5RLRQO0RLRQ,Q1HRQLQ0HFKQLFV1HRQV/VRI0RLRQGHVFLEHKHG\QPLFVRIREMHFV XQGHJRLQJQVOLRQ7KLVLVOVRKHFVHLKRLRQV7RSRFHHGHSSRSLHO\ HGHILQHKLVFOOHGIRFHQFFHOHLRQHFLQHPVRIQJXOTXQLLHV KHHE\LYLQJFRHFO\KHQORJRXVOVRIPRLRQIRRLRQV 6LKGHILQLLRQVQGNLQHPLFVQGKHQGLVFXVVKHG\QPLFV &RQVLGHRQO\REMHFVKHLJLGERGLHVQGRHERXIL[HG[LVRIRLRQVXFK KIRKHPRPHQQVOLRQVHLJQRHG &RQVLGHPVVHOHPHQLQFRXQHFORFNLVHRLQJREMHF,QVHHSLQJKRXJKKHQJXOGLVSOFHPHQT LQQPRXQRILPH PVVRQKHGLVNLOORHLKQQJXOYHORFL\ T SRLQ
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
$QJXO$FFHOHLRQ,I LVLQFHVLQJLQPJQLXGHHKYHQQJXOFFHOHLRQ 7KHGLHFLRQRI LVIRFRXQHFORFNLVHRLQJREMHFLKQLQFHVLQJQJXO YHORFL\JLYHQE\KH5+5VEHLQJRXRIKHSJH,IIRKHFRXQHFORFNLVHRLRQ LVGHFHVLQJLQPJQLXGHKHQ LVEFN LQRKHSJH 7KHXQLVRI HGLQVSHVHFRQGVTXHG V 6 T 9 7QJHQLO 7QJHQLO &HQLSHOFFHOHLRQLV 9
$QJXOYHORFL\VSHHG T T T,QVQQHRXVQJXOYHORFL\ G GT T OLP $QJXOFFHOHLRQ,QVQQHRXVQJXOFFHOHLRQ G G OLP 7QVOLRQYLEOHÍ Î RLRQYLEOHHOLRQV T 6 9 7QJHQLO 7QJHQLO 9
&RQVQQJXOFFHOHLRQNLQHPLFHTXLRQV 7KHNLQHPLFHTXLRQVHIRXQGHLKHE\VXEVLXLQJKHERYHQVOLRQYLEOH ÍÎRLRQYLEOHTXQLLHVLQRKHQVOLRQNLQHPLFHTXLRQVRE\QORJ\ Y Y Y T T!! [ [ Y Y!! T [ 7KHVHHTXLRQVFQEHXVHGRFTXLHQJXONLQHPLFLQIRPLRQERXSREOHP,QFRQMXQFLRQLKRLRQOIRPRI1HRQV6HFRQG/KHRLRQNLQHPLF SPHHVHXVHGLQPXFKKHVPH\VHHKHQVOLRQNLQHPLFSPHHV
5RLRQO0RLRQ\QPLFV 7KHRLRQOIRPRI1HRQV " # /HTXLHVRNLQJGHILQLLRQVIRQJXOIRFHV R7RTXHVQGIRQJXOPVVLHRLRQOLQHL 5RLRQOLQHLLVQREMHFVHVLVQFHREHLQJQJXOO\FFHOHHGQGLVXQOLNH QVOLRQLQHLLQKKHQQREMHFLVRLQJERXQ[LVRIRLRQLLVXVXOO\ QLHJXOO\VKSHGRH[HQGHGREMHFKFQQREHHHGVSRLQOLNH 0RPHQRI,QHLLVFHH2EMHFV 7KHPRPHQRILQHLIRV\VHPRISLFOHVLKPVVHV PL HFKSHSHQGLFXO GLVQFH L \IRPKH[LVRIRLRQLVGHILQHGVKHVXPRIKHSRGXFRIKHVH PVVHVQGKHVTXHRIKHSHSHQGLFXOGLVQFHIRPKHRLRQ[LV, P %, P P P P 0RPHQRI,QHL&RQLQXRXV2EMHFV,,QKHGLVFHHPVVHVFVHHKYHKHVXPPLRQ P ) ) H[HQGHGPVVKHVXPPLRQEHFRPHVQLQHJO P( ( o ( ³ GP LQHJLRQLVRYHLQILQLHVLPOPVVHOHPHQVLQKHLJLGERG\ )RFRQLQXRXV QG 3OOHO$[LV7KHRHP 7KHPRPHQRILQHLHVXOIRKHVOEERXLVFRQH[LVFRXOGKYHEHHQIRXQGOVR XVLQJKHSOOHO[LVKHRHP 7KHPRPHQRILQHLRIQREMHFERXQ[LVSOOHORQ[LVRIRLRQKRXJK KHREMHF&20QGORFHGSHSHQGLFXOGLVQFHGIRPKH&20[LVLV, 3OOHO B $[LV, &20 0G
5RLRQO)RFH7RTXH/LQIR7LV &RQVLGHKHKLQJHVRIGRRVYHLFO[LVRIRLRQIRKHGRR,QSSO\LQJ IRFHRKHGRRSXVKLQJRQLIRH[PSOHKHQLIKIRFHLVGLHFO\RQKHKLQJHVRI KHGRRKHHLVQRRLRQ,IKRHYHOHYHPLVXVHGQGHSXVKKHGRRKH NQREKHQHFQQJXOO\FFHOHHKHGRRERXLVKLQJH[LVRIRLRQ 7RTXHLVKHSRGXFRIH[HQOIRFHLKOHYHPGLVQFHIRPKH[LVRIRLRQ ) H[ ^ ` / A 7KHOHYHPGLVQFHLVKHSHSHQGLFXOGLVQFHIRKH[LVRIRLRQRKH OLQHRIVLJKRIKHSSOLHGIRFH %HIRHORRNLQJVRPHH[PSOHVQRLFH 6,XQLVRI7RTXHH1PKLFKLVQRFOOHG-RXOHLQKLVFRQH[ 7RTXHVHYHFRTXQLLHVKRVHPJQLXGHQGVLJQHJLYHQE\KH FRVVSRGXFGHILQLLRQRIRTXH u ) QG5+5 )RPQ;<SOQHSHVSHFLYHQGVVXPLQJKHREMHFLVHVKHQIRFHV KRXOGHVXOLQFRXQHFORFNLVHRLRQVRIQREMHFFRHVSRQGR SRVLLYHRTXHVQGIRFHVHVXOLQJLQFORFNLVHRLRQVHNHQV QHJLYHRTXHV7KLVHSHVHQVLJQFRQYHQLRQIRRTXHV
$[LVRI5RLRQ _ G*+, ^ ) H[ G 7RS ` )-./ /LQHRI6LJKIR)012 G345546 T6 T6 )789 G:;<<;= LVKHSHSHQGLFXOGLVQFHIRPKH[LVRIRLRQRKHOLQHRIVLJKRI)>?@ ^ ) H[ G %RRP ` 1RLFHKHIROORLQJ GABC LVQRHTXORG EFFEG 9HIJ!9K LMMLN )OPQ R ST ) VX Y [XX[\ LQPJQLXGH G]^_ 6LQT6 G`^aa^b &KQJLQJKHRLHQLRQRI)cde HOLYHRKHEHP[LVFKQJHVKHOHYHPQG HGXFHVKHRTXHE\IFR6LQT6,IT6LV]HRGHJHHVKHQ9LV]HR
7RTXHQG9HFR&RVV3RGXFV u ) ) _ 6LQT 5+5 7KHRLRQOIRPRI1HRQVf g /LV 1H B ([, ([PSOH/HPVVPKQJIRPRSHRIQHJOLJLEOHPVVRXQGERXSXOOH\ RIPVV0)LQGKHFFHOHLRQRIP 0 7 7 P PJ
7 PJ P 7 PJ P )RKHSXOOH\PVV0 7 VLQ, 7,, h (TXLQJKHRQGXVLQJ, j klm 0 i HFQLH, n P PJ P 0 PJ PJ P 0 )RKH]HRPVVSXOOH\HJH JVH[SHFHG 7, o PJ 0 P 0 ½ ¾
PJ P 0 $IHIOOLQJLPH KHQJXOYHORFL\LV QGKHGLVNNLQHLFHQHJ\LV.,, ^ ` PJ 0 P 0 ½ ¾ (TXLOLELXP )RKHVLFRHTXLOLELXPSSOLFLRQVHTXLHKOOQVOLRQFFHOHLRQV QGRLRQOFFHOHLRQVEHLGHQLFOO\]HR 1H B ([ ) 1H B ([ ; ) 1H B ([ < ) 1H B ([ = 7KHVHHTXLRQVRIVLFHTXLOLELXPVXSSO\XVLKVHYHOHOLRQVIRPKLFKH P\GHHPLQHKHFRQGLLRQVXQGHKLFKKHV\VHPHPLQVVLF 1RLFHKV\VHPP\EHLQPRLRQLKXQLIRPYHORFL\QGVLOOVLVI\KHVH FRQGLLRQV7KLVLVQRQVLFHTXLOLELXP
5ROOLQJ0RLRQ $GLVNROOVLKRXVOLSSLQJGRQQLQFOLQHGSOQHHHPLQHLVILQOYHORFL\KH ERRPRIKHSOQHILVXVLQJHQHJ\PHKRGVQGKHQLK1HRQVq r / 7KHFRQVLQRIROOLQJLKRXVOLSSLQJOORVXVRLHIRKHGLVNGLVSOFHPHQ ORQJKHLQFOLQH ; 6 T 9HORFL\RIQVOLRQLV9stu x + ( ( I T6 PJ+ v v P9, 9 &RP x PJ+ w w 9 ½ x P9, ¾ :KLFKXSRQXVLQJ,y z{ 0 PJ+ } } } 9 ½ P9 P ¾ PJ+ 9 ~ ½ 9 P P¾ J+
6PHSREOHPXVLQJ1HRQV / < ; + 1 I P2 1 PJT6 7KHRTXHKHSRLQRIFRQFLV T6 I V, Iƒ,,Q; PJ6LQ T I V P PJ6LQ T, 8VLQJ, ˆ 0 P PJ6LQT P P J6LQT Œ 9 Š 9 ; + J6LQT 6LQ T 9Ž J+
&RPELQHG7QVOLRQQG5RLRQ )RROOLQJLKRXVOLSSLQJLPYHORFLLHVGXHRKHRLRQGGVRKHKHHO QVOLRQ&20YHORFL\ 5ROOLQJ)LFLRQ,IVXIFHVLQFRQFIRROOLQJPRLRQHQRSHIHFO\VPRRKKHQKHQRPOIRFH KVYLEOHORFLRQKP\EHRII[LVQGKHHIRHSRGXFHRTXHRQKHKHHO &RHIILFLHQVRIROOLQJILFLRQHSSR[LPHO\ IRXEEHLHVRQSYHPHQ
:RN.LQHLF(QHJ\7KHRHPIR5RLRQV 7KHRNNLQHLFHQHJ\KHRHPOVRLQFOXGHVRLRQONLQHLFHQHJLHVQGRTXHV ) T6 ; :.,, )RFH ) LVSSOLHGRYHQFOHQJK LV 6 T VRKHOHIKQGVLGHRIKHKHRHP ) T )XKH ) QG HLJKQJOHVLPSO\LQJKHRTXH u ) LVMXVHTXOR ) _ QGKHRNGRQHLQKHRLRQOFVHLV : T T T I L )RFRQVQRTXH 7KHSRHRHKLFK ) LVGRLQJRNLV 3 : T 3 x 5HFOOKH ) x9 IRPRIQVOLRQG\QPLFV
$QJXO0RPHQXP 7KHQJXOPRPHQXPRIQREMHFERXRLRQ[LVLV /, 1HRQV š /LV ) 7KHRLRQHTXLRQLV 3 /,IOOH[HQORTXHVHLGHQLFOO\]HRKHQ 0HQLQJQJXOPRPHQXPLVFRQVHYHG /, LVFRQVQLQLPH / œ /,QKHEVHQFHRIQHH[HQORTXHVQJXOPRPHQXPLVFRQVHYHG, œ œ, 6LQFH u ) KHQ u ) $QG 3 / u *LYLQJ / u 3 VQRKH\RFOFXOHQJXOPRPHQXP
S PY $QJXOPRPHQXPLVKHSRGXFRIKHSLFOHVPRPHQXP PXOLSOLHG E\KHSHSHQGLFXOGLVQFHIRPKHSRLQRIREVHYLRQRKHPRPHQXPYHFROLQH RIVLJK S PY A 2 )RV\VHPVRISLFOHVHKYHKHYHFRVXP / OŸ Ož O / ^O O O ` 7KHHRIFKQJHRIV\VHPQJXOPRPHQXPLVKHYHFRVXPRIRTXHVRQLV LQGLYLGXOSLFOHV ª / ([PSOH $RGRIPVV.JQGOHQJKPKVRLRQOLQHLRINJP «3LYRLQJ ERXLVRSHQGKHERRPHQGRIKHRGFROOLGHVLQFRPSOHHO\LQHOVLFFROOLVLRQ LK.JSX\G,IKHQJXOYHORFL\EHIRHKHFROOLVLRQVGV KHQILQGKHILQOQJXOVSHHGRIKHV\VHPIHKHFROOLVLRQ
6LQFHKHSLYRSRLQLVIL[HGH[HQOIRFHVIRPKHFROOLVLRQFKHHLPSO\LQJ]HR OHYHPIRRTXHVERXKSRLQ7KHHIRHHFRQVHYHQJXOPRPHQXP / / I,, I I NJ x P x V > NJ x P @ ³ ² ± V I V
*\RVFRSHVQG3HFHVVLRQ :LKQLQLLOQJXOPRPHQXPYHFRORQJKH[[LVKH G/ SRGXFHGE\RTXH IRPKHHLJKYHFRVHVXSSHFHVVLRQERXKH][LV 1RLFHKLIKHJ\RVFRSHLVQRLQLLOO\VSLQQLQJKHHLJKYHFRRTXHRHVKH J\RVFRSHERXKH\[LVLQRKHEOHRS 7KHSHFHVVLRQH : LV : GI G _ G/ G / _ /, 5SLGO\VSLQQLQJJ\RVFRSHVKHHIRHKYHVORSHFHVVLRQHV