nowe Horyzonty w Analityce i Monitoringu rodowiska, CDAiM (CEEAM), Gda sk 2003. [7] W a l k e r C.H., H o p k i n S.P., S i b l y R.M., P e a k a l l D.B., Podstawy ekotoksykologii, PWN, Warszawa 2002. [8] D o b r o w o l s k i J., D o m i n i k J.W., W g n e r A., P a r d o s M., Benninghoff Ch., Testy Biologiczne i Badania Chemiczne w Monitoringu Ekologicznym rodowiska Wodnego, Chemia rodowiskowa wiczenia i seminaria, Szczepaniec-Ci ciak E., Ko cielniak P., cz. 2, Wyd. UJ, Kraków 1999. [9] D o b r o w o l s k i W., Biotechnologia proekologiczna kluczem do unowocze nienia in ynierii rodowiska, J. In ynieria rodowiska. Tom 6, Zeszyt 2. 2001. [10] L e w i c k i P., Komputerowa analiza obrazu w wybranych biotestach dla oceny jako- ci wód, rozprawa doktorska, AGH, Kraków 2006. [11] M a z u r R., K a w a R., L e w i c k i P., The monitoring of selected pollutants of waters with the application of the selected eco-toxicological criteria, Polish Jorunal of Environmental Studies, Vol. 16, No. 3B, Olsztyn 2007, s. 334-338.